Software
Houzz Logo Print
mpking828

Starter making horrible noise

19 years ago

So my 1984 Simplicy with the 11hp engine is making a horrible noise when I turn the key.

Looking at it, the starter is turning. (I can see the top of it spinning) It sounds like it's not engaging the engine.

The Motor is:

Model # 253707

Type # 0167-01

Code # 86010711

It made this noise the last time i used it, but the engine cranked right over, so I didn't think anything about it.

I paid $250 for it, and I've only mowed 4 times with it. I was hoping to get a little more time out of it before I have to fix it/replace it.

Comments (31)

  • 19 years ago

    It may be a stuck starter gear or a bad bendix. Rotate the flywheel manually and try again. The starter may engage after rotation. It may be that your starter bendix was sticking or it may be close to failing.

    Starter Bendix

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    Ok... Um.. easiest way to rotate the Flywheel? The machine is a hydro.

    I'm assuming reach under the machine, and spin the pully that drives the Blades

  • 19 years ago

    Turn the pully that is connected to your engine's crankshaft. A few degrees should be enough.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    I suggest you put a couple drops of oil around the starter shaft where it exits at the top of the starter. Your noise may be the result of stuck or striped gear AND dry starter shaft bearings.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Ok.

    I rotated the flywheel. Same noise. It's louder on different parts of the fly wheel. I thru a few drops of WD-40 in the starter shaft, and it's not quite as loud.

    Looking on the otherside of the engine, I can see under the cover, and see what appears to be the teeth of the flywheel. They all appear to be there, so I'm assuming my problem lies with the starter then.

    So what is a Bendex, do you think that's my problem, and is this something I can fix, or should I find a dealer?

  • 19 years ago

    Sounds like the starter drive gear(Bendix) stayed engaged with the flywheel the last time you started it, hence the noise when you last used it but ran OK. The starter should engage the flywheel teeth ONLY when the starter is being used, look to see if those starter teeth are turning when you move the flywheel, if so there's your problem. Starter will probably need to be replaced.

  • 19 years ago

    "few drops of WD-40 in the starter shaft"

    Note: WD-40 is only a very temporary lubricant. It is not what you need to put around your starter shaft. Actually it is a better starting fluid than lubricant. While this may not be what is causing your noise, the starter shaft needs to be lubricated occasionally,with real oil.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    I'm guessing the Bendix isn't sliding all the way to the end of the starter motor shaft.

    {{gwi:339491}}

  • 19 years ago

    Replacing the starter is a job you can probably handle. 4-5 bolts and 2 wires. Replacing the Bendix is far more complicated and if your like me, my time is worth more to me than monkeying with something like a bendix. You, even if your not a good wrench, can replace the starter in 20 minutes tops.

  • 19 years ago

    Replacing the starter gear or starter clutch is 1 roll pin out, 1 roll pin in after removing the starter (2 bolts). This starter will not have the type of retainer pictured which is difficult to remove/replace, unless the starter has already been replaced with a much later one. You probably just have a bad gear. I would only use genuine B&S starter gear when replacing.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Ok. Where do I get parts / new starter? Dealer? Online?

    Mike

  • 19 years ago

    Well I would not even consider getting a new starter. One, I don't think you know that the starter is even what is bad. Two, there are lots of good used B&S starters out there. Starters are not a weak point with B&S. Any B&S starter from an 8 hp to 18.5 hp single cylinder vertical shaft engine will fit this engine. Note, the starter gear from really, really old and from relatively new, will be different than yours. If it is a nylon gear, it will fit.

    If I were getting a new starter gear, I would get it from a B&S dealer so it would be OEM as I said before.

    Starters are available from various online, aftermarket and OEM Dealer sources.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Thank's Walt.

    A coworker of mine says he has a 8hp B&S motor he can give me the starter off of. So you have answered my question of whether it would fit or not before I even had a chance to ask it.

  • 19 years ago

    My 18 year old starter started making the stripped teeth noise. I just reversed the gear and used the side that wasn't worn. That was last spring, still starting right up.

  • 19 years ago

    "My 18 year old starter started making the stripped teeth noise. I just reversed the gear and used the side that wasn't worn. That was last spring, still starting right up."

    I think you posted this before and I posted that there is an up and a down to B&S starter gears. For $2 why bother?

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    WOW, I guess I better go out and remove it! but why it works and looks the same either way. For us that has to pay retail they are not two bucks.

  • 19 years ago

    "but why it works and looks the same either way."

    A B&S starter gear does not look the same "either way". You are perfectly welcome to waste your time doing such things but I certainly would not recommend it to anyone else to do.

    I have to pay retail for OEM parts.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Holding a 695708 B&S in my hand made in usa. See slight different in sides I take it the flat side goes up(but, it doesn't say). I also see a slight taper on one side of the teeth which would be up to ease engagement. When I flip it over the inside groove runs the same way (wonder how many of these are installed backwards???)

    It works walt in a pinch out in the sticks far far away from the city conveniences why not???? IMO it was a waste of time to drive 25 miles for a $4 dollar part. When the other side is prefectly fine.

  • 19 years ago

    The problem is leading unsuspecting people to think it doesn't matter which way they are put in. B&S made them that way for a purpose and even marked some for people who don't know which way is up. And sometimes, they will not work right if put in the wrong way.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Ok.

    I just pulled the starter off. It's definitily the bendix. It got stuck at the end of the shaft, and the motor sheared all the teeth off the nylon starter gear.

    30 bucks later, new gear and new bendix, looks like i'm good to go.

    BTW, the starter must have been replaced, because the parts pictured above, are exactly like what I got.

  • 19 years ago

    Ok.

    The directions for the installation mention using special tools to remove/install the C-clip that holds the assembly together.

    Should I just get the pliers and screwdriver out, and go at it? Or should I wait till Monday and take it to a repair shop.

    Mainly I'm looking to see if this is doable with normal hand tools, since I don't have the special Briggs and Stratton c-clip removal tool.

  • 19 years ago

    The C-Clip appears to be a snap ring (a clip with two small holes). You can buy snap ring pliers for about $8 at Sears.

    Sometimes you can grab a snap ring on the opposite side of the opening with regular pliers and pull it off. Reverse the procedure to install. See if you can pull off the old one with pliers. If you can pull the old one off, you can push the new one on.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    This "C-clip" will probably need to be carefully pried out with a small screwdriver. If you "spring" the C-clip open a little larger in the process of getting it out of it's groove, be sure to "squeeze" it back small enough that it snugs back into it's groove when you put it back on the shaft.

  • 19 years ago

    Some upside down starter gears will ruin the flywheel ring gear.

  • 19 years ago

    You mean the 30 bucks was just for parts? Wow, I think they saw you coming. IF your starter is indeed one of the ones with the "C" ring retainer, It IS NOT a snap ring and requires a special tool to remove and re-install OR a lot of prying and luck.

    The original starter for that engine would just have had a small roll pin to remove and re-install.

  • 19 years ago

    If the ring looks something like this,

    {{gwi:339490}}

    You can use generic snap ring pliers. Here are some examples. Make sure that the points that come with the pliers fit your ring holes.

    Snap Ring Pliers

    As I wrote earlier, you can buy snap ring pliers at Sears.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    As I wrote earlier, it is not a Snap Ring, Snap Ring Pliers will not work.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Well then, what looked to me like a hole in the ring must be a reflection in the picture that Bill posted.

    -Deerslayer

  • 19 years ago

    Took it to a dealer, he changed the part for me. (Helps having the special tools)

    The part(s) came to $27 at one dealer, and $22 at another. So I don't feel like I got taken.

    One question, Should I put grease on the starter gear where it runs into the ring gear. When I took the old one off, It appeared there was grease on there, but I can't be sure.
    Grease makes sense to me, but the directions made no mention of it, and I don't want to get any on the Bendix (I'm afraid it might get stuck again)

  • 19 years ago

    "One question, Should I put grease on the starter gear where it runs into the ring gear"

    No, it needs to be dry and clean.

    As for your price, I have never bought a new starter clutch, just starter gears for about $2. I have lots of starter clutches, complete starters for $15 and there are hundreds of good used ones out there.

    Walt Conner

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks.

    Looks like I'm back in service.

Sponsored
Custom Home Works
Average rating: 4.6 out of 5 stars10 Reviews
Franklin County's Award-Winning Design, Build and Remodeling Expert