Software
Houzz Logo Print
vitamaltz

Is This Rotting Maple Doomed?

16 years ago

This maple is only about 14 feet from our house, and I'm concerned. It was topped by the previous owners, probably more than a decade ago. The scars from the topping are now rotting; chunks of limb fall off pretty regularly, including from a limb that extended vertically from the top of the main trunk. I'm worried that the new growth will eventually be too heavy for the damaged stubs to support, and I worry that the main trunk may be compromised too. I want to get an arborist to look at the tree, but before I do, is there any advice or opinion anyone can offer based upon the photos? I'd be sad to lose the great shade this tree provides, but even sadder to lose a part of my house to a falling limb.

Thanks in advance. I normally hang out in other nooks of GW, and I really don't know the first thing about tree health.
{{gwi:358470}}From maple

{{gwi:358471}}From maple

{{gwi:358472}}From maple

Comments (7)

  • 16 years ago

    It's hard for me to be 100% sure what I'm seeing in some of those pictures and they definitely don't seem to tell the whole story. In other words, it's hard to give meaningful advise based on what we can see in the pictures. BUT, based on your text, I'd say you are on the right track by being concerned about the risks and by seeing the need to have an ISA certified arborist come out and take a look.

  • 16 years ago

    If that thing were on my property it would be gone. Notorious for weak wood and some clown topped it to boot. Not promising.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks guys. I'll make that call tomorrow.

  • 16 years ago

    vitamaltz, I agree the tree has outlived is usefulness. My sister had two very similar looking maples in her back yard. One is gone now, the other is still standing only because the kids love the tire swing attached to it and my brother in law can't bring himself to inflict their pin oak with the swing.

    Any plans to replant something in its place? There are other smaller maples. Japanese and Paperbark come to mind. Many many other types of trees as well.

    What kind of sun exposure does the area receive? Is it wet or dry? What elevation are you at?

    Fall is the next prime planting season so you have time to get this taken care of and plan ahead. You could probably get away with planting now, probably, but hey why not come up with a good plan.

    PS, this story is a great example of the topping problem.

  • 16 years ago

    We're at 1,300 feet. The tree gets sun until an hour or so before sunset. It's on a slight hillock in clay soil. We definitely want to put something else there... this tree gives our deck great shade, which also helps keep the house cool in summer.

    I know where other maples on this property have been cut to the stump that new shoots emerge almost immediately and grow really fast. I'm guessing this is b/c they have the benefit of a mature root system. Would cutting this near the ground and allowing one new shoot to grow from the stump be a viable option, or is that asking for trouble?

    I don't love the greedy shallow roots this thing has, and in some ways I'd love to have another tree there that doesn't suck the ground dry or fill my gutters with whirlygigs.

  • 16 years ago

    14 feet from the house .... what a nightmare..

    get 3 quotes.. and make sure the cutter has CURRENT ins .. make him show you the policy.. and call the ins co before he does work ...

    the chips make great mulch for the rest of the garden .... if you have the space to store it .. and maple is pretty good firewood ...

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, save the chips and wood if you have and use a fireplace. You'll have a good chance of getting mushrooms in the chips scattered in the garden as well.

    Dan