Software
Houzz Logo Print
santi_rodriguez

Planting Method?!?

18 years ago

After much experimenting and failure (and reading here at the forums) I have succesfuly managed to plant and acre give or take, about 18 saplings (and counting) of different species of different kinds of trees now, they've been alive for a year now, compared to the few months my previous attempts had lived.

I have used the following method:

My first concern that I noticed was hervibores, horses, bovine cattle, you name it, I planted a sapling and they ate it. So the first thing I did was fence the whole area and make it animal proof, the only thing that can get by now are mice and hares, but not any big predators.

Then the ones that didn't seem to appeal to the beasts I lost to lack of humidity during the hot summer. See I bought a piece of land on the country-side, but I live on the city so I only go there once a month or twice a month most of the time, except for the holidays were I stay a few weeks. So after much reading and trying I found out that water and weeds are essential to be controlled. For this I did the following:

After the tree was planted I laid a 6 page thick layer of newspaper, all around the tree say in a 1 and a half foot radius around, and wet that thoroughly. On top of that I laid a thick layer of dried leaves (in my case eucalyptus, which are available all year round as there are 5 large trees on the area). And on top of that I added a generous amount of cattle manure and wet that thouroughly. I never allowed the leaves or manure to touch the trunk of the tree for rotting issues I read about, so I left a small inner circle around the trunk. After I did this I solved the watering and weed control, even in the hot summer without rain for three weeks the soil underneath retained moisture. After a year I tilled all the decay thats left around the tree, and repeated the process. I also took care of fertilizing with this method. The resulting compost of this mulch I observed is all the fertilizer they need.

The third point that I took into account, was soil structure. The soil I have is quite good a bit on the clay side, but as I dug the hole (twice as big as the root ball), I mixed the soil with compost or rotted manure. This plus the addition of mulch every year keeps the soil in optimum conditions.

And last point is the pesty little ants, I went through hell to battle them. The first thing I did was to find the nearest ant hills and destroy them adding some ant poison to them.

And then to the trunk of every sapling I tied a white plastic bag(don't know why but it seems that white repels ants) and on that bag I sprikled powdered ant poison and was never bothered by them again.

The next time I go I'll take some pics and post them here.

I posted this to recieve suggestions and improvements on my method from more experienced gardeners, and arborists, and also to share my experience.

Santi

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    Well, your first problem is amendments added to the planting holes. No (none, zero) research data supports the use of soil amendement when doing single plantings. there's a couple of different reasons for this, the main one being to avoid the interface between coarser amended soil with the finer native soil. If the tree was containerized, you often will have a double interface of very coarse container mix, coarse amended backfill, then finer native soil. The time you would definitely amend the soil is if you amended large areas such as beds or even yards.

    I would also be concerned about your mulching method with the newspaper and manure. Was the manure composted or fresh? Even if fresh, after a season, the manure will be composted enough to make it suitable for weed growth. If concerned about weeds, you can put down landscape fabric then a wood chip mulch 2-3" thick on top, or either till in 1-2" of compost to a depth of 8-12" over the entire area or simply place an inch of compost over the entire area and mulch on top of that.

    Third, annual mulching, if heavy, to the same areas will result in a rise of the grade of that area, causing roots to grow more up than out.

    Lastly, keep in mind soil is recommended to have only 5-8% organic matter. Compost is not fertilizer, but does have some nutrients. The problem is one compost pile will not have the exact same nutrients as the next pile. Essentially, you shouldn't rely on compost or manure as a fertilizer. While on this topic I will say just go ahead and a get soil analysis to see if you need nutrients or organic matter.

    Just my two cents.

  • 18 years ago

    I agree with the concerns mentioned by Stompede. Amending the soil used to fill the planting hole is usually not a good idea. Drainage issues and root growth limitation are two potential problems with this practice.

    I also have the same concerns with the way the trees were mulched. But, the one thing I absolutely would never ever consider doing would be to "put down landscape fabric then a wood chip mulch 2-3" thick on top." This would be the best way to guarantee an eventual weed maintenance nightmare. Anyone that has had to fix this mess from a previous homeowner that didn't know better knows what I am talking about.

    I agree that compost is not the same as fertilizer, but, in most cases, compost would be far better for the trees. Fertilizer is usually not required or even recommended for trees unless there is something missing in the soil. Trees depend on compost for much of their nutrition, for a natural mulch layer, and for overall soil health in their native environment. In some ways, I think of fertilizer as a vitamin pill and compost as good wholesome food.

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks for your advice!

    Question tho, mulch or no mulch? So far it has helped me a lot with humidity. Maybe instead of working it into the soil around the tree, when it is decayed, just spread it around the base so the roots won't grow upwards and then add the new layer??

  • 18 years ago

    Mulch is great (just about a necessity for me). I have at least a 5' diameter mulched area around all my small trees. I use Glyphosate or Roundup with preemergent to help control weeds.