Software
Houzz Logo Print
mauirose_gw

Three years is too long

18 years ago

Again and again i have read on this forum that a rose should be given a minimum three years grace before judgement. Surely there are exceptions? Roses that get too big, roses that smell funny, roses that have major disease issues, roses that hold onto their blooms long after they should? Three years seems like a long time to keep a rose you really don't like. Especially with a 12 month growing season like mine.

OTOH some things might be worth waiting for-bigger bloom, better form, faster repeat, more fragrance. Three years is maybe not so long to wait to fall in love.

Am i getting this wrong?

Comments (17)

  • 18 years ago

    No, I think you're getting it right.

    We have had roses here, which were perfectly good roses, but which neither of
    us liked at all.
    If you plain don't like it, why continue to look at it, year after year?

    There was one very memorable modern Shrub Rose which actually came
    to us as an "extra."
    It had abundant, tho controllable, vigor, bloomed all the time, and was
    completely disease-free.
    On the down-side, it had no fragrance. But most importantly,
    the color was such a screaming meemie red that, everytime we looked in that
    direction, we might as well have had flash bulbs go off in our faces.
    It clashed with EVERYTHING.
    Both of us detested it, so we dug it up after a year.

    Jeri

  • 18 years ago

    I've come to believe that somewhere inside something will tell you whether to hold on or to let go. We have only so much time to live and only so much space to devote to roses, and that has to be weighed against the possibility that you might come to love the rose or it might decide to get its act together. I bought a China rose, Carnation, which many people really like, but the color doesn't please me. I'm not getting rid of it now but it gets only one more year. General Gallieni ended up on the compost pile because I didn't like the color, but it was then replanted in a less conspicuous location and now I'm glad I rescued it. Huilito is a china rose that doesn't please me in many ways but the darn thing blooms so much that I'm giving it another year or two to learn to appreciate it and perhaps grow out of its disadvantages. I think what I'm trying to say is that the rose police won't lead away in handcuffs if you don't give a rose three years. Guidelines are not cut in stone and your garden is your domain; just do what seems best for you.

    Ingrid

  • 18 years ago

    In my personal experience with roses, I find that it generally takes 3 years in the garden for me to assess adequate information on the rose's blooms, growth habit, foliage, hardiness and health. Every once in a while, great qualities are visible immediately, as are the irritating, unacceptable qualities and I don't concern myself with "further testing" to determine whether to keep the rose or not.
    Molly

  • 18 years ago

    Not all roses deserve a three years' grace in our garden. Time and space are truly precious.

    1. There are roses that I simply do not like - those never get past our garden gates. I am sure most of us have a similar list.

    2. There are roses that do get past the garden gate, usually because of impulse buying, sometimes because of artful enabling. But as soon as the blooms show up, alarms bell start ringing, I can't stand the rose, it's got to go. Those are shovel pruned or given away pretty quickly. One such rose was Hot Cocoa. I must be one of the few people who hates the colour of it that much. Why did I get it in the first place? Well, it was because of all the iniatial hype when it was first introduced.

    3. The 3 years' grace discussed in this thread refers to this third category. In general, these are roses that produce flowers I like, but just couldn't decide if they are worth the trouble or the precious spot in the garden, due to other issues (disease resistance, growth habit, etc.), and whether there are redeeming features prominent enough to overcome it's negatives. An example is Papa Meilland with his ugly knees.

    The above applies equally well to other plant groups in our garden.

  • 18 years ago

    Three years grace applies only to own root roses. Grafted roses had better look good a heck of a lot sooner. Otherwise why even bother? Then there is the flower form and color. Sometimes you KNOW the second you see it bloom for the first time that this rose is just not gonna cut it. Case in point: Marchessa Bocella (Jacques Cartier). Lots and lots of rosarians love this classic Portland, and to its credit the bush was fine enough. The flowers however ... URGH! The petals are pointed and have a tendency to look messy when the blooms are fully developed. The entire reason that I grow antique and reproduction roses is because their blossoms are at their most beautiful stage when fully mature. Otherwise, I might as well grow Hybrid Teas. So it got shovel pruned the first year.

  • 18 years ago

    Then there are those of us without any standards. As long as it lives (it doesn't even have to thrive), I'll grow it. On the other hand, I haven't run out of space yet. Also, for history's sake, I am willing to grow less popular roses, especially as I start digging into the 'back 40 [feet].'

  • 18 years ago

    I usually give them at least three years if they are own root. They need time to establish before I can tell anything about the mature bush shape, how they bloom, etc. If they are leafless and blackspot prone from the beginning, they have to go. In my climate, disease resistance doesn't improve with time, in fact I've found that a rose that is fairly clean the first year will often defoliate every year after that. I did dig up one rose that was perfectly healthy because it bloomed and the color of the bloom was nauseating to me. I couldn't stand to look at it :-)

    Carol

  • 18 years ago

    Rose breeders look at their seedlings their first year, and throw out most in the first year. You, however, have the pick of the pick. By the time the rose got to you, 10,000 seedlings have been discarded. Sometimes, though, it's obvious that I just don't like it, for one reason or another, but when I hold back, and watch it for another year, I start to see what this rose is about, and what it can offer. Others, though, make an instant hit, and keep hitting stronger and stronger each passing year. Like Fair Bianca keeps hitting. Hansa keeps getting less and less liked in comparison. John Cabot - has its spectacular beauty.

  • 18 years ago

    Threeeee years, yes I am giving them three years but it's hard. Can't help but notice that my purely impulse purchases are the ones that are on probation-- Coffee Country and Night Owl to name two. The one that's growing on me is Lion's Rose aka Lion's Fairy Tale. I want to see what the fall flush has to offer! and also, will it eventually become a bush rather than a small collection of canes? KWIM?

  • 18 years ago

    I think and feel that gardening is about satisfaction and enjoyment, peace and serenity. One can learn a great deal of information on this forum, but after you gather the facts, do what you want. If you don't like a rose for some reason, replace it, you are the boss. That said, I have given some roses more than three years and have been well rewarded. Just two examples, Orfeo did not even bloom the first year, barely the second year and this, it's fourth year has not been with out sprays of beautiful, stinky, big red blooms. It was worth the wait. Boule Neige is a difficult rose, sending up beautiful, healthy canes but no buds. I prune back in the spring, hoping for some lovely fragrant blooms. Last year I had one, however this year I have had at least a dozen. Was it worth it? For me yes, Boule is so lovely, like snowballs in summer. This rose is 5 or 6 years old.

    Do what you like and enjoy your garden.

  • 18 years ago

    I am performance oriented (read: judgemental), I guess. Mine are judged when the go into the ground. Do they grow well? Do they struggle through winter (that alone puts them on notice)? Prodigious growers and bloomers ensure their own survival. Because I only want to grow hardy, carefree, and healthy roses for my zone, I am picky. That said, if I think a specimen was weak and I want to try again - I do. Just ask Louis Odier! :-)

  • 18 years ago

    If I'm not thrilled with a rose I will usually move it to another spot and I might SP it if it still doesn't perform . Two roses that did better with a move were HTs First Prize and Fragrant Cloud. They only needed more sun. I moved a Rosetti Stone which has not done so well but since it's a smallish rose, I will find another spot for it. There is usually a reason a rose does not do well. Root competition, too little sun, too little water, whatever.
    I also love to give roses to someone with slightly different conditions and a willingness to take on a challenge. One that I gave away still is not doing well and I suggest they SP it. Just no hope for that one.

  • 18 years ago

    Are we talking about roses that just came out last year? I would think most roses have plenty of information and comments along with pictures. Of course i am a sucker for a mystery rose if it's a freebie. I usually tend to buy roses i like, and the ones that don't do well generally die on their own.

  • 18 years ago

    The one type of rose I ALWAYS wait several years to evaluate are cuttings I root myself. They are by definition own root, and teeny tiny. I almost shovel pruned one once - it was a "mystery rose" from our neighborhood. In the first 4 years it grew 12 feet high, but never ever bloomed, not even one flower. I asked for expert advice, and was told to feed it, and wait. Low and behold, the following Spring it was covered with the most beautiful roses - huge, transluscent pale pink blossoms, nodding down from above - just gorgeous. It turned out to be the hybrid gigantica Belle Portugaise. It blooms first in my garden, along with the banksaie lutea which is next to it. Turns out the pale pink and the pale yellow look fantastic together, and both roses are now HUGE, so they put on quite a display - people think I planned it on purpose, but it was really an accident. Now I wait until a rose is full size and blooming before I make any decisions about it.

  • 18 years ago

    I once bought a poorly grafted "Boule de Neige", a rose I've always loved, it was the last one for sale at Regans end of the summer sale, and the rootstock had only been partially budded, sending canes up on only one side of the bush. I do wish I had shovel pruned it early on, it teased me horribly, sending out 2 to 5 blooms a flush.
    I've noticed that several of the more artless Teas, take a few years for their blooms to transoform from underwhelming to breathtaking. That happened in my garden with "Ducher", "Angels Camp Tea" and "Le Pactole".

    Lux.

  • 18 years ago

    Bluesibe in No.Calif: Boule de Neige tends to bloom on old wood. If you stop pruning it and let it develop a bit, you may get a spectacular performance. I love this rose! A lot of the once-blooming old roses need to be pruned AFTER they bloom; you might try that with yours.