Hi Heather, It's hard to suggest finishes when we don't know what style you like (modern, traditional, etc) what colors you like, etc. I will say that if you choose to keep your existing cabinet doors and door fronts and just paint, you may want to give them dimension with some added molding...they look rather flat in the picture. I would also suggest removing that wooden valance across the top of the sink area and possibly those shelves. The valance seems dated. I would consider painting out your wood molding around the window rather than keeping in stained (and any other stained molding around doors, windows to match). It's just my opinion but I think the stained trim dates a room too. They make an invisible hinge that doesn't show at all when the doors are shut, I would suggest that, then you don't have to worry about the finish on the hinges and I think the hinges showing sometimes looks busy. Painting the cabinets will make a HUGE difference in lightening the room. If you like the stained look, I would suggest changing to a lighter countertop material to lighten the space. I hope these comments were at least a little helpful. Maybe post another comment about what styles and colors you like and probably you'll get more helpful feedback than what I've given. Best of luck with your project.