Software
Houzz Logo Print
sherry_roma

White clay - does color matter?

18 years ago

(I posted this on the Soils Forum, but I thought my rose friends probably have some knowledgeable opinions, too. So I'm reposting here.)

In some areas of my yard I have a lot of white clay (maybe in layers mixed with sand) down in the native soil. Also, have a lot of limestone. Native PH runs a tad above neutral. I'm growing old garden roses which don't mind that PH, and I'm told they like clay and will grow even bigger in it.

My question is this: is all clay the same? I suspect not. Red clay must have different minerals in it. So is white clay a positive or negative in my garden. I've previously been taking most of it out, but I'm working on my last rose spot in the front yard, and there's a lot of it. If it would be good for my rose, I'll leave it (broken up into chunks smaller than my fist.) I also amend new beds with 50% horse manure compost to try to mitigate the nematodes in this Florida sand.

Thanks for your help on this.

Sherry

Comments (20)

  • 18 years ago

    i think the red clay has more iron in it to give it that red look.
    do you have to use much iron?

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, I have had to use it on Tausendschon in the form of Ferrous Sulfate. It doesn't like my alkaline soil. I used it in a newer bed this spring when I had some pale leaves with dark veins. My garden is new so don't have much to go on.

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    White clay (at least the sort we have here) is iron-deficient compared to red, and plants can get chlorotic without a bit of Ironite or the like.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, solicitr, so I just need to supplement with iron? I finished the bed today and left the chunks of clay in. Does that make any difference as long as I add iron? Hopefully, I don't need to dig it up again and remove the clay chunks. And will iron have to continually be added or does it accumulate in the soil and reach an acceptable level?

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    That you have limestone as well as the clay most likely (in my mind almost certainly) means the clay has limestone particles in it, and those are high in calcium. The abundance of calcium is raising the soil pH. The higher a soil's pH the less available the soil's iron is for plant roots to take up. (The higher the pH the more the soil's iron ions become tightly bound to soil particles and unavailable to plant roots seeking out iron.)

    Some plants handle this better than others and I suspect that's true of roses, too. My guess is the roses with a lot of R. multiflora in them (like Tausendschoen) are going to be the most intolerant of your situation (and Camellias, Azaleas, and Gardenias will be even worse, much worse). Yes, you're going to have to amendment the soil periodically with an acidifier such as sulfur, or regularly add extra iron.

    The good thing about the clay in a soil is that it holds onto water longer than sand does. It takes a lot longer for a heavy clay soil to get wet once it dries out, but then when it does get wet it takes a lot longer to dry again.

  • 18 years ago

    York Rose, thank you for the very good information. You answered all my questions well. I'll have to get my iron mixed and applied. I have a Marie Pavie that looks pretty shabby and slow growing that may need some, too.

    Thanks so much for the help.

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Dr Huey would be the preferred root stock.

  • 18 years ago

    A white clay in a white-ish limestone terraine will have almost no organics. That in addition to being probably poor in most trace metals.
    Is there a potter in your area who can tell you what specific kind of clay it is?
    There are clays that are so leached of any of the 'good' things that you almost have to start over.
    If you take a lump of your clay and saturate it with water, how long will it stay wet in the shade? If it stays wet well, then it does have some value.

  • 18 years ago

    Amending with horse manure is going to solve a lot of problems but not the lack of iron. And you can't 'build up' iron in the soil. It becomes locked in so it isn't available to plants. Just resign yourself to adding ironite any time they seem chlorotic.

  • 18 years ago

    jbcarr, I think you mean Fortuniana. I do have a few roses on Fort but most are own-root Chinas and Teas. Then I succumbed to some polyanthas because they're small. What the heck. Supplementing with organics, hopefully they'll last longer than without. Today I yanked a Sombreuil out of the ground that was doing less than poorly - virused, I think - so I can be ruthless, too.

    Ann, I will do that wetting check. Searching on the web, I saw that white clay is used for ceramics. Figures I'd get something that's devoid of nutrients. Hopefully, it'll make a good sponge.

    oldroser, I don't mind amending with iron, just had to know to do it. The addition of iron makes other nutrients more available, too, right? So it's a good thing. Gee, at this point I have to do what I have to do to keep these babies happy.

    Today I hit some sand/clay combo trucked in by the builder as fill. Man, drought turns that stuff - whatever it is - into cement. I'm too frail to be swinging a mattock. What was I thinking??? But I got Mme Antoine Mari in the ground today (after I broke the bottom out of the cement) along with Crepuscule and Jeri Jennings. Yesterday LeVesuve went in with the white clay chunks. Have I said that I'm liking my garden? It was nice today. Tomorrow I can go to work and rest up.

    Thanks everyone.

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    I disagree on the preferred rootstock. In all of Florida, fortuniana is still the best. Dr. Huey usually caves in within 3 to 5 years. Dr. Malcolm Manners has done a great deal of research on this matter, and I trust his advice.

    Hoewever, there are some OGR that will do fine own root.

    Sandy

  • 18 years ago

    Sherri, I have one spot in my yard that has white clay. It is the big middle island in my front yard. It came planted with a cherry tree and some junipers and hollies. I avoided planting anything it it after trying to plant some annuals there and hitting the 'playdough' as I called it.

    But Last year I took the plunge and planted some roses. I didn't dig down far, I just made an indent and mounded up the roses. I have own roots Graham Thomas, Crown Princess Margarete and Golden Celebration. They've been doing well so far. Then in the front, I put 3 Moondance and Frankly Scarlett. I'm having problems in one spot, I think because I'm competing with the roots of the cherry tree. They can't go down, so they've gone pretty far out. So I have to remember to keep those roses well watered.

    And this year I added 3 Barrone Prevost own root. Again, well mounded and I also added a lot of home made compost and shredded leaves to hopefully amend that soil to something the rose can survive in.

    In the back of this bed, closest to my house, I'm thinking of added some big teas. I have 12 bands right now in pots, so It's just a question of who goes where. I think what I'll do is put down a lot of compost and manure this fall and then let that sink in over winter and plant the roses next spring.

  • 18 years ago

    Sherry,

    I am very interested to know how your Jeri Jennings does. That is one lovely plant and I am hoping for the best here in Swampland. You're near Ocala, right?

    I decided to wait to order it, hoping that I would find out before I invest.

    I am resting at work today, too. Lol. I dug out a 6X8 foot bed, sifted the toxic rubble landfill and baby Sago Palm chunks from the sand. My next phase is to replace the sand along with alfalfa, dog kibble (for the worms), leaf litter and manure. Into that bed (later) will go Natchitoches Noisette, Blush Noisette and Archduke Charles. Maybe with Anna Marie of Montravel at their feet. The bed is teardrop shaped.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Anna Marie of Montravel

  • 18 years ago

    Buford, very interesting. White clay in the middle of all that Georgia red clay. Two things: if you're keeping your beds well watered (well maybe not since you're in a drought) but hypothetically, wouldn't that make the clay penetrable by the roots? I don't know - just asking. And second, maybe your roses won't mind the iron deficient white clay unless they have Multiflora blood.

    Thono, yes, I'm right in the city. Jeri Jennings has lovely growth, showing no disease (!!!). My first flowers look just like the photo on the Rogue Valley site. I forgot to smell her - duh. I think she's going to be a keeper! And you know, I haven't been mixing the alfalfa pellets generally in the bed until the last 3 or 4 roses. I put it in each hole but not out in the rest of the bed. Someone on the soil forum said horse manure compost is good, but the soil needs vegetative matter, too. So alfalfa fits right in there. Live & learn! Never heard of using dog kibble. What do you use - the cheap stuff? My dogs would REALLY go nuts if I started putting there food in the garden! I use Milorganite. The worms love that, too. I have NN (2nd year), and I saw a full-grown BN recently at a small nursery/rose garden near Ocala (Flemington). It was lovely. A nice, well foliated bush. I hope my NN fills out like that soon. Archduke Charles is really nice, too. AMoM is very pretty, too.

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    John Starnes, one of my top two Florida rosarians from whom I have learned the most, grows everything no spray. He says feed the soil and the plants will do well. they may get some disease, but they will throw it off and recover nicely. Also, the kibble helps bring in and keep the micro herd of worms.

    It can be the cheapest you can find and he also suggests that we add a bag of plain cat litter; non-clumping and scentless. This is granulated clay and helps the sand retain some water. Though I guess this is not an issue with you.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Starnes @ HMF

  • 18 years ago

    thonotorose, in southern ga they use the white clay in kitty litter.

  • 18 years ago

    Cool, I don't have to buy cat litter!

    Oh, gee! I forgot the sprinkler was running (for almost 5 hours!) - running down the gutter. Darn!

    Thonotorose, I still have mostly sand so it dries out pretty quick. It was staying damp for a few days, but lately in this wind and drought (what is it - 6+ weeks with no rain?) I've been watering every other day. Everything is bone dry. I've seen John Starnes' photos and articles. He's a great encourager of Florida rose growers. I don't spray either. I'm hoping to get mine to such a state of health and vigor that they never get blackspot. Ha!

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Today I hit some sand/clay combo trucked in by the builder as fill. Man, drought turns that stuff - whatever it is - into cement.

    Ever seen a recipe for making cement? If I understand correctly it's pretty much a mixture of clay & sand, with lime added. Wet it up, let it dry, and presto, as long as the proportion of sand to clay is right you've got cement!

  • 18 years ago

    That's what I got!

    Sherry

  • 18 years ago

    Viz. Ann's comment: clays can have the nutrients leached out of them? I learn every day.
    I have gray clay, alkaline and stretches of it very poor in organic matter. Where it's more dirtlike, with organic matter and capable of growing grass, it's great soil, while the potters' stretches I amend with abundant organic matter. I can grow most roses I've tried: Teas and Chinas, English roses, once-blooming old roses, most species, Hybrid Musks, Bourbons, Wichuriana climbers, Noisettes--they're all happy. I have few Rugosas, and R. laevigata was unhappy in the very clay-ey soil it was given, so that I had to pull it out, and I haven't tried Multiflora climbers yet, though 'Veilchenblau' is going in in the fall, so I'll see. Clay is GREAT for water retention. Unless there are strong objections to it for other reasons, I would treat is as a valued component of my garden soil.

    Melissa

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals