Software
Houzz Logo Print
basic_gw

mid-winter quiz

20 years ago

Anyone care to give a shot at identifying these trees? Not much to go on, but some of you are so good at this I thought it might be fun to see if you could ID them with just the winter silouette. I don't think I could ID more than 2-3 of them if not for the fact I planted them! A couple of them are dead giveaways.

#1

{{gwi:321886}}

#2

{{gwi:321887}}
{{gwi:321888}}

#3

{{gwi:321889}}

#4

{{gwi:321890}}

#5

{{gwi:321891}}
{{gwi:321892}}

#6

{{gwi:321893}}

#7

{{gwi:321894}}

#8

{{gwi:321895}}

Comments (14)

  • 20 years ago

    Yea, dead giveaways if you already know what they are. :)

    #2's bark looks familiar, but I can't guess it
    #3 might be a Redbud
    #4 looks like the growth of a maple
    #6 pretty sure that's Kentucky coffeetree
    Some of the others (5 & 7) are some kinda Prunus (cherry)

  • 20 years ago

    Beng,

    You're on a roll...you should have ventured a guess at all of them. Pretty good guess on #4, but no cigar. No credit for #2 and only half credit for 5 & 7 :)

  • 20 years ago

    Does this help?

    #1
    {{gwi:321896}}

    #4
    {{gwi:321897}}

    #7
    {{gwi:321898}}

    #8
    {{gwi:321899}}

  • 20 years ago

    #4 - Platanus (sp.)
    #7 - Prunus maackii

    What's all the white stuff on the ground?

    Resin

  • 20 years ago

    #8 looks like it might be a rowan of some sort

    Resin

  • 20 years ago

    Prunus maackii it is. Unfortunately, no Rowan or Platanus in the group. I believe three of the eight have now been identified.

    Now, regarding the lack of white stuff, a better question is where in the he!! is it? A freakishly mild winter thus far with snow fall well below average. January was the warmest on record, with coldest temp this winter being
    -10F/-23C. That's grilling weather!

  • 20 years ago

    #2 & #4 are dang hard. Several sapling species have #2's bark-cracking pattern. Branching seems opposite on #2. Have---to-----maintain------credibility-------arrrggghhhh...

    #8 I will risk a guess -- Alternate-leaf dogwood. Horizontal branching & the other clue.

  • 20 years ago

    #1 Betula lenta
    #2 Fraxinus sp.
    #4 Cladrastis kentuckea
    #5 Prunus serotina

    conifer50

  • 20 years ago

    You guys are picking them off now. Beng got #8 (Cornus alternifolia) and Conifer50 scored with 4 & 5. That leaves 1 & 2...a native and an exotic. #1 would be much easier if it was a bit larger, while bold branching (and eventually the bark) of #2 is key.

  • 20 years ago

    I still think #1 is a species of birch, #2 is going to require more thought!

    conifer50

  • 20 years ago

    Agreed that #2 is difficult...I really didn't expect anyone to get it. It's a hybrid of Phellodendron amurense and P. sachalinense called 'His Majesty'. #2 is Carpinus caroliniana. No "muscling" of trunk yet, which would have made it easy to ID. It does have the characteristic crook to it, however. Thanks for indulging me.

    Bob

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks for indulging us.

    Does your C. alternifolia have decent flowers & fruit at that age? I've got a small seedling.

  • 20 years ago

    Hi Beng,

    I sing the praise of this little beauty at every opportunity. I bought mine in a #5 container and it was about 3'-4' when planted summer of 2000. Its now about 9' x 12'. Mine flowered at a young age and produces a nice fruit crop every year. The birds get absolutley silly over the fruit. It's located at NE corner of the house, and I love to waste time watching & listening to them through the window as they seem to lose all sense of caution harvesting the fruit.

    The flowers are subtle, but still very nice. An added bonus is their fragrance. You don't see this feature mentioned very often, but it is quite pleasing. Probably not quite as nice as Fringe Tree, but close. What am I doing...you already know all this. Like I said, I sing its praise at every opportunity. ;)

    Bob

  • 20 years ago

    Bright red catches birds' attention from afar, so instead of red fruit like Flowering dogwood, Pagoda has bright red fruit-stems.

    An old-timers' name for Pagoda dogwood is Pigeonberry...

Sponsored
High Point Cabinets
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars21 Reviews
Columbus' Experienced Custom Cabinet Builder | 4x Best of Houzz Winner