noinwi - I guess I don't understand what you think is wrong with it? That organic material was added? That's needed to compost it. Normal. Should work for side dressing with no problem. Can't really see any composted manure used as a mulch in the usual sense of the word but its a good soil amendment. The texture sounds fine too - maybe a little dry is all.

So can you clarify why you are upset with it?

Thanks.

Dave

Well, I've noticed that a lot of "compost" sold is actually very little actual compost, and has a great deal of sand (or who knows what) added to it. Many of the labels are misleading, and a high percentage of fillers other than compost are in the bag. I, for one, resent paying a fair amount of money for garbage.

That's why I started vermicomposting, and I keep the worm condo in my house with no pest problems whatsoever. I have the Can o' Worms system, and it takes up little space. It is also user friendly, and can be done in an apartment. It's a good way to use table scraps (no meats) and other organic matter. The quality of the worm compost can't be beat.

Sandy

It wasn't as rich and "humusy"(is that a word?) as it used to be. It contains a lot of sand.
I mulch with shredded bark, but I like to put down a good layer of manure first. I also mix some manure into the planting holes along with some granular fertilizer and bonemeal. It's just what I've always done. I'm a creature of habit and didn't like the change in the mixture. I'm sure I'll get over it.
Thank you both for responding.

I've also noticed there is a lot of sand added to what we buy as "soil".
Whats up with that?

I don't understand any of the complaints. I guess I'd have to see the stuff. Some changes occur because people have requested it. Sand is not just an additive. Soil is rock that has been ground over millions of years (aka sand) and organic material. . . so why is that bad? It helps with aeration and drainage in the right ratios. Sand isn't just glass. It's the ground up minerals the plants get their micronutrients from. Super fine sand with water (clay) is what is below your natural topsoil that the plants are drawing up. If the plants you compost didn't have this available, your compost would soon be worthless by itself. Actually, you wouldn't have compost because you wouldn't have any plants to put in it. They would never fruit to reproduce. Sand would make the bags heavier and would cost a lot to procure for the simple reason of "filler". It costs a lot of money to ship sand as it is so heavy. It would probably be cheaper to leave it out if it weren't for the fact that minerals are good for soil. It would be much cheaper, if the goal was to "fill", to just use unfinished composted sticks and such from green dumps and tree surgeons. Before automatically assuming you are getting filler, check with the company that makes it and see if there is another reason they added it. You might find it to be a superior product. In case nobody knows, some sands are highly recommended as organic soil amendments in every book on organics I've ever read. Surely someone here uses green sand. . . According to Garden Web (Preparing a New Garden), your soil should be 40% sand.

They are right. I do NOT want to pay for sand. I have plenty of that in Florida.

I want composted manure. That use to be cheap like couple dollars a bag. Now you pay two dollars and all you get is ground up wood chips and sand with hardly any manure unless you pay over five dollars a bag for something better. Ace has the black cow manure which I think is good but you are paying premium.

The stores are getting this stuff from local/regional producers, so one person buying a bag from Ace Hardware or HD or Lowes is not going to get a product from the same source as someone buying the same bag at the same store in a different part of the US.

Those local producers are to blame, and the stores are to blame for selling this junk. I've complained to Ace that 'compost' had big lumps of clay in it and was so pale in color that it was clearly more soil than organic matter.

joe.jr.'s comment (2 up) that soil should have sand in it is fine if I was trying to buy topsoil. This thread is about the quality of bagged compost. Compost should not be diluted with sand, silt or clay just because it's cheaper than compost so they sell it cheap and skim a few more cents in profit.

Complain. Tell the manager, return it for a refund, make online comments, and make sure other customers hear you say that the product is substandard and you won't be buying it again. And don't. That's the only way.

Rule king doing the same bought bag of top soil it wasn't topsoil bye no means very 😞

Why was it not topsoil? Do you know what topsoil is?