Software
Houzz Logo Print
harryshoe

Which Can Handle The Most Sun

I have recently had a large hedge removed from my front yard. I am adding 3 small trees. The planting locations each have a different level of sun exposure with one in full sun, one in mostly sun and one in morning sun only.

The three trees are:

Japanese Red Maple, Bloodgood

Kousa Dogwood

Eastern Redbud

How would you locate each of the trees within the choices of sun exposure?

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    no issue with the redbud ....

    bloodgood ... should be OK .. ONCE IT IS ESTABLISHED .... might burn for the first few years .. until it gets a good root mass to support the tree .... i cant say how many years.. since you dont mention how big you are starting with.. the bigger the transplant.. the longer to get established ... [i have problems with JM's due to winter problems .. rather than summer issues .. though damages is apparent in summer.. sometimes its hard to tell when the damage is done.. rather than when it SHOWS ]

    no clue about the dogwood ...

    if you decide to be concerned about the amount of sun.. tend toward avoiding the HOT SUN times.. say 3 to 6pm .... when the sun intensity coordinates with high ambient heat.. it is then.. that lack of pumpable water.. can cause tissue damage ... make sense??? .. e.g. full sun at dusk and dawn is irrelevant .. compared to high noon

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    I wouldn't plant any of those in full sun, especially the redbud if you get 90+ temperatures routinely during the growing season.

  • 16 years ago

    In Eastern Pennsylvania, our summer high temps are usually in the 80's. The hottest days are normally hazy or partially overcast. There is ample rainfall during summer. All of these trees can easily survive our winter where lows rarely reach 0.

    The trees I have picked from a local nursery look to be in 5-gallon pots and are 4-5' tall.

    I have a Redbud which thrives in my back yard. It gets sun until 2:00.

  • 16 years ago

    Harry, from full sun to only morning sun, I would site them as follows:

    Redbud
    Bloodgood
    Dogwood

    Cercis canadensis is native to a wide part of the country that routinely experiences hot summer temperatures - it is the state tree of Oklahoma! Regular summer irrigation helps but the species is considered quite drought tolerant once established.

  • 16 years ago

    We've had this debate a thousand times and by nature gardengal disagrees with everything I say.
    I live in georgia were we can go 60 days without a rain shower in the summer with temps no less than 90. In my observations, out of the three, Japanese maples in full sun look the best at the end of the season. As for the redbuds, for a tree that is not long lived to begin with, I wouldn't introduce it to an area it will be even further stressed. These may be native to hot sunny locales but they are mesic understory trees not often found growing in the sun and the ones that are don't look like something you want in your garden. Dogwoods in full sun don't look so great but survive and plenty of people who don't know better grow them in full sun.
    In my opinion your best bet is to plant trees that are adapted to a sunny location. You already know these aren't good trees for a full sun location but they will likely survive and hang in there but don't expect them to be prized specimens.
    If you still want to give it a go with these then Japanese Maple would be my first choice.

  • 16 years ago

    My vote, based on research and seeing these trees in Arbs (I've been considering the same three trees for planting this spring).

    Redbud
    Bloodgood
    Dogwood

    Anyone of these will be ok with the minimum end definition of full sun (6 hours), but none of them will be happy with a full day of sun.

  • 16 years ago

    It sounds like this is extremely climate dependent. Not a big shock since sun and moisture amounts can be very different in different places.

    From what I've seen here, both the Bloodgood and the Kousa can handle full sun. Redbuds are very brittle, and that one should be protected from wind, ice, snow, and heavy breathers.

    Something else to consider is that when the redbud is in bloom, it will clash with the Bloodgood leaves. Redbuds in general are a very difficult color to work with, Cornus florida being one of the few things they don't actively fight.

  • 16 years ago

    LOL! iforgot, you haven't been around GardenWeb long enough to have had this debate "a thousand times" :-) And it is not just me that disagrees with you - I am only stating what is well-documented by many other sources. You seem to be imposing your growing restrictions and issues uniformly to all other areas of the country. What may be appropriate or relevant to Georgia does not necessarily apply to everywhere else in the country and it might be helpful to remember that.

    I'd not think there would be many issues with the redbud's flowers clashing with the maple. It doesn't sound like the trees will be immediately adjacent to each other and the bloom time of the redbud and the Bloodgood in full leaf may not necessarily coincide. The redbud should be blooming about the same time the Bloodgood is just beginning to push out foliage. And many people might think the burgundy/wine red color of the Bloodgood would be complimented by the magenta flowers of the redbud. Personally, I don't care for pink OR magenta, but then it's not my tree!

  • 16 years ago

    Redbuds are native here and often grow in full sun on shale banks. Kousa dogwoods can also handle full sun here. BTW, I'm zone 6, not zone 5b)

  • 16 years ago

    I have seen all three growing in full sun locally. With varying degrees of success. Many of the least successful involve a poor tree just plopped in the middle of the lawn and left to fend for itself.

    My plan involves a delivery of blended soil/compost to make raised beds for these trees. A deep layer of mulch will follow.

    Does anyone have additional suggestions for a small distinctive tree, hopefully low-growing and spreading, suitable for the front yard?

    I've thought about adding a Doublefile Viburnum to the mix...

  • 16 years ago

    Small trees are not my forte but I've had good success personally with serviceberry in full sun. And I've seen a number of crabapples doing well in full sun. If you don't get more responses to your question you might try posting that question separately.

  • 16 years ago

    The reason I made a point to disclose my location is not to suggest that eastern PA is anything like my climate but rather to demonstrate that if the tree can tolerate the extremes here then it can tolerate the extremes somewhere less hot and dry. Sort of like the series of tests they put cars through to make sure they can stand up to everyday life. If it looks good after a summer of extremely hot weather and drought then chances are it will be the one that looks the best in an area with less extreme conditions.

  • 16 years ago

    Viburnum prunifolium makes for a nifty little tree. Tolerates (requires?) more sun than other Viburnums and spreads as it matures. I've been growing one in hot, sandy conditions and it seems to be holding up. Not exactly a rapid grower, but looks good all summer.

    I also think Hawthorns make distinctive small trees. Flowers are a bit malodorous, but the spreading, flat-topped look of a mature cockspur hawthorn always turns my head.

  • 16 years ago

    I agree with prunifolium being a nice little tree, does well in hot/dry sites. V. prunifolium is actually native to part shade conditions in our area.

    Again, agree on the cockspur hawthorn, especially the crusader. One of my fav trees in the yard.

    Serviceberry, Malus and the ones mentioned above, IMO/IME are much better suited for a full all day sun enviroment...they all (except Malus) can do very well in part shade locations as well.