Software
Houzz Logo Print
flaurabunda

Can anyone identify this pest?

16 years ago

May was rose slugs. June was JB's. July was the Cicada Killer. August was Cucumber Beetles. I guess this bug is Version 5.0. Every month I see a new pest!

These just appeared over the last 2 days, and I shot pics of the top of the leaf & the critters who have set up camp on the underside. Damage & habit is similar to rose slugs, but they aren't the right size or color for that.

{{gwi:324770}}

{{gwi:324771}}

{{gwi:324772}}

{{gwi:324773}}

Anyone familiar with these munchers?

---Laura

Comments (10)

  • 16 years ago

    Laura
    You need to start walking past your rose bushes faster so you don't see these things. I'm sure I have similar problems but I don't look for or see them so they don't bother me.
    Always looking for problems takes much of the pleasure from growing roses. Having a no spray garden means I have to ignore all these things so I don't look for them. The miminal damage they cause is not worth worrying about.
    When you see the critters, use your fingers to smash them. That'll save a lot of time and get rid of much of your immediate problem.

    Your best source for insect identification is Baldo Villegas. His website is linked below and his e-mail address is on his website.E-mail him your pictures for an ID.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Baldo's sactrorose/rosebug website

  • 16 years ago

    Rose leaf skeletonizers.....

  • 16 years ago

    Probably a type of sawfly larva or rose slug--there are several different kinds. Squish 'im.

  • 16 years ago

    Those are pretty good, well done with alittle wine.

  • 16 years ago

    What a great website (the Baldo site). Thanks for posting it!

    (flaurabunda, sorry about the icky pests!)...a nice strong water blast?

    Here is a link that might be useful: Garden Musings

  • 16 years ago

    Yes, they could be sawfly larva (rose slugs).
    But, I've never seen them in such large groups on 1 leaf around here.

  • 16 years ago

    Flaura,
    I had these about a month ago. (We seem to have similar critters on our roses.) I squished the ones I saw and had few problems with them. I was afraid they would spread everywhere, but they did minimal damage.

  • 16 years ago

    Yeppers.....I've tried the fast-walking method only to find that a week later I had a major problem for ignoring something I should have controlled.

    I caught these turkeys before they did much damage. I pulled the leaves off, put them in a ziploc, & disposed of them with the critters intact. I had a LOT of rose slugs/sawfly larvae in May, and these looked quite different.

    We recently had a cookout at a state park here, and it the area was teeming with ladybugs. I adopted a few & brought them home to my roses. We hiked a couple of trails and I was amazed to find roses (multiflora, maybe?) sprawling about under the dense canopy of the woods. None were blooming, of course, but it was cool!

  • 16 years ago

    Does look like rose slugs (sawfly larvae) but that is a lot. They are easy to kill, like aphids. Just run your finger over them (I wear gloves) and squish/scrape them off the leaves. That's usually enough to kill them, they aren't capable of traveling far if they survive the fall--like aphids, when you knock them off, they can't get back up.

    I used to worry about them in my garden, but it seems each year the wasps and hoverflies take care of more and more of them and I don't have nearly as many as I did before.

  • 16 years ago

    flaurabunda,

    We have 2 different types of sawfly larva (rose slugs) here.
    One type we have has only 1 generation (May to Mid June), then the second type takes over from (Mid- June until September). There out there munching right now. Since it's later in the growing season, I'm just going to let them eat.
    I've noticed lots of good bugs eating the larva, so, everyones getting a meal. lol