Software
Houzz Logo Print
terrilp

Greenhouse over pond question?

18 years ago

Hi,

I am considering purchasing a greenhouse to construct over my pond, and I'm hoping someone could help with my question since I know nothing about Greenhouses. Does anyone know If my 3000 gallon pond would freeze in a greenhouse and no heat? If I don't heat the greenhouse would it be the same temp as outside? I was kind of hoping that the sun would heat it enough in winter to prevent freezing. I'm not looking for it to be warm, just prevent freezing, in zone4.

I would appreciate it if anyone could help.

Thanks,

Terri

Comments (5)

  • 18 years ago

    It would be better in the greenhouse as it reduces windchill and excessive evaporative heatloss from the equation.
    3000 gallons is a fair amount of water,it would take over 7kw (gain or loss) to change the water temperature by 1 degree F.
    A sunny winters day will raise the greenhouse air temp by a good amount which should add "some" heat to the pond and also the surrounding floor area.
    If you could cover the surface of the pond at night inside the greenhouse that would help reduce a lot of evaporative heat losses.

  • 18 years ago

    Hi
    Have no experience with your climate but a good place to start is What are your average winter temps, How much sun is available in winter.??What is the depth of your frostline?? What to do during summer??
    Have run a 3x6 foot pond in my shadehouse for several years. The mainproblem has been location within the structure. Obviouly if you put it in the middle you have access and viewing all the way around. Means you have to walk around it to get to the other end. If you put it against the outside walls you have no viewing or access to one or two sides.lol Above ground worked better but a large aquarium worked the best.
    Good luck with your project !!! gary

  • 18 years ago

    Terri:

    You didn't tell us WHY you need to keep the pond from freezing. Are you planning to keep fish in it all winter? If cold isn't an issue, I'm presuming any plantings in or around it are winter hardy?

    As already noted, 3000 gal. of water would help reduce heat loss inside of a GH, but not by much and while laying a cover on the surface of the pond would reduce heat loss from it, especially if the cover was a solar pool cover, you wouldn't want to do that if there were fish in it.

    However, in Z-4, even with a GH over it, I believe you would still need some additional heat. A floating pond heater and an airstone powered by a fairly powerful pump might be enough, but if it's an inground pond and you simply want to maintain an oxygen supply to cold water fish, that ought to work as well without the GH.


  • 18 years ago

    Hi,
    Thanks all for responding.
    I was hoping to keep the pond from freezing so that I could leave my Koi in there. I have always brought my fish in the house in the winter, but it sure would be nice to get rid of the 4x8 tanks in the basement, as they take up a lot of space. I know a lot of people leave their fish out all winter, but the only way I would even consider doing it, is if the pond would not Freeze. But at the same time, I cannot afford to heat the GH.

  • 18 years ago

    Ah, Koi. Okay. We are in the same boat with cold water carp. Mine are Wakin, but as they grow larger I have the same desire not to move them and I do have the space to winter them elsewhere. Wakin don't get as large as Koi, but will go to 18 inches.

    Have you thought about just using pond heaters and an airstone?

    This is the time of year when I haunt the home center pond departments, to stock up with end of season sale items and yesterday, saw floating heaters at a Menards for less than $40.00 that might do the job for you. I didn't check capacity for them, but even if you had to buy 2 or even 3, it would beat constructing a GH.

    Also: Check out Farmtek for big stock tank heaters and if you are in WI, I would bet there is a Farm & Fleeet somewhere not that far away from you.

    Another option; if you don't have one already, instead of air stones, a large, submersible water pump driven stackable sponge filter. If the outlet was above the surface, with a floating tank heater anchored directly above it, would serve to keep the surface ice free, circulate the water and at the same time, filter, although if you leave them out, I presume you would stop feeding and let them go dormant?