Software
Houzz Logo Print
predfern2

General Jack in zone 5a?

18 years ago

Is General Jack hardy in zone 5a? I saw some at Home Depot, but helpmefind.com says it is only hardy to zone 5b.

Comments (6)

  • 18 years ago

    I have an own root Général Jacqueminot (shortened by some to General Jack) planted near a dryer vent on the west side of my house. It requires some pruning each spring but still has lots of green canes left. I would consider it hardy with a little protection. Mine doesn't get protected except for what ever leaves happen to collect around the base. It gets quite tall in the summer.

  • 18 years ago

    The William Saunders Rose Society web page has rose-cane winter hardiness reports compiled by members. If you scroll down the linked page to Marcia McCarty's report, she lists her experience with General Jack.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Wm. Saunders Hardiness Reports

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, the General likes Zone 5, and the older he gets the better he likes it. :-)

    Seriously, give him time to get established. I get very little dieback on GJ. The first 3 years or so were tough. Btw, this rose is often very late to break dormancy, so don't go thinking that he's dead just because he's slow. It will catch up quickly.

    The GJ in the photo is 8 or 9 years old.

    Well worth the wait, especially for the fragrance. Not the prettiest bush in the world. It gets leggy, so I prune him well every few years after the spring/summer flush, and selectively removed the oldest and leggiest canes every 4 years. Don't prune much the first couple of years if you don't have to.

    Photo from last year, taken close to sunset. This rose gets leggy, as you can see, so I gave him a good pruning when this flush was over. Being at the far end of the lot, I tend to neglect the General. Alfalfa meal and a layer of compost in the spring (usually late April). Additional fertlizer and compost here and there if I'm in the mood. This rose is in almost-constant sunlight.

    Rebloom is decent enough; again, once it has matured. Not much rebloom the first year or two. Unfortunately, rebloom is during JB season and the General is one of their favorites.

    I like this rose so much that I got another one a couple of years ago for another part of the yard. The new one is still getting established and should be a better performer this year and in the future. My daughter loves this rose too, for both the color and the fragrance. She just moved into her first home and I get to help colonize her yard! Yippee! :-)

    {{gwi:233279}}

  • 18 years ago

    Wow..lionheart..GJ is gorgeous for you! I live in z5 N.Y., also..so I guess it's got to go on my wish list! Do you mulch it or do anything special for winter protection? Thanks, Donna

  • 18 years ago

    I bought it at Home Depot today. It is a series of roses in pots. Last year I bought the equivalent Reine des Violettes. Chopped roots and looks grafted but RdV grew last summer and survived the winter (I buried the bud union 3"). A bit cold today but I got GJ in the ground. I can't wait for the beautiful blooms and wonderful fragrance. Thanks all.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Donna,

    Sorry to have not seen your question sooner. Call me "lazy". I do not protect my roses for winter. I'm very Darwinian, but also tend to get roses that are likely to perform well in our chilly zone.

    Of course, it took years of failures to get it through my thick skull that, no matter how beautiful, some roses just don't belong here. Bummer!

    We have such a short growing season that the 3-year-rule is the minimum for us. It often takes some roses 4 years to get their feet under them here. There's no instant gratification with roses...something that took me a while to figure out. :-)

    If you're not as lazy as me, go ahead and winter protect them. But I've found, with hardy roses, winter protection is not worth the extra effort. With more tender roses, you really must winter protect.

    I can't stress enough that GJ will likely have some die back until it's well-established. So will other hardy roses. The trick is waiting until they mature; they become more hardy then.

    All the best!