Software
Houzz Logo Print
darth_talon

A few questions...

15 years ago

I looked at Soil FAQ Page. Answered a few questions...now a few more have popped up...and maybe a few to see if I got things straight cause I feel like a dummy. lol

1.) Soil, compost, Mulch. What is the difference for these three? I gathered how to create compost and what can be used for mulch (Have plenty of the stuff around) Soil is just the dirt on the ground? (For me, it's practically sand and possible clay)

2.) I read that wood ash is okay but ashes from a BBQ is frowned upon. What about cigarette ash? I've gotten mixed messages with this one. (I'm asking on this cause I have a ceramic pot that I swear the first layer is nothing but ash)

3.) Any apartment renters: Do you do a compost pile? If so how?

Comments (18)

  • 15 years ago

    Darth, I'm also a bit of a newbie, but I might be able to give some insight on #1.

    Compost is the stuff you make by throwing together vegetables, grass clippings, leaves, coffee grains, wood chips, etc., in order to make a nutrient rich material that you can use for feeding your plants. Just search 'compost' in the dictionary or wikipedia and you can find out more about it easily.

    Mulch is the material that you put on top of the bedding your plants are planted in. Common mulches are wood chips and leaves, but you could also use compost material (typically prior to it being completely composted, so that it continues to compost and then leach into the soil). Mulching serves a few purposes... it just looks better than bare soil/dirt to most people... it also helps to keep weeds from coming up. And it can also help feed your plants over time (as in the case of using compost as a mulch, or wood chips that will take a long time to break down).

    Soil I'm not as sure about, but I see soil as what your plants roots are planted in... what supports it physically and what is currently feeding the plants.

    Hope that helps a little.

  • 15 years ago

    So basically compost is really what others call fertilizer. Okay, i get what compost is, I get what mulch is. Thank you. Now just need get a better understanding on what "soil" is lol Cause if soil is really nothing but dirt (like my desert sand) then I have plenty of it.... more then compost. :) On the flip side, I can take over the backyard (to a point) and the front yard for growing stuff. :D

  • 15 years ago

    I would agree that compost is fertilizer, as in it obviously fertilizes the soil, but generally when people say 'fertilizer' in everyday communication, I find that they usually mean something that you buy at the store and sprinkle in the soil. Subtle difference. I tend to hear non-organic farmers using the fertilizer, while organic farmers use compost (though there are organic type grain fertilizers you can buy as well).

    For soil, and someone might correct me here... yes, just desert sand is soil. Clay could be soil I suppose, if that's the top layer in some areas... or dirt, or any combination of those plus the organics and silt and such mixed in. 'Soil' doesn't really tell you anything about what can be grown in it, that's why you generally hear the question, 'what KIND of soil do you have?' As I've been asked when I said I have a yard full of dirt... well what the dirt is made up of is the important thing to know.

    You'll probably want to 'fertilize' that desert sand with some finished compost, or store bought fertilizer or whatever. Find out what your plants need first, then enrich the sand with what they need. Then put mulch on top, as mulch will also help retain water from evaporating out as quickly (which I would guess could suck in the desert).

    Anyhow, hope that helps.

  • 15 years ago

    well it certainly clarifies "soil" to me. And keeping things moist out here isn't as easy when you're trying to grow things from seed. I'm not 100% on the clay part, as I haven't dug anything anywhere. My little seeds are currently sitting in potting soil in a cardboard egg carton bottom. It's only been there for a day... but keeping the soil damp when the seeds need sunlight is a little tough. Not sure if I'm doing things right or what. I check the dirt though every evening when I bring them in.

  • 15 years ago

    Soil is the mix of mineral particles and organic matter that makes up the surface of the earth we live and walk on and where the plants grow.
    Compost is a soil amendment, not a fertilizer, made from a mix of vegetative waste that has been worked on by bacteria and digested into something different then the original matereials.
    Mulches are materials that are placed on the soils surface to aid in 1. "weed" suppression, 2. soil moisture control, 3. soil temperature control and, 4. to add organic matter to the soil if the appropriate materials are used. Compost could be used as a mulch but mulches cannot become compost unless they are piled up so the bacterial can convert them.

    Dirt is the stuff you track into the house and get yelled at for doing. Soil is what your plants grow in.

    Those ashes from you BBQ will contain fats which are, usually, not something good to add to your soil and if you use commercial charcoal briquets they will contain "stuff" you would not want in your soil. Whether to use the ash from wood depends on your soil. What is your soils pH? What nutrient is missing from your soil? Do you need Calcium or Magnesium?
    Plants need both Ca and Mg and if they are out of balance those plants cannot properly utilize either one.
    To the best of my knowledge no one has done a study of what cigarette ashes do, or don't do, to soils. Knowledgable people do not smoke cigarettes so what the ashes might do is of little concern to them. People that still smpke should be more concerned about what the tobacco is doing to their bodies then what the ash might do to the soil.

  • 15 years ago

    heh well that definitely answers the soil question.

    As for the cig ash, I guess I'll be doing an experiment.

  • 15 years ago

    I am not so sure BBQ ashes contain harmful fats - they would burn off - but I would not use them anyway because of the high pH and potentially elevated heavy metals from the use of coal in the briquettes.

  • 15 years ago

    I don't have BBQ ashes.... the BBQ we have is a propane tanked one. but there's a container of potting soil just sitting there with a layer of cigarette ash sitting in it.

  • 15 years ago

    I would think it would take an awful lot of cigarettes to have much of an effect, regardless of what's in them...toss it in the compost.

    Tobacco itself does have insecticidal properties, so the butts, maybe not.

  • 15 years ago

    OT, but could be handy...
    Very few seeds need light to germinate. Warmth is the thing. I usually put my seed tray inside a plastic bag, which stops evaporation.
    I think you'll struggle to start seeds/keep seedlings alive in egg cartons as the area for soil's so small and the cardboard allows evaporation.
    Used plastic containers with drainage holes poked (from inside so water doesn't get 'caught' on the little plastic volcanoes you create).
    I chuck all sorts of stuff round the garden, but I wouldn't use cig ash. Where there's ash, there's butts and I hate butts. They really are full of toxic gunk.
    I have a house and a compost heap, but I know people in apartments who compost using the bokashi method, then bring it to me for my garden. Win/win!

  • 15 years ago

    tox@ coolness.

    feij@ I don't see very many if any butts in the container. I think it's just the ash sitting on top of the soil. I have plastic grocery bags to help the cartons? Otherwise to help them along I have little glass jars for a little extra room but not much. I think I need a few more plastic containers that I can safely put holes in... and what's a bokashi method?

  • 15 years ago

    You'll be way better off if you slip a bag over the carton than nothing, but I'd recommend collecting things like yoghurt pottles etc. There's always plenty of plastc stuff around! Proper drainage is really important.
    Make sure you check for germination daily, as the seedlings need light as soon as they emerge. I try to check/remove bag in the evening, so the seedlings have a night uncovered before getting hit by the sun.
    It'll be easiest to search 'bokashi' online, someone out there will have explained it better than I can.

  • 15 years ago

    I hate butts. They really are full of toxic gunk. ;-)

  • 15 years ago

    Okay... is the bag suppose to help keep moisture in? and I've got maybe 12 plastic things ready if need be... 6 more and I'll have enough to cover what's in the carton if all of it grows.

    I actually reread the instructions on my seeds' packet and learned I need to keep them indoors until they start sprouting leaves. =/

  • 15 years ago

    Bokashi is another way to make compost, usually requiring you to spend your money on "special" breeds of bacteria to digest the materials.
    Covering seed starting trays with plastic sometimes helps hold moisture in the soil which sometimes can help seeds germinate better. I have done it both ways and found that with some seeds it does help while with others it does not. Tomatoes, peppeers, and egg plant seeded into starting trays that are covered with plastic and then placed on top of the refrigerator germinate faster then do seedling trays not placed on top of the refrigerator. However, the time difference between trays placed on top of the refrigerator and not covered with plastic is so insignifigant as to not warrent using the plastic.

  • 15 years ago

    Oh dear, Jon. We don't use 'butt' like you lot, so the unfortunate double-meaning escaped me!
    For me, covering with the plastic bag makes a massive difference by reducing evaporation and maintaining even moisture. If seeds dry out once, that's it for them.
    OP, I'm hoping we're on the same page with the plastic thing: for eg, if using a 6, 12, or larger egg-carton, just slip the bag over the whole thing. I use individual recycled seedling punnets. Any old smallish plastic containers with drainage holes will do though. I line them up in old roasting dishes so I can water from the bottom when the plants emerge.
    If you can get a container with medium-low sides that fits the egg-carton in it and allows for bottom-watering, I'd recommend that if using egg-cartons, but I'd still push to use something other than egg-cartons if you can.
    kimmsr, I assumed from the op's question re apartment dwellers and composting that there would be no place to do 'normal' comost. What composting method would you recommend in that situation? I know of people who create their own EM, so money's not necessarily an issue.

  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    1. A.Compost is not necessarily a fertilizer. You have to give compost time to breakdown if you got enough soil mixed in with your compost you can add: Red wigglers, or Eisenia foetida, are the best compost worms. Unlike your everyday night crawlers, they live well in close, highly populated conditions and don't burrow. Which will speed up the composting process however Red wiggler worms can eat about half of their weight in food every day. This means if you put one pound (16 ounces) of worms (about 1,000 worms) into your bin, you will be able to feed them one half of a pound (8 ounces) of food every day.

    B. Mulch can add nutrition content but normally doesn't (grass clipping make a good mulch with nutritional value at quicker disposal but it still needs time to break down best for outdoor projects). Its generally in the form of wood chips. If you put a thick enough layer on will help with varying things. 1 Moisture content of the soil (by preventing evaporation as quick) 2 Some pest (like fungus flys by keeping the top dry and soil still damp enough for plant.) (certain chipped wood repels different insects as well). 3 Help with temp control (harder to freeze ground with mulch also harder to dry out soil in summer by keeping the ground cooler)

    C. In general you don't want to use a lot of sand for soil it general inert on a lot of nutrition value there are however cases were you can use things like sand or clay but that's generally in hydroponic systems and they tend to use clay more cause it hold water better than sand. Soil to grow without a highly monitored system needs a few things to grow plants. I'm not gonna go deep into nutrients because most potting soils and fertilizers are fine if you remember a few things. High nitrogen to grow, high phosphorus to flower, Always use half intended direction in general so you don't burn out your plants with to much nutrients. One thing people mostly forget is bacteria. Just like your digestive system uses bacteria to help digest food. Bacteria in soil helps release nutrients. Another good thing for soil is worms. Some are better then others but what goes in a worm comes out healthier for your plant than before the worm ate it. The reason is worms have most the bacteria needed to digest bits of soil in there digestive track. and because there digestion is nothing like our the good bacteria and other microbes are easily distribute around the soil. not to mention they aerate your soil which breaks up dirt allowing roots to grow easier but also add oxygen to the root system and easier drainage of water. Your best bet is to go buy some potting soil from the store (if you add worms to compost or soil in gardens a good amount of sand will help the worms digest they use the sand like teeth in there digestive track.)

    if your looking for good worms for your garden you want

    Alabama Jumper

    (Amynthus Gracilus)

    Their thick skin allows them to live in soil ranging from sandy to heavy clay. They also burrow deeper then some of the other worms making them ideal for outside garden.

    Look up worm casting for more information about how worms can help gardens.

    I can not take credit for this information. I was pasting info from many different sources into a notepad. when i did my outdoor garden last year and again with a indoor one this year.

    2. Ash

    All i can tell you is my firsthand experience here. When i lived on a farm i helped with burning the fields a few times. Which i was told prepped the soil for better growth. I've used Ash from campfires and they work well. However the problem with ash is you can use to much. Outside its harder as rain and area will spread it out. In a pot its lot easier to change the pH of the soil, over-fertilize, and over-water. So id stay away from doing it often.

    3. You can make a worm farm outta a few 5 gallon buckets. Worm farms give you two things. Worm Tea, Worm Casting. neither are high in any particular nutrient but it wont burn out your plant (though with casting you are suppose to mix it with your soil not straight use it for soil), and the nutrients are in the best form readily available for the plant. Its very easy to search for info on worm farms in google and YouTube. That about the smallest way i know and you could put it on a balcony or in a closet.

    Hope this helped any looking.

    oh hints on sprouting seeds. Go get some cheap dollar store party shot glasses. Fill bottom with paper towel. wet towel put seed on top or some say in between i put on top so i see root start and make sure it don't get to much water. then cover the whole in saran wrap. You only need enough water dampen the towel in it no puddles needed. The moisture with humidity will sprout it in no time just make sure you transplant it shortly as there's nothing for the root to feed off but water. Also be careful about breaking the root your better off letting it grow on its side then breaking the root. It will self correct to find the sunlight.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals