Software
Houzz Logo Print
tjsangel

Sell me on Peonies

19 years ago

Hi everyone,

I have always loved the flowers and foliage of Peonies, but have never grown one. 1 reason is my neighbors plant gets covered in ants. I have an ant issue in the house every spring. Anyone else have this problem? I want a small shrub that will look nice all summer, on the small side, will go in a flower bed. If I go w/a Peony, which are the best cultivars? Thanks!

Jen

Comments (30)

  • 19 years ago

    peonies have showstopping blooms, and the foliage looks quite good all year long.
    I've grown them my whole life, and frankly, have never seen anything like this 'ant infestation' that gets mentioned now and then. Could be one of those 'urban legends'that are showcased on the TV show.
    pondy

  • 19 years ago

    My grandmother give me mine before she passed on...so it is of great sentimental value...they live forever so you can pass them generation to generation...I know when i see mine i think of my grandmother. Besides they are such a full bushy plant with georgous blooms, how could you not love them...i have them around my mailbox for the mailman to enjoy as well :). She also give me rose of sharon which i have been able to share lots with other people to enjoy.

  • 19 years ago

    I have over 50 peonies and yes, they do get ants, but nothing really bad. I take a bucket of water, cut the blooms early in the morning, dip the flower in the bucket and the ants come right off! Works everytime. Then, just dump the water in the ground. Peonies bloom for a short time. If you're looking for a small shrub that blooms all summer, why not try a hardy rose like 'Knockout', 'The Fairy', and I'm sure the list goes on.

  • 19 years ago

    Go directly to the link provided below (Do Not Pass Go!);
    request the free catalog offered on their home page. When
    this catalog arrives, turn to Page 34 and start drooling -
    you will NEVER have to be sold on peonies again. . .

    Seriously, though, Klehm's is justly famous for their
    peonies (they've hydridized many of them). . .some of the
    prices may startle you, but their quality and choice is
    unassailable. Notice that all the listings have a "bloom
    period" -early, mid or late season - so if you plant a
    mixed collection, you can have bloom for nearly two months!
    Beware of those "El Cheapo" boxes of roots you'll see in
    HD and Lowe's - they are generally quite inferior.

    I grew up with peonies surrounding our house, and I've had
    some in every one of my gardens over a lot of years. . .
    and you're not too late, because peonies are best planted
    in the Fall. Just be SURE to follow the instructions about
    planting the roots very shallowly! Oh, and the "old wives
    tale" about the ants: not to worry. . .ants already in
    your garden (not new invading hordes!) are naturally
    attracted to some (not all) peony buds (theories abound!)
    but will disappear once they are in full flower. To avoid
    bringing them inside, try cutting just-breaking buds, put
    them in water in a shady spot, leave them overnight, and
    come daybreak - presto! - no ants. . .Please, please don't
    spray! The ants are doing no damage and will be gone by
    the end of the peony season. . .

    Carl

    Here is a link that might be useful: Klehm's Song Sparrow Nursery

  • 19 years ago

    Peonies have to be one of the most spectacular blooms in the world. Easy to grow, very little disease, very rewarding.

    Ants are attracted to a substance on the peony buds. If you have a very large number of ants around your home, some will get on the flowers. Most people just shake the blooms upside down to dislodge the ants. (I saw an ant bait being discussed on the pest forum. Grape jelly and boric acid. They claim the worker ants carry it into the colony and eventually the queen eats some. Worth a try.)

    I would like to comment on posters calling other peopleÂs plants inferior. I have some peonies from my grandmother, some from Wild and some from a box store and I defy anyone to tell the difference. It's kind of a slap in the face for anyone to hear their flowers called inferior.

  • 19 years ago

    Easy there, bean counter - all Carl18 said was "Beware of those "El Cheapo" boxes of roots you'll see in HD and Lowe's - they are generally quite inferior." That's been my experience too. I've had mixed success with box-store plants, more failures than successes, and don't bother with them anymore. The local nurseries tend to offer more mature perennials anyway, which I prefer.

    When you buy a box of bare-root peonies (3 plants in a carton for under $10 is what I see in the big-box stores), you have to understand that they may well struggle for a few years to become established. They definitely are not going to bloom the first year in your garden, and if you're new to peonies you may not know how shallowly they need to be planted in order for the plant to bloom at all.

    The advantage of buying a more "grown-up" peony is that you don't have to determine the planting depth; it's already correctly planted in the container, and all you need to do is dig a hole, remove the pot, and plunk it in. After that, they're one of the most carefree perennials around!

    I love the big showy bloom and the fragrance of peonies. I just wish they lasted a little longer -- so often, there's a big storm in our area right after the first peonies open, and the rain and wind take them out. The foliage is still nice all summer, but it's a shame you can't get a month or more out of the flowers!

  • 19 years ago

    Peonies also never have to be divided and live forever. I prefer the single varities like 'Krinkled White', 'Sea Shell' and 'Soft Salmon Joy'. Not only are they the epitome of elegance, they have the advantage of staying upright no matter what the weather does.

    Ted

  • 19 years ago

    I have grown peonies all my life. The are among the most beautiful flowers in the world! Mine get ants but I just turn then over and shake them off as I take the blooms inside for show. Read somewhere the ants like the liquid that flows when the buds swell. I have never had the ants ever ruin a blooom. They've been a transient bother for me.

  • 19 years ago

    While everyone has waxed eloquent on peony blossoms, I'd like to chime in on the charms of the plant beyond bloom time. In early Spring, when first emerging, it sends up feathery red shoots, suitable for matching with red hellebores, or contrasting with the deep blue of scilla. Following bloom time, the foliage is attractive and disease-free all summer. In autumn, the foliage turns a nice yellow, very attractive with purple asters. Just remember to remove and destroy all foliage after it's faded.

  • 19 years ago

    Ooops! Sorry, Bean Counter - I really do try to bend over
    backwards online and be politically correct. . .my comment
    about the HD and Lowe's was meant to be a simple "heads-up"
    or "buyer beware", not a condemnation of any individuals
    plants.

    Carl

  • 19 years ago

    While some of the big box store peonies may thrive, you'll never get the magnificent cultivars that you can get from a quality supplier.

  • 19 years ago

    Agree with all the praise above. Everyone should include peonies (at least one...) in their garden if possible. The blooms are spectacular, the foliage is neat and tidy all season, and there is a lovely foliage effect of the red shoots in the spring, as mentioned above. And don't forget the fragrance!!

    These things are hardy as bone. Heck, they're as hardy as time - I've heard of plants over a hundred years old and still thriving! Any fool can grow a peony, all they ask for is enough sun and water, maybe some supplemental feeding if the gardener remembers (but will still perform beautifully year in, year out even if said gardener...cough, cough...forgets).

    One of mine is an el cheapo I bought about a decade ago when I just started gardening, it has since turned into a lovely, lush plant (it is a Festive Maxima, still one of the best IMO). Starting with those small roots requires patience, though, it did take a few years to get going strong. Still, not a bad way to go if you're on a budget.

  • 19 years ago

    I bought fragrant peonies from White Flower Farms in Connecticut, because I live in nearby Long Island NY. I have always heard peonies are hard to grow, and only bloom for a short time. But I love the way they look and WFF advertised them as "living 50 years" so I took a chance. Planted them according to instructions last October and I saw some shoots last week when I was peeking under the winter mulch. There's a Peony forum, I'll head over there next.

  • 19 years ago

    Yes and the foliage after bloom is beautiful as well. Turns red/bronze in the fall. I do agree though to buy the from a gardeners' supply - I got mine from White Flower Farm as well.

  • 19 years ago

    The only problem with Klehm's is the drool I get on the catalog when looking qt all those gorgeous cultivars.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh, thank God, someone else afflicted with CDS (Catalog
    Drool Syndrome) - I was beginning to think I was the only
    one out here suffering. . . :)

  • 19 years ago

    Flowers are beautiful, foliage is great all summer and I don't mind ants... but peonies are very floppy... after heavy rain all flower heads lay on the ground.I don't like floppy plants and I don't like staking them... that is why I am hesitant to plant more peonies.

    JanuszB

  • 19 years ago

    the doubles are floppy, without a doubt, that is why i buy the singles .. they are *perfect*

  • 19 years ago

    For floppys, thats why they sell peony supports. I put one around every peony when it's planted and never take it off. You can never go wrong buying from Song Sparrow!!

  • 19 years ago

    If you read the individual descriptions carefully, some are supposed to have very sturdy stems that won't flop. I love the old fashion, fragrant doubles that do tend to bend under the weight of the heavy blooms. After a storm they can end up laying on the ground, that's why I cage them. When the foliage is fully developed you can't even see the wire cages hidden in the leaves. Also, different varieties bloom early, mid season and late season so planning can extend your season by several weeks.

  • 19 years ago

    I, too, do not have much experience with peonies. I grew a couple in my old house and the flowers always flopped over. I agree that they are beautiful plants and flowers, but what is the best way to keep them from flopping? I just got one from a neighbor and want to make sure it gets planted the right way.

  • 19 years ago

    Idea for people needing peony or other plant supports. I get the Springhill catalog with a $25 gift certificate on the front. I don't need their plants, have plenty, but I always need supports. So I go to the middle section and order the supports. You have to spend $25 but get $25 worth free. If you don't get the catalog you may be able to go on line and get the coupon. It is worth a try. www.SpringHillNursery.com
    Tina

  • 19 years ago

    Carl, at last I have a name (CDS) for my affliction. Oh well there are worse things to be afflicted with. Did I mention I also have CHAD? Chronic Horticultural Aquisition Disorder.

  • 19 years ago

    Oh no, I think I have CHAD too! Is there a cure? I inherited a double-flowered pale pink peony from the previous owner of the house. Ants crawl all over the flower buds. I take no notice of this whatsoever, as they don't appear to be doing much harm, whereas rosemary or lily beetles have a devastating effect on those plants. The floppiness annoys me hugely though and I never remember to buy a frame in time. Apart from that, I like them well enough. I'd just choose to buy a single flowered peony if I was getting one from scratch another time.

  • 19 years ago

    I have only two peonies; one single and one double. If I ever get more peonies, I will get doubles.

    It's true that the single is very beautiful, but it is also in bloom for about 2 days. The double is good for 2 to 4 weeks depending on the weather. Quite a difference!

  • 19 years ago

    Ferdzy, good point about the singles, I hadn't though about that. Here in Northern California, there's not such a big problem with them flopping, since usually the rainy season is just about over by the time they bloom (wind, however...).

    They really are one of the great plants to have in a garden, where they can be grown. I grew up in SE Texas, and also lived in Florida and in Southern California, all places where peonies were pretty impossible. It makes me appreciate them all the more now that I can have them.

    --Ron

  • 19 years ago

    I have about two dozen peonies, mostly inherited from the previous owner. They were small when she planted most of them and some haven't bloomed yet, so I have been patiently waiting to find out what the varieties are - all double blooms so far.

    Peonies are absolutely gorgeous, and I especially love the varieties that are fragrant. The foliage is attractive too although a few plants get some powdery mildew by fall.

    They are low maintenance in one respect because they're very long-lived and don't need dividing, BUT they are high maintenance because they need support to look half-way decent. They have a relatively short bloom period per plant, and yes if we get a heavy rain while they bloom (which ALWAYS happens here in New England) the blooms flop over in 2 seconds and are pretty much ruined. In that case, it's good to cut them beforehand and put them in a vase!

    So I wouldn't recommend 2 dozen...but definitely having a few because they're so beautiful.

  • 19 years ago

    I love my peonies. I've squeezed a dozen or so into my yard over the past few years. I rarely see ants on mine, so I'm not concerned about it. Some peonies have marvelous foliage that looks good into the fall, too. The singles are often more weather-proof.

    The Hollingsworth Peony Nursery has a great website. I received great divisions of their plants a couple years ago, and they even bloomed the next year. Forget about just drooling on a paper catalog, you might want to cover your computer keyboard while you browse their online photo catalog. (They also comment on foliage characteristics and sturdiness, which is very helpful.)

    I've gotten a large handful of peonies from G.H. Wild - and they've done well for me too. Patience is a virtue when planting peonies - it takes a couple years to get a good clump going.

    You won't regret planting a peony - they are great perennials.

    Laurel

    Here is a link that might be useful: Hollingsworth Peony Nursery

  • 19 years ago

    Ants on peonies are part of the deal. The ants are actually consuming the exudate from the buds. If you plant peonies the ants might be less likely to venture into you home... now there's a thought! :)

    The ancient chinese actually considered that the gentle touch of the ants was what coaxed forthe the lovely flowers that peonies are known for. I love that story but I'm "cool" with ants. ;)

    If the flowers are "doubles" you do have to stake them or they'll wind up in the mud after a rain. But, for me, that's a small price for those wonderful flowers and the SMELL. Best of all, there is virtually nothing that eats them or to which they fall prey. Botrytis is more a matter of good culture than anything else.

    The foliage is impeccable all season long and pairing them with bulbs is a quick way to cover up ripening bulb foliage. The pink buds and the lovely red of emerging foliage is a sumptuous spring treat. Peonies are the Ronco Grills of the plant world... "set it and forget it". It doesn't get any better than that in my book.

  • 19 years ago

    Is it really true that the bloom on singles last only a couple of days????

    Last fall I expanded my peony envelope and bought two singles (Gold Standard and La Pinja) for their absolute elegance. I sure hope the blooms last more than 2 days! Of course, it may take a year or two for them to bloom and to test this theory. ;-D
    Judye

Sponsored
Schlabach Woodworks
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars22 Reviews
Franklin County's Reclaimed Wood Professionals