Software
Houzz Logo Print
sherry_roma

Calling all hay mulch experts

17 years ago

I know some of you use this so maybe you have advise to offer. With my composted horse manure came clumps of dry hay from the horse stalls. I figured "Why waste it", so I put it on my new round bed as mulch. I pulled it apart and 'sprinkled' it on the ground a few inches thick. Well, for the life of me I can't put enough water on it to penetrate beyond a 1/2" of hay no matter how long I stand there with the hose. (I don't understand where all the water is going!) And lifting up clumps of hay to wet the ground underneath is not my idea of a fun evening. If this isn't the kind of hay you use, then I'm done with it - out it's going. I don't have the soaker for this bed set up yet, so I'm concerned for the newly transplanted LeVesuve, who looks fine by the way. What am I doing wrong?

Thanks all.

Sherry

Comments (8)

  • 17 years ago

    Sherry, I never used hay for a mulch, but I did have horses for years. Hay packs down a lot and actually becomes a barrier to water. Think of it in terms of thatched roofs. It might work better for you to move it to the areas where you don't want the water to get through in your garden, as a weed preventative. However, the hay may also contain lots of weed seeds. Been there. Done that. I thought my father was going to kill me as a kid when I spread horse manure mixed with straw and hay from my stalls, into his corn field. We never did get rid of all the weeds! Choked out all the corn in that area too.

    I am thinking of trying pine needles in the future rather than pine bark. For one thing, I can't hack shoveling piles of it up and hauling it around anymore. Pine needles come either free, if you gather them yourself somewhere, or in lightweight bales. I noticed at the last Heritage Rose meeting in Lakeland, that all of Malcolm's rose gardens at the college were being mulched with pine needles this year. Don't know about cost. However, I have read that the pine needles allow air and water to pass more freely than pine bark, which compacts pretty tightly.

    Sandy

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks, Sandy. The hay will be gone tomorrow.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    At least add it to your compost pile! Or use it to choke weeds, though, as Sandy says, you'll then have additional weeds, though easier to pull than the original ones.

    About the water not getting through, I guess that around the roses I just don't put it that thickly. Its capacity for packing down is what makes hay so valuable for choking out Bermuda grass. In your case, you're probably better off mulching with pine needles, an option I don't have.

    Melissa

  • 17 years ago

    Because it needs to be said:
    There's hay and there's straw, and they aren't the same thing.
    Hay is the preferred food (lots more protein) for animals as it has the seedheads from the grasses. Straw is the stem and leaf part of cereal crops, after the grains have been harvested.

  • 17 years ago

    Depends on the type of hay in certain areas of the country. You need to know what the hay is harvested from. The bermuda hay we gew and fed in Texas was okay to use in the garden..the bermuda here is not. Depends on whether it goes to seed or has to be spread from plugging (check that out). As to straw, the worst problem we ever had in the veggie garden was from using wheat straw. Super crop of wheat left over from what the combines missed, I guess. Pine straw is always good!

  • 17 years ago

    It's true that hay and straw are not the same thing. I grew up farming, and I had horses for years. Straw is typically used for bedding, while hay is used for feed. Both can contain lots of weed seeds. I haven't seen a field yet where there aren't some weeds growing in with it, not to mention it's own seeds. In any case, usually a nightmare in a garden where you do not want weeds. Think about it. The seeds come mixed in with some nice organic material to get it off to a great start....namely horse poop. And passing through a horse's digestive track doesn't harm many seeds. It takes a hot compost pile to kill them.

    Pine needles are the way to go, in my opinion. I'm battling weeds that came in my pine bark.

    Sandy

  • 17 years ago

    The subject of hay/straw is about the same as rocket science to me, having never set foot on a farm in my life. All I know is I won't do that again.

    I've had a few sprouts of something or other. It's been no problem to pull them out as I walk by. The benefit of the composted horse manure far outweighs the negative.

    Sherry

  • 17 years ago

    Way back in the 70's when Ruth Stout wrote about growing vegetables with a deep hay mulch, I tried it on my two 6X25 ft. raised beds full of OGR's. I followed her advice about topping off the old hay with grass clippings but as I got busier with work, seeds started to germinate and eventually the entire OGR collection disappeared under 3 foot grass. What a messsss....