Software
Houzz Logo Print
conniemcghee

Cicada damage (photo)

15 years ago

So, a few weeks ago I stopped in to moan and groan about the coming cicadas, and was wondering if they would do extensive damage to my young trees. Looks like I have my answer.

So sad. This is my Chalk Bark Maple, recommended last fall by arktrees. Ordered in October, so in love with it - and now look at it. :(

You can see little slits on the bark where the females have laid their eggs. The top half, maybe more, seems to be dead. I can't tell yet if the bottom part is going to go. I'm afraid it may take out the whole tree.

I should have covered this tree, at least. The verdict a few weeks ago when I asked was that damage would be minimal and trees would bounce back, but I'm not so sure about this one. They have also really done a number on the Altheas/Roses of Sharon, but I'm not so worried about those. Fortunately, my Paperbark Maples (also very young) at this point seem untouched. Japanese Maple damage also seems minimal to none. Really, it's just this tree that has taken such a hit.

The cicadas should be gone in about two weeks or less. I'm waiting to prune until after they've disappeared, in the hopes that any females laying eggs will continue to do so in the already-dead branches, hopefully sparing me at least a few.

Any other advice? Do you think I'll be buying this tree again in the fall?

{{gwi:376175}}

Comments (13)

  • 15 years ago

    That is a sin and a shame; you must be sick. I can't tell how tall the tree is, but I see green leaves lower down, so maybe it will (cringe) die back to there and grow from a leaf node down there. Freaking cicadas.

  • 15 years ago

    I'm not sure how it is a sin for G--'s creatures to live out their lives according to Her plan...but misunderstandings notwithstanding, all one can do is hope at this time. And set some money aside just in case.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    connietn: Here between Murfreesboreo and McMinnville the cicada 'infestation' isn't as bad as around Nashville, but it's bad enough. This is the third one I've gone through here, and as I said to my wife, "if I'm alive during the next one, I probably won't give a d**n". Anyway, some of my stuff is still recovering from the devastating Easter freeze of '07 and now this. I'm almost to the point of not wanting to go out and enjoy my collection. The cicada's seem to target everything I've planted, especially expensive and slow growing things, but I know its not really so. I have a fairly large chalk maple that so far doesn't seem to be affected very much, but the stewartias, viburnums, cornus etc.- I don't even want to think about. Thinking back on the last time, I know that not all the branches affected will die back or break off, so that's a consolation. When I get really gloomy feeling, I think about the nurseries in Warren County. A triple whammy for them-the freeze, the drought of 07-08, and the economy.

    Okay, enough moaning and groaning. It looks like you still have some green near the bottom of the tree. I would cut it back to below the last slits to just above the green. Make the cut at a slight angle to shed water. Make sure all grass is away from the root zone and apply a mulch, but not against the stem. And make sure the tree does not suffer for lack of water this summer. It looks like the spring rain machine has shut off. There has been a major weather pattern change and if it holds we could be in for a long, hot, dry summer.

    The periodical cicada's are part of the nature of things here in the south. The local vegetation is adapted to it and will survive to live another day. BUT...Mother Nature can be a real, well you know what LOL.

  • 15 years ago

    That was an expression of sympathy for my loss - thank you, lisanti, for that. :) The tree is about four feet tall. It does appear that, so far, the bottom half isn't affected.

    Dan, curious: Have you ever lived through a brood emergence? Not just a couple of annual cicadas sprinkled about - I'm talking a full-scale emergence for six or so weeks. The only person in this city who seems to be enjoying it is the entomologist with the County Extension Office. He's having a ball (but even he complains about all the dead bodies and discarded shells). It is universally agreed upon to be a huge nuisance.

    I have seen them in drug stores and grocery stores. They get into your car. Your home. If you dare to bust out a weedeater, you'll be covered with them in seconds. There is a layer of discarded shells an inch thick (not exaggerating) under some trees and shrubs. The noise is deafening - Vanderbilt released a story the other day about potential long-term effects on hearing. Dead bodies crunch under your feet everywhere you go.

    And now, they're eating my Chalk Bark Maple. Freakin' cicadas is exactly right.

    Twelve more days...twelve more days...

  • 15 years ago

    Hey Ken, thanks for the reply! It is great to hear from someone local. I remember the freeze of '07 too - we were in another house then, but my crape myrtles and Japanese Maples took a bad hit. Glad it hasn't been as bad for you all over there. Funny how it seems to be in small pockets. Even in Nashville, there are some neighborhoods that are much worse than others. I have a friend in Lebanon who says she's only seen two or three. Their neighborhood is more than 20 years old, so - it's weird!

    Ken, do you think I should cut it now, or wait 12 days until they're mostly gone? Big dead branches in my garden are driving me kind of crazy. The Altheas in my yard look really horrible, much worse than this. Those I don't worry about so much, but I don't think the Chalk Barks are very fast growers. :(

    Good point about watering. That's what my husband was saying yesterday too.

    Come on, Chalk Bark! Live!! You can do it!!

  • 15 years ago

    Oh - I'll correct myself before someone else does not *eating* my Chalk Bark Maple, but destroying it. I do know the difference. It's very early.

  • 15 years ago

    Connie: since the little beasties haven't finished yet, if you do cut now I would cover what's left with something to keep them out. If it were me I would do surgery now, the sooner the better. Judging from your foto, I'd say your tree has a better than even chance of survival. Your husband gives you good advice, keep the tree watered, and NO fertilizer.

    After I posted above, I went out to watch the sunrise, and sure enough several branches at the top of my chalk maple are brown, along with some on a couple of sugars. Yesterday they were fine. As the days go by, more and more damage is showing up. The calls here have peaked I think, but all the damage is yet to show. It will continue through the summer and into next year. Chalks are slow growers, mine is about 12 years old and maybe as tall, and branched to the ground.

  • 15 years ago

    Dan, curious: Have you ever lived through a brood emergence?

    AFAICT, my experiences have nothing to do with the G--esses' plan for Her creatures and whether Her plan is a sin.

    Natural processes notwithstanding, I hope your little tree makes it.

    Dan

  • 15 years ago

    Wow. OK. :) At any rate, thanks for pulling for it. I hope it makes it too.

    Ken, I think you're right. I went out and touched the top and it broke off. :( So I guess I'll go ahead and get rid of the damage, and wrap the rest. It looks like I have about 30" left at this point, so maybe it will make it. Water, water water!

  • 15 years ago

    Update: Well, sadly, pretty sure it's going to be a goner. I trimmed off what was obviously dead, but I think there's more dead below that. There are slits in the trunk all the way down to about 6" from the ground. I watered it well just for grins, but I won't be surprised if the rest is gone by next week.

    I ordered this one last year, but since then I have found a place that has them locally - so at least I won't be out shipping again.

  • 15 years ago

    there is no reason to presume.. it is dead below ground ... is there??? if it is.. then the cicada's just finished it off .. or were irrelevant ...

    i would leave it be.. and see if any dormant buds break lower down .. PRESUMING it is NOT a grafted tree ...

    with no insult to the root system.. you might be surprised it MIGHT bounce back.. but for the fact that it is a recent planting .... who knows ...

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    It's a shame you didn't cover them, especially the smaller plants.
    I see in your other thread that you considered it and decided not to?
    I'd be ill with regret :(
    Mucho sympathy.

  • 15 years ago

    I think it will come back from the roots. I have a chalk bark maple that the deer have gnawed on for several years. The poor thing keeps sprouting back (and they love the tasty new leaves). I transplanted it there originally so it was in a similar circumstance.

    I really should cage it! Fingers crossed for you.