Software
Houzz Logo Print
nkm56

How long does it take?

19 years ago

I see the pictures of other people's ponds with their fish swimming around, and that soothing image is exactly why I decided to install a pond. However, my koi almost never come out of hiding. I rocked up some areas on the sides of my pond so that they could have a few "caves" to hide in from predators, but since seeing a heron nearby I decided to go ahead and net the pond. Combined with the scarecrow water cannon, I feel they are as safe as I can make them without putting solid walls and a ceiling around the pond.

I've had them for nearly two months now, and I would have thought that would be ample time for them to adjust to their new surroundings. I have six butterfly koi, about five inches long, and one regular koi about seven inches long.

A man who has goldfish in his shaded patio pond told me he had to remove the rocks and therefore deny them their hiding places, and now they rush to the surface to greet visitors and beg for food. I'm reluctant to remove their hiding places because my pond gets about four hours of hot afternoon sun and it gives them a cool place to go. But I would like to see them now and then! They don't even want to come out for mealtime. They wait me out until I give up and go back in the house. If I look out the window, I can see the turbulance as they gobble up the food.

Eventually, they will be too big to all fit in the caves at the same time, but for now, if I'm lucky, I'll see a fin waving near the opening, and that's the only clue I have that there are fish in there. Does anyone have any advice? My fish are apparently terrified of me. If they happen to be swimming around when I go outside, they take one look at me and dive for their hiding places! How long does it take for them to adjust?

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago

    I'm no fish expert, but I would think your fish would have gotten used to you by now. Personally I wouldn't eliminate the caves, that's not the solution, and it does give them a place to retreat, esp. with a heron nearby. Are you perhaps standing next to the pond when you feed them? We've noticed that our fish won't feed at all when we do that, so we have to step back and sit at our patio table and throw the food out that way. We've had a series of heron attacks this spring, so it's probably a defense mechanism to be leary of anything tall looming right next to the pond. The other thought is what kind of plants do you have? Do you have plants that cover a good portion of the surface? That helps them feel less exposed and they're more willing to come out in the open and feed.

  • 19 years ago

    I'm no fish expert either, but this is what I did. I read about ways to get your fish to eat out of my hand.

    One thing is do not feed your fish for a few days. Don't worry, fish will find little things to chomp on, so they will not go hungry... much.

    Sit by the pond (quietly) and put your hand with a little food (3-4 pellets) in it, into the water. Release the food into water.

    The key is to move slowly and quietly (as they become used to you, they will tolerate faster movements and some noise). Also start out feeding in one select spot until they get use to you as their "food source".

    They will come to the food. Just stay there quietly. Stay there until all food is eaten. Add a little more. Soon they will SEE you as the source of food (right now they see it as falling out of the sky - lucky them).

    It takes patience; Presently I have one fish that comes right up to the side (I can rub it under/around the mouth). Anyone walks out to the pond, that fish moves, and the others follow. The others are just there, a foot away.

    I've gotten caught up in summer activities and haven't focus on the training of my fish much recently. My next step is to choose my next fish to selectively feed and focus on it to come to the side (there are a few candidates).

    LP

    Here is a link that might be useful: Handfeeding koi

  • 19 years ago

    I couldn't get mine to come out from their "caves" either so I started to take little pieces of hotdog buns (they sink fast)and squished it up into a pellet about the size of a pea and for several days I would toss it close to the cave until they'd run out to eat it (did have to sit back in the lawn chair and not move).. and then I slowly worked it to shore now I add the koi food to the shoreline then toss a piece of bun in the midst of it. They are getting more used to me hovering over them as long as I dont make huge moves.. sooooooooon I will be able to feed them out of my hands.. (Hopefully) after they have been gorging themselves for a while I have started doing bigger moments around them so they get used to it.

  • 19 years ago

    I found they, my goldfish, really love the insides of tomatoes! They were as shy as you describe until I started making them aware that the food came from my hand, very slowly. Now they come and beg everytime I'm by the pond!

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the responses. I sit in a chair near the pond, drop a little bit of food in the pond, and wait. Eventually one of them will come out, then dart back into the cave. I swear, it's telling the others, "She's still there!" because it's ages before one of them will poke it's head out again. And when it sees me, it's back into the cave and another long wait. I've been doing this for a nearly a month, trying to get them used to my presence, but they aren't accepting it. I forgot to mention, they really only come out in the evening, just as its getting dark. If I go out with my flashlight after dark, I'll catch them swimming around.

  • 19 years ago

    Mine took about 3 months. I started out with 12 and within days had 9. I never saw them! I thought about getting more so at least I would maybe see one! LOL

    When everything died back for the winter, I expected them to hide out at the bottom.

    We had a mild winter and I started seeing them swim around about two feet down.

    This spring, they had babies. It is so cool. At dusk they skim along the surface looking for bugs on the water.

    Give it time. I do not feed my fish and I am sure by feeding them it would not have taken as long.

  • 19 years ago

    Things are looking a bit more promising tonight. I went out and sat in my chair at the edge of the pond and put the food right in front of me and I was determined to just wait them out no matter how long it took. It did take a long time, but they finally started coming out and circled frantically at the bottom for a while before getting brave enough to rush up to the surface and grab a bite and then zip back down. I just kept waiting there, and they kept coming up. When they appeared to be feeling a bit more comfortable, I put some food in my hand and held it just above the surface, and as they started coming up, I gently released it into the water so that they could see the pellets appearing with me right there in the hopes that they will soon learn that I'm the one putting the food in. It was well after dark when I finally came back in. I'm eaten up with mosquitoes, but feeling a little better about the prospects for friendly koi.

  • 19 years ago

    I generally feed my fish (mostly goldfish but have four small koi) every other day or at most once a day. They won't grow as rapidly as if you fed them two or three times a day but they will stay healthier. They'll continually forage and produce less waste products and decomposing food won't be a problem. Less waste equals less algae too. That said, I shut off the pumps/filters and they are immediately right there at the surface begging. If I have to go into the ponds for maintenance they'll be within inches of my legs so I have to move slowly. When my two dachshunds get a drink out of the pools again they'll be right there. Just give them time..john

  • 19 years ago

    Naturelover, I gave my fish some tomato pieces today and they loved it. I had put out just a very small amount the first time and when I looked later it was gone, so I put out a little bit more and it disappeared too, but I didn't see who was eating it. So I put out another small amount and watched from the window. Sure enough all 4 (2 comets and 2 shebunkins)gobbled it all up. Now I am wondering how much to give them. There's only a total of about 18 inches of fish between the 4 of them.

  • 19 years ago

    Remember Pavlov's Dog? He rang a bell, then fed the dog. Eventually he rang the bell and the dog drooled.
    With my last year's batch of fish (wich unfortunately got eaten by either coons or birds) I would tap on the side of the pond, then feed them. They got even smarter than me and started coming up to the surface when they heard me walking across the deck! Ready to eat!
    I have a new batch' who have a milk crate to hide in if critters come to the pond (weighted) I've had them about a month or so and they are starting to respond! I have to sit very still next to the pond, but I can move about now once they discover the food.
    The others get to the hand feeding. If you want that follow their directions! I might do that later in the summer. I just want to be able to count them each day and hope some critter didn't get into the yard and eat another bunch of my babies! Nancy