Software
Houzz Logo Print
maschnei

Am I losing my Austrian Pine?

16 years ago

I planted three Austrian pines about 5 years ago. They have done nicely except the middle tree began going brown last summer. The top of the tree is still green, but most of the lower portion is sparse and brown. The two trees right next to the brown one are doing great. Any suggestions or ideas?

{{gwi:348356}}

{{gwi:348357}}

{{gwi:348358}}

Comments (12)

  • 16 years ago

    Looks like it. Could be any number of things - chemicals, bugs, planted too deeply...impossible to tell with info given.

    Let's start guessing with:

    1. o Are there entry/exit holes in the trunk?
      o Is it planted too deeply?
      o Did you put tons of fert in the planting hole?
      o Is there herbicide used nearby & does that neighbor hate you?

    and go from there.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    I'd remove it. It looks to have some sort of needlecast disease; individuals vary in their susceptibility. The other two will fill the gap quite effectively.

    I'd also prune out the competing second leader in the right-hand tree.

    Resin

  • 16 years ago

    the middle has to go ..

    if not for any other reason ... you dont need it .. now that the 2 end ones have grown so aggressively ... i bet they will fill in the gap after spring flush ....

    your pine has pine cones.. so it is a conifer .... if you care ... [though conifers are trees .. go figure on that] ....

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Resin has a fair point that I'm trying to get to, but my concern is how it got that way, and why aren't the others suffering a similar fate?

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    look at the growth whorls between the 3 .. this one has NEVER been as vigorous as the others..

    how about improper ball and burlap when culled for retail sales??? even before we get to bug or disease ...

    not to mentions i suspect they were rather large transplants... and all the problems associated with that ...

    i will even further guess.. that everything brown on the first pic.. was the basic size of the transplant .... was i close???

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for all the input. I'll try and respond to some of the questions:

    -The trees were about half the size when I planted them several years ago. I don't remember exactly when.
    -I built up about an 18" mound with topsoil, compost, sand, etc as there is nothing but heavy clay in my area. I had lost 3 white pines in the same area previously due to poor drainage.
    -I can't see any visible entry/exit holes in the trunk
    -My neighbors don't hate me :), although I don't really want to see them, hence the trees (I'm sorry--Conifers)
    -I did some spot treatment of poison ivy with Round-up last summer. But, I did that on all three trees.

    Also, what is the "competing second leader" in pineresin's suggestion here?

    "I'd also prune out the competing second leader in the right-hand tree"

  • 16 years ago

    I see it. Upper right corner of the very first photo you posted. You see two trunks sticking up like antennae on a space alien. Cut one of those in half.

  • 16 years ago

    I bet the new mound soil wasn't incorporated into native, making a perched water table and weakening the tree. Maybe some fungi still in soil as well. Just take that declining tee out as they are too close anyway, and if somehow you were to save it it would be too close to the others anyway.

    Cut the competing leader off at the trunk, not in half. Bad practice, esp on conifers. We have a lot of Austrian pines around here that do the dual leader thing & need corrective pruning.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    Many thanks.

  • 16 years ago

    In addition to what everyone else said...

    That third (ailing) tree gets less air circulation and less sun than the other two. That could weaken it and make it vulnerable to other problems.

    In my area (Southeast PA) Austrian pines are highly susceptible to Diplodia tip blight, so that's one possibility.

    Here is a link that might be useful: DIPLODIA TIP BLIGHT

  • 16 years ago

    I hate to say it, but I think your tree is definitely a goner. While I am no tree expert, I am a passionate amateur, so I have learned a few things. I am 100% certain that your tree is suffering from Dothistroma pini, otherwise known as Red Band Tip Blight. It is a fungal disease that can attack any tree, especially from age 30 on, but it especially attacks vulnerable trees. I think I read somewhere that Austrian Pines should be spaced 15 feet apart, but I can't find where I read that. At any rate, the middle tree looks extremely crowded from both sides, which is going to make it extremely vulnerable to disease. This probably explains why the other two appear to be doing alright.

    The reason I am so certain your tree has dothistroma is because of your extremely valuable and informative closeup of the needles. If you'll notice, the outer halves of the needles (the tips) are brown, but the inner halves (the bases) are still green. This is the unique hallmark of dothistroma. In addition, it typically starts from the bottom of the tree and works it way up. Considering how few green needles are left on your tree, it is probably more dead than alive at this point. Since it is so crowded out by the other two, I would just remove it. Otherwise the other two might become vulnerable as well from competition, not to mention the high possibility of infection from this extremely contagious disease. Also for this reason, you should educate yourself on the early symptoms of this disease and for diplodia so that you can hopefully nip disease in the bud before it takes over your other two trees, especially since they have been so close to the infected tree. It is possible to stop the disease if treated in time, but infection can be hard to detect until it is too late if you aren't vigilant. Also, try to remove the dead tree in dry, non-windy weather if at all possible because heat, rain, and wind are how the spores are spread.

    I have included some links to government and university sources about dothistroma so that you can learn about early symptoms, treatments, etc. There are plenty more such sites if you google "dothistroma."

    Good luck, and sorry about your middle tree.

    Laurel

    http://lancaster.unl.edu/factsheets/087.htm
    http://extension.missouri.edu/extensioninfonet/article.asp?id=1709
    http://www.ipm.iastate.edu/ipm/hortnews/node/81
    http://urbanext.illinois.edu/ShrubSelector/detail_problem.cfm?PathogenID=58
    http://www.na.fs.fed.us/spfo/pubs/fidls/dothistroma/doth.htm
    http://www.forestryimages.org/browse/subimages.cfm?sub=688

  • 16 years ago

    Laurel,

    It could very well be Dothistroma, though I don't see any pycnidia and these symptoms can also be caused by other agents. Good to see an amateur pathologist! (I am an assistant professor of forest pathology).