Software
Houzz Logo Print
scotjute

Pruning of Fruit/Nut Trees

18 years ago

Been reading the other message going on about pruning trees.

Fruit and nut trees have typical instructions to cut these trees back at time of planting.

This seems to go against the general advice not to prune a tree back at planting.

Have 12 bare-rooted trees in the ground, pecan and pear. The question is do I prune them back following the typical recommendations for fruit trees or leave them untouched?

The trees will be watered weekly once they break dormancy and no rainfall that week.

Comments (3)

  • 18 years ago

    i would work on the presumption that ... a tree is a tree is a tree ....

    too often ... plant people are not up to date on new technology .. often just working the farm.. like grandpa did.. a century ago .. .. they don't have the website.. and they might not have the most current brochure ... that might have been stuck in the shipping carton ...

    regarding hosta.. i once queried .. why the labels on the plant had the improper name on them.. since the name was corrected over a decade ago ... the answer suggested that the mass producer perhaps had a half million labels made a decade ago .. and they were going to use them up if it was the last thing they did .. lol ...

    but the bottom line... on baby nut trees... you most likely aren't going to have nuts for years to come.. so i cant see the downside to leaving the leaves to make the food to grow the roots to get the nuts faster ...

    clip away too much ... and you will just retard maturity down the line ....

    that would be my gut reaction .....

    ken

    PS: you don't mention the supplier....

  • 18 years ago

    Fruit trees aren't meant as ornaments, nor as shade trees, but as fruit producing "mechanisms", so the standards are not the same. The pruning of fruit trees is to enhance the amount of fruit the tree can safely grow, not to grow the most attractive tree, keeping the essential "treeness" of that species. So, it may (will) call for different criteria and standards. Mostly, for many of the commercial orchards, and especially the local peach and apple orchards, ease of picking is also a factor. The peach trees are pruned for low-branching, vase shaped trees, and the apples are pruned for a slightly different shape, but still to produce the largest amount of healthy fruit per tree as possible.

    To be somewhat cliche-ed, you are comparing apples and oranges....

    There are any number of books on pruning orchard trees - and while I would use the accepted, "new" standards while removing any largish branches for any reason, I would be much more inclined to adhere to the accepted orchardist's practices for most fruit tree pruning.

    If you just want to grow a fruit tree AS a tree, and get whatever fruit you can as an after-thought, then ignore the above.

  • 18 years ago

    Perhaps this it the answer. Found this on-line from San Antonio gardening source: "Seedling pecan trees which are genetically developed thru the juvenile and intermediate phases before becoming bearing adults do not require central leader trunk training because a central leader will develop naturally. However when we ... take an adult bud out of the top of a bearing tree and graft it onto a small nursery seedling tree, all growth developing from the graft will always be adult and will grow exactly as adult shoots grow in the top of trees. Therefore, nursery trees grafted with adult buds must be trained into a central leader, otherwise, the tree will have multiple trunks."