Software
Houzz Logo Print
tessiess

Which willow for willow water?

I'm going to start trying to grow some roses from cuttings and would like to use willow water. Thus I want to get my own willow tree. If you use willow water yourself, what willow tree do you grow/get the branches from?

I would prefer to get a willow that is on the small side and hopefully isn't the most invasive. Something in the range of 15-20 feet tall would be fine. I have a spot in the yard where it would be away from any structures or plumbing pipes, so the roots couldn't do too much harm. However, I don't want a really tall tree there. Any suggestions? If it is especially pretty, even better!

Melissa

Comments (14)

  • 15 years ago

    I think that any kind of willow will do. I cut branches from a weeping willow in the Sacramento cemetery. Like me, you might be able to spot one where you could get permission to cut a bit or where discreet removal would not be noticed. They grow wild along the river here in Sacramento.

    If you want your own, an alternative would be a curly willow. A friend grows his in a large pot, so it doesn't get much more than 12 ft high. It's an interesting plant and the branches are great for arrangements. Another friend grows hers in the ground, where it's at least 25 ft tall but not a huge tree. Both of them simply stuck a branch from a flower arrangement into soil and it rooted.
    Anita

  • 15 years ago

    Since I don't have room for a large willow tree, and for all the reasons Anita mentions, I grow a curly willow in a large pot, 8 or 10 gal., with a deep saucer. It's it part shade.

    Here's a picture of one growing in a pot. It will get bigger and thicker than this. Mine gets cut back occasionally as I use the branches for different things. It's a beautiful graceful plant.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Curly willow in a pot ...

  • 15 years ago

    We have a curly willow in the ground, but a couple more of them in pots. It's probably THE easiest plant to start from cuttings, too.
    Studies indicate that willow water is a very good root stimulant.
    Rooting hormones are also very good root stimulants (we like Dip 'n Gro -- a gel) ---
    But using BOTH a rooting homone AND willow water REALLY increases your take.
    Clay likes to give cuttings an over-night soak in willow water with a little "Nature's Nog" added.

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    Thank you all. There seems to be a trend here.;) Curly willows are soooooo pretty too. I was shopping at Forest Farm and was feeling overwhelmed by all their choices. Which to pick when there are so many. Some of the curly willows don't seem to want as much water as others, and that also makes it a good selection for my garden conditions. Thanks again all!

    Melissa

  • 15 years ago

    Okay: how do you make willow water? We have a big wild population of them here. Thanks,
    Melissa

  • 15 years ago

    We used our native Salix caroliniana when we did our willow water experiments in 1999. We used a willow water that had already been shown to strongly promote rooting of mung bean (a standard test of root-promoting ability by a substance). We tested the double musk rose (R. moschata) and 'Fortuniana', both of which are known to be somewhat finicky about rooting. We compared with a control (no hormone), several concentrations of Dip-n-Grow, and several rooting powders. What we discovered was interesting: As expected, the controls did not root at a very high rate of success. However, the surprising thing was that willow water alone did not increase rooting over the control. The higher concentrations of Dip-n-Grow as well as #3 powder gave excellent rooting, as expected. But when we combined a high-auxin rooting hormone with willow water, we got the best roots of all -- high rates of strike, as well as larger numbers of larger, more branched roots than with the auxin-based hormone alone.

    Of course our results might have been different with other rose varieties, but for these two, that's what happened.

    A bit of background on willow water, that is often misunderstood by most rosarians who use it: They assume that it provides auxin, for the same effect as a rooting hormone powder. However, that is not thought to be the mode of action. Rather, it is assumed (but never solidly proven) that to root, a cutting needs adequate amounts of auxin as well as some other substance that has never been elucidated, but which the willow seems to be providing. Plants with plenty of both don't need any treatment, and their cuttings root easily. Plants that lack adequate auxin will benefit from an applied rooting hormone containing an auxin, but will NOT benefit from willow water alone, since it is thought to provide the other substance but not a significant amount of auxin. Plants that have plenty of auxin but inadequate amounts of the other substance should be stimulated to root by willow water alone. Plants that lack both auxin and the other substance would benefit from treatment with an auxin-based hormone as well as willow water, combined. While this whole concept has not been proven, it does explain the observed results with a good number of plants.

  • 15 years ago

    Anybody try just dropping an aspirin in water, since salicylic acid is the most active ingredient in willows.

    I just lost my 40' curly/corkscrew willow. She was old...There is also a Scarlet curls, which doesn't get quite so large. Willows are water hogs and most require a lot of water (hence they prefer stream banks). There is a desert willow, and some arctic and alpine willows that do better without so much water. A good site to look at willows is www.bluestem.ca. They have a huge collection, from ground cover willows on up.

  • 15 years ago

    Catsrose is right about corkscrew willow being big. My two corkscrew willows are at the height of a 3-story building. I planted them as babies in full sun and almost lost them when I skipped not watering just for one day. If you grow any baby willow, start them in partial shade. My neighbor took 10 branches of my trees, and stuck them in a partial shade spot. She never watered them. They are really big now.

    I was reading the instructions on how to make willow water from eHow: boil the chunks, then strain. It doesn't make sense, because boiling will kill all the enzymes. I wonder if a better result can be achieved by crushing RAW branches in water? Vitamin C, pantothenic acid, and all plant enzymes are destroyed by heat. Even the enzyme which helps to digest milk, Lactase, breaks down in heat.

  • 15 years ago

    The friend who gave me the curly willow start cuts hers back every winter or two. It grows back fast as a thick shrub and never gets over 12 or 15 ft. tall.

  • 15 years ago

    I've wondered the same thing as catsrose has asked, does aspirin dissolved in water provide the same whatever-it-is that willow water adds?

    catsrose, maybe we should try and see.

  • 15 years ago

    Strawberry, my DH makes it like sun tea. Cuts the stuff up rather small, puts it in a big clear jar that once held dog cookies, and sits it in the sun for a day or two. I can't IMAGINE boiling it.

    Gean, You might, but I tried it, and it just made icky, cloudy looking water. This may have been, in part, because most aspirin these days has an enteric coating. But I really like the product of willow and water better.

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    While willow extracts do contain salicylic acid, that material has never been shown to promote rooting, nor is it believed to be involved in the effect that willow water has.

    We've also used Dr. Welch's directions, as well as the sun tea method. Whatever is in willow water that has its effect does not seem to be altered by boiling.

  • 15 years ago

    Malcolm said it for me: the active ingredient in aspirin is derived from willow, but willow contains a lot of other substances as well. Aspirin won't necessarily substitute for willow when it comes to rooting roses.
    I appreciate all this information: thanks, folks!
    Melissa