Software
Houzz Logo Print
penserosa

Dogwood trouble - pic

18 years ago

Hello - We planted a pink flowering dogwood in full shade in May '07. This year it didn't flower, which I understand would be due to its putting energy into the root system. However, each branch leafed out and the leaves have looked very good. When it looked a little wilted, I watered it. But in the past week or so (?), the leaves are systematically shriveling up, beginning at the tip, until they just hang there dead. I watered it deeply last week, and am wondering if it got too wet? Previously I just stood there with my watering wand and gave it a good drink, but last week I set the cheapie lawn sprinkler under the tree and turned the water on very low, and left it for a while. Was that my mistake?

Thank you for any ideas you might have.

Pat

{{gwi:385295}}

Comments (13)

  • 18 years ago

    Pat, if it's a Cornus florida, the common 'Dogwood', it needs more sun. Full shade is not going to make the tree thrive

  • 18 years ago

    Rats - I wanted to plant it in partial shade but my husband insisted that the nurseryman told him to put it in the shade. I see all the dogwoods out in full sun and they look great, so I wanted it to have at least partial sun. Is it possible to move it now? When we planted it, it was reasonably large, i.e. not potted - the rootball was in burlap and it was about 6 feet tall. Do we dare dig it up?

    Thanks for your reply, Paula.

  • 18 years ago

    Yes, it can be moved, but not now. Do it this fall, after leaf drop, or late winter/early spring, which might be a better time. I'll let the other posters chime in on their opinion on best time. Dig as large a rootball as you can.

    The nurseryman was possibly meaning to imply dappled shade, as in understory of taller trees. It can grow in full shade , part, and full sun. However, experience taught my trees class instructor that full sun is good for better resistance to anthracnose.

    It sounds like it may be suffering from heat scorch, possible from hot dry windy conditions. If your region is experiencing dryness, as I am, water the tree once weekly with a deep soaking to keep it in good health until transplanting.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Cornus florida

  • 18 years ago

    Bumping this up in hopes of input from other posters. Paula, do you think the full shade is contributing to the leaves drying up? Or do you think that's all about the water? It has definitely been dry here, though I've tried to keep up on watering.

    Also, I did feed it with Holly Tone and later read in this forum that dogwoods don't like that stuff? Bummer, since it says it's for dogwoods...!

    Thanks very much for your advice.
    Pat

  • 18 years ago

    You pressed my buttons when you said you 'fed' it with Holly Tone. Those leaves looks like some I've seen on plants burnt with too much salts. Did you follow the recommended dosages? The active ingredient in Holly Tone is nitrogen in the ammoniacal form.

  • 18 years ago

    Calliope - yes, I did use the recommended amount - at least, I thought so. It was based on the size of the trunk, and I just eyeballed it rather than measured, so maybe that was one of my mistakes. When it didn't bloom, I thought it needed fertilizer - had I done the research first I would have known that it was putting its energy into the roots. Is there anything I can do to rescue the tree, or is this something it will survive on its own when the nitrogen eventually dissipates or is used up?

  • 18 years ago

    I would concentrate on watering. Don't feed it with anything else - although I don't think the Hollytone was necessarily the "wrong" thing, since my dogwoods are quite happily growing in their native, acid clay! If you can dig down about 4-6" and see how wet or dry the water is at that depth, you might get a better idea as to whether it is getting enough water.

    I would not wait until it looked a bit wilted to water, but would water based on how dry the soil is - stick a finger to the second knuckle into the soil and water if the soil is dry at that depth. A pointed stick will work as well - you just need to get down 2" or so. If it is still wet, then wait to water, and check another day. Water WELL, slowly and deeply, so the water gets down to the bottom of the roots. Hand watering with a wand can work, but it needs to be watered over the entire root area.

    I doubt the sprinkler was "wrong" in terms of the amount of water applied, but it's a generally wasteful way to water, as a certain amount of the water can evaporate before it hits the ground, depending on temperatures and wind conditions.

    If you haven't mulched, do so - as widely as possible; no deeper than 4"; and put no mulch in the inch or so next to the trunk. When you do mulch, then check UNDER the mulch to see it the tree needs water - which it should do less often than without the mulch.

  • 18 years ago

    It's definately not because the tree is too shaded. I have understory dogwoods who by now are dwarfed by the dominant trees around them and the leaves are quite healthy. Since this tree has been in a year, and done well, and this issue sprang up rather quickly and systemically, something in the balance has shifted. What could be a proper fertiliser amount will definately be more potent under low water conditions. That potentiates the effects of the salts. The active ingredient in fertiliser are salts. If this is the case, water will help to dilute it. If you are having issues with not enough water this spring, the advise of the last poster is pretty much on the money. Sometimes trees, especially young ones will completely defoliate and then recoup. It's an insult to the tree, but not necessarily fatal. You'll see soon enough whether new leaves shall come on to replace the old ones.

  • 18 years ago

    Many thanks to all who replied! Where would I be without Gardenweb? I went out and checked about 4 inches down, and the thing is dry as a bone. Now to find it a new home my husband will approve of.

    Thank you dibbit, Paula, and Calliope. :-)

  • 18 years ago

    Checking back in...so it sounds like it wasn't getting enough water. Slow, deep water x1 a week. Slow = your hose set at the base of the tree on a DRIP for 12 hours. The faster the flow, lessen the time. Test it. Easier to do this way, no loss through run-off, no taxing your well or water bill.

    Going back to the shade issue, as long as it's not deep shade, like close to the north side of a house, it will probably do ok where it is. They are adaptable to sun/pt.sun/shade

  • 18 years ago

    It took my C. florida 4-5 years to get a decent bloom going so patience is needed too regarding blooms. Mine is in almost full shade. It gets a little late afternoon sun after 3.

    I saw a bit of anthracnose in mine in its early years and now I reluctantly do preventative fungicide spraying very early in the season and a couple of times throughout. I hope as the tree gets bigger it can fight anthracnose on its own when spraying is not practical.

    I tend to give a lot of water the first planting year then back off. Is the soil especially sandy (too well draining)? Is there big tree root competition nearby sucking up moisture? Whats your weather been like? air humid? blazing heat? frequent thunderstorm/downpours?

    All things to consider, but anthracnose is highly likely. Wet conditions accelerate it. Do you clean and remove old (possibly diseased) leaves in the fall?

  • 18 years ago

    Pat,

    You should be just FINE if you're in partial shade.

    If you do some research you'll find the Cornus species in nature grows best as an 'understory tree', somewhat under the canopies, and the protection of much more massive specimens of the forest (present and past) such as oak, beech, hickory, and American chestnut.

    For one thing, until flowering dogwoods become somewhat mature, their tender bark is EXTREMELY susceptible to canker.
    For another...you want to make sure that your dogwood is protected from potential damage that may occur from 'frost cracks' that often result from an aggressive winter sun... in the morning...abruptly 'heating up' a very SMOOTH, tender, and FROZEN outer bark, and cracking it, literally, like an eggshell, on the south- south east side of the tree !

    If / when flowering dogwoods get to the point when the bark begins to 'furrow' naturally, then the danger of frost cracks greatly diminishes.
    But canker can and will always remain a potential problem with dogwoods of any age, so you have to watch your pruning technique.
    You also should know how to ID an existing canker problem, and how to do minor trunk surgery with a sterilized locking pen-knife to help correct it over time.

    What I did to help prevent this type of frost crack damage was to plant my Cherokee Princess directly on the NORTH- NORTHWEST position of the house, about 12' back from the front corner of the house.
    I also did this so it would eventually 'frame itself in' with the left side of our ranch home, from the perspective of the curb.

    Yes....dogwoods do tend to prefer things acid.
    But I recommend spoon feeding them only organic-based acids, like cottonseed meal and blood meal...and ONLY at points in time when they're NOT under stress from heat !

    I'd steer clear of synthetic acids.
    Save them for your rhodos and azeleas.

    I aerated and topdressed the entire lawn with compost this spring...and I was sure to compost the trees, too, including this red dogwood, which, by the way, was a free "throw a way" tree from a Cincinnati nursery 4 or 5 years ago.
    (:

    And the incorporation of this aeration / composting within the grass-dominated dripline, to some degree, also helps increase downward percolation of natural rainfall and/or irrigation water, instead of the (typical) 'sheet wash' scenario that is oh-so-common here with the heavy clays in S. Ohio.
    This helps to make the less frequent, "deep watering" of the dogwood more meaningful, and less expensive as well.

  • 18 years ago

    You guys are great! Thanks for every single reply. I am happy to report that after giving it a good soaking, new leaves are already appearing. I watered it Saturday for several hours and again last night as it was already dry again a few inches down. This time I left the water on all night and today it really does look happier. Hope is renewed!

    Many thanks for all the good information.
    Pat