Software
Houzz Logo Print
piscesgirl

HELP! Need tree suggetions/opinions

19 years ago

I guess my questions are:

1) Should I do what the arborists say and remove the bradford pear tree?

2) What should I plant in it's place?

Story:

1) We have a large (30+ year old) Bradford pear tree next to our house. We like the fact that it offers our deck some privacy from the neighbors, however it has some problems. The tree is overgrown, way past due for pruning, was inproperly pruned by previous owners, and planted too close to the house for the spread of the tree (trunk is only 10 feet from the house). We called arborists to come and give estimates to prune it and already two of them have told us they recommend having it removed because of the poor previous pruning hack job, the trunk has already been split once and a middle large limb removed, and because of the constant upkeep on this unrully tree with a horrible branch structure.

2) If we remove the tree I hate the fact that we are going to loose all of our privacy. So if we plant a new tree I want it to meet certain criteria.

- be a flowering tree (since I will be loosing a flowering tree)

- not produce messy fruit (the tree is near a deck and I don't want a mess)

- be a fast grower (I want privacy as quickly as possible)

- Maximum of 20 ft spread (beyond that it is going to start hitting the house like the current tree is)

- Be fairly disease & insect resistant

- Have a decent life span

Any suggestions?

Should the bradford pear stay or should it go?

I have looked into cherry trees but I am concerned with their short life span and diseases. Same with Redbuds. Dogwoods seem to grow slow. Not sure about the kousa varities? Are their other forms of pear trees (non-fruit producing) that have a better branch structure and are not as unrully with growth habit? How about crape myrtles? I don't know much about them.

Thanks.

Comments (10)

  • 19 years ago

    I forgot to mention. The tree is going in a partial shade area.

  • 19 years ago

    Here are a few that meet most of your criteria:

    >Purpleleaf Sand Cherry (Prunus x cistena) *makes small fruit*

    >Redosier Dogwood (Cornus sericea) (makes very small fruit)

    >Pee Gee Hydrangea (Hydrangea paniculata 'Grandiflora')

    >Pussy Willow (Salix caprea)

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks for the suggestions, however these are more shrubs and very small trees. I am looking for something that is tall but with a smaller spread (about 15 feet). Anything that has short height won't even come up to the level of our balcony and thus won't offer us the privacy we are looking for when sitting on our balcony. The balcony floor is about 5 feet off the ground so the tree has to be at least a mature height of 15 feet.

  • 19 years ago

    Yeah and you also don't want a mess to clean up.
    Plant some arborvitae and go get some flowering shrubs. You'll get the flowers you want and the privacy. Or if you want long lived, strong wooded, privacy, attractive bark I really like European hornbeams, the columnar varieties offer slightly different shapes. No mess.
    If you want privacy on your deck from day one go get some 10 gallon leyland cypress in containers and place them on your deck. (seriously)

  • 19 years ago

    There is a columnar callery pear cultivar called Capital Pear (Pyrus calleryana 'Capital') if you would like that.
    It grows about 10 to 15 feet wide and 25 to 35 feet tall and grows moderate to fast. It has has better structural strength than Braford Pear.
    Pyrus calleryana 'Capital'

  • 19 years ago

    You could put up a trellis/lattice along the side of the balcony where you want privacy and plant vines in pots, either evergreen perennials or annuals, or a mix, as a temporary measure, for 3-4 years. Any tree that will give privacy quicker than in about 2-4 years in that situation will cost BIG bucks to buy and plant - you would have to buy one that started out about 15' tall, as trees usually need a year to settle in and begin to get taller. Most of the trees that are that tall, and are reasonably priced are young and relatively sparse on top. It's going to cost to cut down the pear and get it out of there, and get it cleaned up, anyway, so why spend a lot more?

    If you don't want Leyland cypress in pots, any other moderately sized evergreen in pots will give you the privacy at once, although the pots may take up too much room - I don't know how big the balcony is. An espalliered pyracantha, if you can find one hardy for your area, could work also, as could any other evergreen shrub.

    A Franklinia will mature at about 24' in 40 years, and has white flowers in the late summer/fall, with red fall foliage. It will take moderate shade. Koelreutia, golden rain tree, will mature a little taller in 40 years, flowering in summer with pendulous yellow blossoms - it has no fall color to speak of. It takes light shade.

    Redbud may be too slow growing and too wide, but it will be the height you want and will take shade. Cornelian cherry, Cornus mas, might do for you as it tolerates shade, matures to about 18', has yellow flowers, may have fall color but it does have berries that drop early.

    You may do better, as Quirkyquercus suggested, to chose a fastigate, foliage tree that will take shade, like the hop hornbeam (although it does grow, very slowly, to a greater height than specified), and provide your color with a shrub or vine, whether in pots on the balcony, or below in the ground.

  • 19 years ago

    firsthome, I would recommend Japanese Tree Lilac (Variety Ivory Silk) if you do a search on this tree you can see really good pictures of them.

  • 19 years ago

    A magnolia might work M. tripetala and M. virginiana are native up into PA. Hawthornes are also an option and are about as messy as a flowering pear or crabapple. American holy might work, but the few leaves it does drop are spiney to step on.
    The problem is that in general fastgrowing means either tall or shortlived, and often both. small slow growing trees can be purchased at a larger size, but the cost is usually prohibitive.
    What height do you need to provide screening? You don't like shrubs or very small trees, so I'm assuming the deck is elevated, or near a slope. This might help fine tune any suggestions.

    Ziggy

  • 19 years ago

    The Japanese Tree Lilac mentioned above does like full sun but will work in this location.
    The Korean Sun Pear is also a good tree for this spot and is stronger than the Callery pears. I have a beautiful one that is 10ft tall now and a great bloomer with fire orange fall colors.
    The magnolias will work if there is at least 6 hours of sun per day. "Elizabeth" or "Butterflies" are both yellow and spectacular when in full bloom. "Elizabeth" is vase-shaped with a creamy-yellow flower. Butterflies" is a larger, more spreading tree with a canary yellow flower.
    The Hawthornes are excellent trees. "Winter King" is an outstanding tree that will meet your needs.
    I would avoid "Toba" as it tends to have severe leaf drop in the summer.
    You may be able to place an ornamental crab apple in this spot. "Brandywine" has outstanding double-red flowers and grows well. There are many others as well.

    Good luck with your decision.

  • 19 years ago

    How about a Heptacodium miconiodies--Seven Son Flower. It's multistemmed, but pretty narrow, fast growing, and gets 15-20 feet tall. Blooms white in late summer followed by a long show of red calyxes.

    Another possibility is Magnolia virginiana - Sweet Bay Magnolia. Grows moderately fast, fragrant blooms for almost two months in late spring/early summer.