Software
Houzz Logo Print
gardenfanatic2003

What do you attribute your WS failures to?

17 years ago

From looking at past threads, it sounds like many WSers have some containers that do not have any germination at all. What do you think might have been the problem with those particular containers?

Deanna

Comments (23)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi there,

    I sowed two containers of cardinal flower and my sprouting was a failure. I got barely any sprouts in one container, zilch in the other, and the seedlings all died. :(

    I sowed one container of blue poppies and did not get one sprout.

    I am trying them again this year.

    I think I used containers that were too shallow and the soil mixture dried out too much. The planting directions and subsequent research I did on cardinal flower state that it likes a moist medium--don't let it dry out.For blue poppies, they like some moisture and some sand in the growing medium, and I filed the itty-bitty seeds just a bit. I used a number of grocery broasting chicken containers last year, and I don't think they allow for enough soil, so they dry out quickly. I am sticking to milk jugs and 1/2 gallon juice containers this year. :)

    For some other failures or spotty germination, I don't think I packed the soil down in my first 10-20 containers that I sowed. I think this caused seeds to sink too deeply or not have enough moisture or soil. Lots of heaving occured. I make sure to tamp down the soil and not worry about using "too much" in each container.

    Cheers,
    Nora Belle

  • 17 years ago

    I think most of mine died from lack of watering since I had almost 100% germination but lost the seedlings. I get busy with the rest of the yard and garden and think they can manage just one more day. Sad to say, they often can't. I've promised myself to do better this year.

  • 17 years ago

    No germination at all?

    It's always the same thing everytime. Infertile seeds.

  • 17 years ago

    Infertile seeds

    poor soil that turned into bricks so that the roots couldn't grow into the soil.

    drowned seeds from 12 inches of rain and no matter how much you added drainage holes, the soil couldn't dry out.

    critters that decided to either use your container for
    1. a play toy and dragged it all over the yard
    2. dug out all the soil
    3. the neighbors cat who used it for a litter pan (they moved away 2 years ago and took the cat with them

    Birds that love to peck through the air holes and pick out the seeds.

    Somewhere along the line in the past 8 years, I've gotten every kind of seed I've sown to grow.

    Germination rate is 90%+ every year.

    Fran

  • 17 years ago

    Great question!
    Ibid the bad soil.
    I also had trouble with Blue poppies, but my problem is not in germination, but I put things out in the garden too soon.
    Impatient!
    Last year Yvonne's salvia which I really wanted, died in the cold. I am trying them again this year, I'm also trying again blue poppies.
    I also sowed more generously this year.

    ellenr

  • 17 years ago

    Hi,
    I actually heard that for poppies ( and other stuff) it is good to plant them in shallow containers, so that they can't form a tap root until they are in the real ground. this way they transplant more easily. Is this true?

  • 17 years ago

    As best as I can remember, everything I have ever sown has sprouted. Some dried out, some turned into a slug meal. Even the things that I sowed that were considered iffy... sprouted. Like my Baptisia australis and Columbine... that I waited forever for, sprouted.

  • 17 years ago

    There are no failures, just opportunities to learn.

    1. Not removing screw caps from jugs and liters

    2. Failure to follow the FAQs regarding ventilation, drainage, and soil depth.

    3. Too much water, not enough water, compounded by #2 above.

    4. Not giving seedlings some weak fertilizer when I couldn't get them planted out quickly enough.

    5. Raccoons dumping containers.

    6. My husband. It's always his fault! :)

  • 17 years ago

    I beg to differ on the 'it's always infertile seed.'

    That may be the answer to no germination, but not to the original question.

    Personally, I've experienced 'failed WS' due to planting the seeds too deep. I'll go to dump a "failed" container, and find that many of them did, in fact, germinate, and were trying desperately to reach the top and didn't because I had too much dirt on top. Oops.

    Other reasons include user-error kinda stuff like "why isn't this container draining?" A) Well, it could perhaps be because you forgot to put drain holes in the bottom (comma, you bonehead)

    Or wow...cute little seedlings (today) and tomorrow it's a handful of perished babies because I forgot to put holes in the saran wrap- DOH!

    So there is such a thing as WS failures...but generally, I'd venture to guess it's from 'user error' because if you do it right, it works flawlessly, not because the system itself is flawed.

  • 17 years ago

    Ok, so the title said "WS failures" and the discussion talked about 'germination.'
    So shoot me for answering the title.

  • 17 years ago

    Umm, I think "It's always the same thing everytime. Infertile seeds" was some very dry humor.

  • 17 years ago

    I plan to blame any failures on garden gnomes sneaking onto the deck and stealing the seeds.

  • 17 years ago

    Good idea, AJ. I think garden gnomes are the root (ha!) of many of my garden ills. :)

  • 17 years ago

    I think I've had a few containers that got too hot and the seeds fried before they could germinate. No I'm not going to blame myself for not moving them to a more shady area, or venting the tops more ... uh, it was the high altitude ... yeah, that's what it was.

    Bonnie

  • 17 years ago

    What do you attribute your WS failures to?

    Too much TLC, not enough TLC, the fact that things don't always turn out the way you wish. Lessons learned. No regrets. Movin' on.

  • 17 years ago

    I attribute my failures to the "survival of the fittest" theory.

    If they cant survive my methods, I dont want em.

    howz that for tough love
    :)

  • 17 years ago

    "uh, it was the high altitude ... yeah, that's what it was"
    yep, what Bonnie said... it's the searing scorching sun rays we get at high altitude, really! DD says "no, it's yer High Attitude" LOL!

    Anyway, if I forget 'again' to move the baby sprouts OUT of direct sun and into semi-shade somebody come shoot me because I will have shown I am not a worthy Plant Parent...

  • 17 years ago

    Adiro said: "I actually heard that for poppies ( and other stuff) it is good to plant them in shallow containers, so that they can't form a tap root until they are in the real ground. this way they transplant more easily. Is this true?"

    I don't know. Never heard this, but it is an interesting idea. Too late for me as I've already sown them, but if anyone find this works pls advise.

    It might not be too early to mention, as some have above, the frying of sprout babies - yes very cruel. :)

    For newcomers be aware the temp inside your 'mini-green-house' can be as much as 20 degrees higher than outside.
    Be sure to read the FAQ's re gradually uncovering the containers and placing them in shade or semi-shade.
    Thus shall your sprout babies be saved and not fried.

    ellen

  • 17 years ago

    Ellen is exactly right on that! I like to explain it this way... when you put your jugs and containers out and they are covered it's just like parking your car. If you park in the sun on a warm day and go get in the car, it can be very hot! The more you open the windows when you park that car in the sun, the cooler it gets. Same thing when you add more vents in a container.

    Winter Sowers, don't leave your babies in a hot "car"!

  • 17 years ago

    Adiro's suggestion for sowing in shallow pots came after a comment about blue poppies (meconopsis) - I just wanted to point out that meconopsis don't form tap roots at all so I wouldn't recommend shallow pots or planting out very early for these - they aren't hard to move around once growing well (assuming you have them in the right climate). No tap roots, don't rush them.

  • 17 years ago

    Umm, I think "It's always the same thing everytime. Infertile seeds" was some very dry humor.

    No, it wasn't dry humor or even meant to be humorous. It really is MY experience.

    Infertile seeds don't sprout.

  • 17 years ago

    I agree with Trudi,they don't sprout if they are infertile or immature. I had this experience with a few containers last year,I know that is the problem with them, because I held seed back and obtained more and compared the seeds.:)


    The biggest culprit for me last year was shallow soil and a bad mix of soil. The containers that had the mix I made didn't do too well,I used peat and perlite. I will not do that again,apparently that isn't something I am good at! :)
    3 inches is a number to stick to,I am going to do 4 inches for my perennials this year just to be safe! ;) Of course some things like alyssum don't need the deep soil,but it seems the majority does. The containers I used didnt seem to effect germination,except colored pop bottles,it seemed there was slow germination and the plants didnt grow so fast in them,after being planted in the ground the plants took off,so I am assuming it was the colored bottles. Maybe they give the illusion of too much shade? Filter out important rays? I am not sure,but they are off the containers to save list for me! I used a variety of containers last year. Being my first year,I wanted to experience as much as I could and fast...lol..Germination was not an issue in the rest of the containers I used,it was the convenience of removing the plants that came into play in determining what I will use again.Milk Jugs ,clear pop/water bottles (2 liter and smaller),Ice Cream tubs, the top of cake dishes from the grocery store(these are awesome over pots),and kitty litter containers,are all ones I will use again for sure!:)

  • 17 years ago

    I see immature and infertile seeds all the time. They aren't going to sprout no matter what. There is always someone who says you can save them and they will ripen. Hmmm.

    Poppies WS just fine. Plop them out early with the first true set of leaves in HOS and they will thrive. They are a no-brainer.

    I think my greatest WS moment was when I was sowing Mexican Hats and I face planted in the snow in the backyard with two full jugs. Those darn things sprouted anyway (months later) and started a line of hats that I ended up giving away rather than tending my own garden. Thanks to WSers, I am back in MH and ready to share.

    Really, this is easy. Listen to Trudi.

Sponsored
AIS Renovations
Average rating: 4.5 out of 5 stars15 Reviews
Custom Craftsmanship & Construction Solutions in Franklin County, Ohio