Software
Houzz Logo Print
mikeheather

Trim Colors for Dated Orange Brick?

14 years ago
So we just bought a house that was built in 1969, back when mottled orange brick was in style, I suppose. Right now the roof is light grey and the trim is beige and it all looks washed out and gross.

I'd like to know if my only options for some curb appeal are a charcoal colored roof and white trim. I'd personally prefer some type of sage-colored trim, but my boyfriend is hesitant, he doesn't think it can look good.

Also, should we buy shutters? What about that odd trim beneath all the windows? Meanwhile, we'll also be un-converting the garage, so tips on doors would be greatly appreciated!

Comments (57)

  • 14 years ago
    Oh and we're working on convincing the power company to bury the lines. We have to get the connector to the house repaired anyway. We need to convince them that it's more cost-effective and frankly, we've been bogged down with other obligations.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    No shutters. I chose platinum for my roof in Florida, and it is great. The neighbors even like it. Let's see if I can find a picture. OK this is before I painted the house. I left the orangey brick and painted the top aquamarine. The trim is a pale warm gray to coordinate with the roof, warm to not fight with the hot brick below.
  • 14 years ago
    Your idea about working with grey is a good one. Paint it on the window frames and siding underneath. Add tall shutters (the height of each window AND the siding beneath) and paint them grey. Stick with square/rectangle windows on the garage doors and paint the doors grey too. A medium grey might be best so as not to look to black (black + orange brick = Halloween ;) ). Paint the gable siding the same color as the roof to give the illusion of a hipped roof. If your roof is in good condition than wait to replace it until needed. Don't overlook the trees and bushes which, unfortunately, are not at all symmetrically placed and really detract from your cute house. Remove the bushes and trees and start from scratch. Add a pretty weeping or flowering tree centered between the two windows to the right of the porch and some new, compact shrubbery the first year. Plant a pair of cobalt blue pots with annuals for your porch. Each year you can add to the landscaping until you have as much/little as you want to maintain. Good luck with your new home and please share photos!
  • 14 years ago
    I actually like the the vertical siding. It offers a unique look to the house that most houses do not have. I would add long shutters to the windows that include the boxes underneath. As for the color, I would pick a couple shades darker than your mortar as it is usually a safe way to enhance your brick and make the house appear more "grounded." I would also consider removing the storm windows to brighten up the windows. It is an effective way to brighten up the "eyes" of your house if replacement windows are not an expense you wish to tackle. Remember, "perfection is achieved not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to remove." Your house has a lot of potential. Landscaping, removing the trees next to the house, and removing the storm door would help a lot. The trees could be a potential hazard if snow and ice are a problem where you live.
  • 14 years ago
    Remove windows, siding and replace with longer/taller windows.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    It's not just a matter of color, it's how you use it. To solve a few of your design problems and create a more unified, harmonious appearance: Paint the triangles, the large side door (a conflicting focal point) and the boxes below the windows in a color matched to the dominant tone of the brick. Paint the front door in a unique color to make it the focal point. Paint the railing black or very dark brown.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I think you're spot on with the color Sage. Owens Corning make a diminsional shingle called Driftwood. It has brown towns and a touch of Sage in it. Your summers are not much different than Indiana and we install this color a lot. A power vent will considerably help cool the attic and check your insulation. The vertical lines in the gable add height, I don't think I would change that. Be careful on garage doors. The corners are clipped and if you install raised panels it will cut off part of the panel. A flat panel with texture may be
    best suited for a clean look. I would paint the recesed panel sage and see how it looks. It may blend in with your landscaping and go away. I'm not sure about shutters, change the door, paint the siding, replace the roof then re evaluate, try to enjoy it
  • 14 years ago
    Try a nice charcoal gray on the bricks and a creamy white on trim. You can then accent the door with color. Put some specimen plants around with lots of color and that will pop.
    BTW, if you paint, it will actually help preserve the brickwork and grout. My brick house was painted (actually DryLok) and it looks so much better than the similar cottages near me and helps to keep the brickwork from having moisture problems (I live in a humid area).
    Instead of typical shutters, think of Bermuda/tropical shutters that hinge at the top and stay in place.
  • 14 years ago
    I had a house built in the 60s with orange brick. Wood was painted in a gray with blue undertones which, of course, did nothing but bring out the orange. With advice from Benjamin Moore rep, we repainted using Abingdon Putty on the body, Providence Olive on trim and Hancock Gray for accent (secondary doors et al). This paint has yellow undertones which reduced contrast with brick. We had a black roof, which we needed to keep--so I used touches of black (light fixtures etc) to tie it all together. We replaced front door with a dark stained mahogany, with window inset. In our landscaping, we used white crepe myrtles & dogwood, white & purple iris, pale yellow Lady Banks rose, daffodils, jasmine. Good luck and enjoy your new home!
  • 14 years ago
    I have the same color and problem, I would love to paint the brick. I agree with zanne4848 if I was staying in this home I would do exactly that! But since we are moving I painted the front door black and added shutters.
  • 14 years ago
    Watch curb appeal on hgtv for great painted brick homes.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Rip out all the greenery close to and touching house. (dated to the 70's--and planted too close to house) Stand back, and the colors will be easier to choose! I, personally, would add a one car garage to the end of the house, since you need some new landscaping anyway. That would do away w/the 2 end windows...New windows on garage can be whatever size you prefer.
    OOoO do you ride motorcycles? If yes, there is a way-cool "spinner" (turn-table)(drive in, set the kick-stand, and then spin the bike to head back out).
    http://www.facebook.com/?ref=tn_tnmn#!/mat.turntable
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    A couple of thoughts:
    (1) Since you indicated that you reside in the coastal region of Virginia, look to Colonial Williamsburg for inspiration. With the brick color, multiple lite entrance doors and trim along with the chimney style it appears the original builder started down that road.
    (2) Are you sure those are the original double hung windows? Floor to ceiling, divided lite double hung windows would not be out of place.
    (3) Because the structure is in a salt air environment, you may want to consider an sealant to help preserve the brick and mortar. Consult the preservationists at Colonial Williamsburg.
  • 14 years ago
    My neighbor had the wood under the window like yours. They put stone there and on the gable end. It is a great improvement. I'll take a photo and post it. Be sure to paint the trim on the windows and fascia a dark color that blends with the stone or brick and gives some contrast with the roof.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    My house is basically that same color brick, but I don't mind it one bit. I however did not have all the busy features that your house seems to have. I painted the wood around the windows a color called toffee crunch (behr) and the roof line a dark chocolate brown. Also painted the gutter dark brown by roof line. Where the gutters run down on the corners of the house I painted them the brick color, so they weren't noticeable. There is dark brown around the front door wood molding and I painted my front door in the sagey green family. I love it, but there is another big difference, my roof shingles are in the same realm color as the brick. Kind of a terra cotta/brownish color. So that's different as well.
    If you can replace the windows for larger ones and get rid of the vinyl details I would do that for sure. And the bahama style shutter/awnings get my vote as well instead of traditional shutters. I have never liked fake shutters though.
    Not exactly sure the style you are going for here, so please keep that in mind if reading my post.
    Landscaping that place will make a HUGE difference as far as updating it! Get some advice from someone who knows what they are talking about and then do the work yourself to save some money!
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    how about consulting with a local professional? help keep a local business...in business.
  • 14 years ago
    we have homes like that in our 1970's subdivision, and those areas under the window were covered in 'redwood' siding, usually in a slanted or chevron pattern, as a way to spice up the house design without being high maintenance like a whole house made out of fake redwood siding would be, needing to be painted or sealed often. That is an option -- to return it to the original concept. One thing I like to do is print out an 8 x10 photo of my house and then slip it into a heavy-duty clear slipcover for scrapbook pages and then doodle and draw over it with markers, you can save it, or wipe off or throw away the sleeve and start a new idea. Also drive around and see what other people do with the same color bricks, or look on real estate website like realtor.com or zillow.
  • 14 years ago
    I like the idea of looking around the area for similar designs to see what has been done. When we wanted to update our house, we looked around as Tabitha suggested. Ours was one of three mid-60s colonials on a block full of houses of many different mid-century designs. All have been maintained and kept fresh, but not "updated" by changing the designs completely. We refreshed the siding and paint and added new windows and new landscaping but kept the original design. Some might call it "dated" but in context in our neighborhood, it is "classic."
  • 14 years ago
    Think your org. idea is perfect a sage.....dont listen to a boyfriend who may or may not be there for long run esp. if he is not paying for it.
    Go to a big paint store and carry a pic and ask for their input without even telling them about the sage and see what they say....go to a roofing co. and do the same and then make a ed. decision.
    Look for the same brick color in commercial or res. buildings and see what they used....Then you have it to copy and ask for paint brand and numbers if poss.
    I would also keep the metal railing as it goes with the house. Right paint color will do so much for it...you can always change it out at a later date if it is just not the look you want and every change is $$ in the contractors pocket. The trim can even be painted by your boyfriend and you it is a low roof...fun to do together .....you dont have to have real exp. just ask a paint store for step by step directions and go online and ask how to paint.

    Happy house repairs to you!!!

    Oh after all it is just paint and you can always repaint the trim .....oh Walmart paint is made by Sherwin Williams and so ck there first and they even match colors for you....think it is about 14.00 a gal...shouldnt take more than 2 gal....prep well and have fun.
  • 14 years ago
    Oh my Neighbor has the Sage trim on the org. brick and it is so beautiful...that is why i know it will look GREAT....think it has a med. brn tone roof and it all ties in beautifully.....wish i could get you a pic....i admire it each time i walk past and it is the only house i uhoo and aha over....in our subdivision and have always said if i had this brick....this is what i would copy.
  • 14 years ago
    Concerning a darker roof and it being hot.....rem. asphalt is asphalt and all are hot.. this was told to me when i was picking out my roof.....no matter the color....just make sure you have the correct amt. of insul. in the attic....and do the color that looks best on the house not go white to think you are making it cooler....
    Also go with nice shutters as this give you opp. to have a contrast on the brick and this give you that curb appeal....If you do the landscaping go wide curved beds with basic ever greens that are common in your area.....lots of mulch and wella....simple and clean lines.
    There again ask a contractor for input and you do the work........sm. fee maybe but saves so much money. Most will draw it all out for you..,..name all the plants and where they go. Or find a home owner near by with a great green thumb and put a nice note in mail box and ask for their suggestions ....make a friend at same time.
    Wish i could get a pic to you of my neighbors house......
  • 14 years ago
    The shutters wouldn't look good with your windows and wood under it. You should paint the front door too & might consider changing the railings.
  • 14 years ago
    One quick step to enhanced curb appeal is to chop down that meatball on a stick shrub in front of the entry stairs. Make the porch railing heavier ('cause nothing says 60s like fake spanish iron railing) - a nice wooden railing is cheap and easy.

    I like the ideas of a sagey green or dusty blue for the trim. It would go well with the brick color.

    The funky panelling under the windows? I bet there were options for buyers, and one upgrade was taller windows ... not knowing which options to install for a house, they framed in for the taller windows and filled in the openings for short ones. Paint it same as trim for now, unless you want to try matching the medium brick tones to make it vanish, and consider installing taller windows later.
  • 14 years ago
    The shutters wouldn't look good with your windows and wood under it. You should paint the front door too & might consider changing the railings.
  • 14 years ago
    Wow! Thanks for all the amazing advice, y'all! =)

    As I said, I'm not painting the brick - it's not that I don't like the color, its just that the roof/trim colors are not doing it justice. I want to work with it, but then again, keeping everything in the brown family is boring. =P

    LOL@ meatballs on a stick. You're not kidding! All the foliage has to go. Even if we *did* like the look of scraggly bushes and fir trees (which we don't) we can't keep them anyway. It's been ages since they've been pruned, so they're bald in some places, rotten in others, and generally looking sick & abandoned.

    Also, we *do* already have a garage! It's hiding behind that homemade monstrosity of a French door garage conversion. Like I said, we're planning to reconvert it back so we can use the space. We want to get a garage door with high window panels, good call on the clipped corners, K.O.H., I didn't even think about that.

    And last but not least, you don't have worry about me not supporting local businesses! I network & I'm active in the community, so I "got a guy" (or girl) for just about everything. And because they're all so awesome, they let me join them and get my hands dirty to save money. I'm learning a lot! Our contractor is my friend Jim Hicks, a local legend. As far as roofing and remodeling go, he's the best of the best. So we know we're in great hands. :)

    FWIW, the boyfriend and I are buying the house together so unfortunately, I gotta take his opinion into consideration. ;)
  • 14 years ago
    There's house I go by every time I go and visit my son. It's red brick, and it has a charcoal trim. I would have never thought that would look good, but it looks fantastic on this house. It also has some lovely bronze lantern type lighting. It looks very classy, IMO.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    uh...duh me...I thought a "conversion" meant that the garage was made into a family room or bedrooms, man-cave...LOL..definitely "dates" me!
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    I spent 30 years in tidewater and am familiar with your concerns. While I have seen many painted brick homes and your would be much improved in color by painting. You are right in not doing so. Why change a min. maintenance surface for one that will peal and blister as well as mold with all our wet air. Changing the brick color is still very possible by using a concrete stain. You will need to seal the mortar joints before you spray and try the color in the back where landscaping can cover the small test area.

    Your current windows are replacements, thus the siding under them. I would agree that floor length windows would be a great elevation improvement, but short of that I would just fill in the space with a slightly different shade of brick in a stacked pattern instead of a running bond. Then add the full length shutters to finish the look.
  • 14 years ago
    Debbie, normally you'd be correct. But whoever lived here before us just haphazardly ripped out the garage door and nailed in the french doors. Then they laid carpet on the garage floor (no subfloor, no padding, no staples) and erected a wall bisecting the front and rear of the garage that I could probably tear down with my bare hands. It's a piece of work!
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    archibaldfarm, not being mean but. I don't think Sherrwin Williams sells to Wally World. Glidden Paint sold out to them in 1994. I buy all my paint from S.W. and called them when I read your note. There is a big difference in quality.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I always like adding a grayish or sage color to update an orange type color brick. I’ve used the following colors by Sherman Williams: Universal Khaki SW 6150 for any siding, for the trim color I would use Quiver Tan SW6151…and defiantly add the shutters but paint them BLACK, and get the more updated style.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    I would like to suggest Hardwick White (looks gray) or London Clay (brown family) by Farrow & Ball. I have the same orange brick that you do and used the latter on my trim and shutters. It is amazing. I was able to replace the ugly burnt orange roof with an upgrade in Heatherwood. I have lived with it about 2 years and this year have just about decided to paint the shutters French Blue or something. I have been wanting to have grills made and painted the same color as the trim or white or something. It will just help me freshen it up and when I get tired of it I can paint those myself. Orange brick is not easy to find the correct trim color. I am fortunate that my sister is a world famous artish and picked the colors for me. I simply was stumped and was about to pull the trigger and paint the brick when she came to my rescue.
  • 13 years ago
    I'm curious what you ended up doing to update your home. I'm looking into ideas for my home with orange brick. Post a picture if you can.

    Also, I came across a photo of a historic home with the wood under the windows like yours. It's from a shutter company website. I just thought I'd share.

    http://www.estatemillwork.com/houston-shutters.html
  • 13 years ago
    last modified: 13 years ago
    Thanks, jenbruce! I haven't posted pictures because, honestly, after spending all winter indoors, all of our home projects have been, well, indoorsy. The only difference to the photo I posted above is that we replaced the Frenchdoors on the garage with a real garage door and we replaced the busted aluminum siding on the front gable with light sage cedar shake looking siding. Now, as you can see, my big headache is the front porch.
  • 13 years ago
    I love the color you settled on really compliments the brick. Are you going to paint the trim that color too?
  • 13 years ago
    Are you referring to the garage door color (which we chose because it matches the mortar of the bricks) or the gable color?
  • 13 years ago
    I guess I was referring to the window trim & wondering if it will be the same color as the gable?
  • 13 years ago
    I have no idea! I know I want the front door to be a dark greyish purple. I don't know if I should get shutters to match the door. Should the trim under the eaves and around the windows be white? Sage green?
  • 13 years ago
    After looking at the garage door color, I think the trim around the windows and doors would look nice in the garage door color. Then take the green from the gable end and paint the shutters that color. Love the idea of a purple door it could be the only place that color is used but I would try to tie it to other parts of the house like a line of the same paint on the shutters or on the window trim and garage door trim. Even some pots or accessories in that color would show it off and coordinate the entire exterior. I sure like your choice of color palate.
  • 9 years ago
    I'm looking for porch and trim color for my orange brick ranch style house.
  • 7 years ago

    I'm trying to figure out what color the siding should be on my orange brick/slate roof home.



  • 7 years ago
    Great house! Think hard before you paint the brick. I think you could do a lot with the right color combo for trim and doors. Look around at some newly redone homes from the 60s. I think the green is nice, but some darker tones would be good too.
  • 7 years ago

    I dont want to paint the brick. Just want to paint the siding or install new siding. Hoping someone will recommend a great color for me. Side view


  • 7 years ago

    Tim Lewis start you own dilemma for advice. You'll do a lot better that way.

  • 7 years ago

    Whatever you do, DON'T paint the brick. Didn't even notice the hydro line until it was mentioned. It is not a big deal. We have it even worse - the hydro pole sits on our property and has been so for decades. The trick is to draw their eyes to the house and nothing else. That property has so much potential.

  • 7 years ago

    Drive around your neighborhood and look at the roof colors that may be of interest to you. Look for ones with similar brick colors. I find real visuals are helpful. Congratulations on your purchase. Enjoy!

  • 6 years ago

    What color is your garage door? I love it!

  • 2 years ago
    last modified: 2 years ago

    I don't think brick is EVER dated. No matter what color it is. Remember, if you paint your brick, you now have maintenance. Brick will inevitably start to chip and peel after a while. And, if you decide you want to go back they have to sand blast it and that can damage the brick and in many cases you will need to tuck point the joints. Painted brick will look dated. This doesn't.


    Thanks to Joanna and Chip, too many homes are being painted...UGH!

  • PRO
    2 years ago

    Old post from a dozen years ago

Sponsored
Buckeye Basements, Inc.
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars40 Reviews
Central Ohio's Basement Finishing ExpertsBest Of Houzz '13-'21