Software
Houzz Logo Print
meriberi_gw

help - red spots on rose canes

15 years ago

hello -

I just noticed that Champney's Pink Cluster (noisette) looks sunburned - one side of most of its canes have these red splotches all over them. But it's not sunburn, right? I mean, it's mid-December, and this rose is in part-shade!

What is it? Do I need to do anything about it to save the plant and protect my other roses?

Thanks for your help -

M

Here is a link that might be useful: In case the photo doesn't come out above, here's the link

Comments (7)

  • 15 years ago

    Meriberi, Can you tell us where you are located, and what your weather conditions are?

    Also, is it possible to get a photo that shows the splotches in focus?
    (If your camera won't focus close, you might try putting an affected cane in a flatbed scanner.)

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    I'm in San Antonio, TX; fall/winter weather for us varies from highs of 80F to lows in the lower 30s, sometimes in one 24-hour period. We've had several freezes already, but none more than a few hours so far. Also, we've had no rain since September, so I've been running my soaker hoses (once/wk when it was still hot, now every 2-4 weeks when things look thirsty).

    Here's another photo that might give a better view of the splotches; I'll try to take better ones tonite with my camera (these are just from my cellphone).

    Here is a link that might be useful: closeup of red splotches on rose cane

  • 15 years ago

    Very interesting. The Sacramento Cemetery's Champney's Pink Cluster had splotches very similar to these, along with silvery-looking places on the canes. Baldo looked at it and took samples to the State Laboratory, and the results were inconclusive. The plant pathologists said that the raised, red areas were edema, which is collection of fluid in the cells. Some people thought it could be downy mildew, but the lab said they didn't think so. We had this sort of growth all over the plant, and finally decided to take it out.

    It showed up about this time of year, and I wonder if it's simply something this plant does, rather than a real problem.
    Anita

  • 15 years ago

    Goodness, my roses have red spots and silvery patches all over the place, especially fall through spring.

    Young canes turn various colors as they mature from green to brown or gray. These can start as red or purple spots and streaks, yellow flushes, etc.

    Purplish red spots and silvery patches can be from various nearly harmless fungi. Red spots can also be black spot infections of the bark that will carry the disease over winter, or the beginning of canker infections that will kill a patch of bark. It could be a reaction to sunlight.

    Don't be alarmed, however. You will probably never know exactly what these spots are, and chances are you will not notice any resulting problems. I just regard cane spotting as a normal thing in my climate and ignore it. If cankers appear in spring I will deal with them then.

  • 15 years ago

    Why is it so hard for my camera to focus on the canes? *sigh* I'll try the flatbed scanner option later when I have a break.

    I noticed that the rose right next to it, Zephirine Drouhin, has this same pattern of red spots on the upper side of the canes (spots on zephy). No other roses in my garden have this, but they are in other areas of the yard.

    At least this camera's images are higher resolution, so it may help:

    Here is a link that might be useful: more red spots

  • 15 years ago

    Meriberi -- Most camera/lens combinations have a limitation on how closely they can focus.
    See in your most recent image, the leaves on the ground were in focus. The cane, somewhat closer, was out of focus.
    Also, if your camera focuses on the central object in its field, you have to be sure that the area you want in focus is dead-center.
    It's not uncommon for cameras to focus no more closely than 3 ft. or so, so you have to know your camera's capabilities.

    As to the blotches -- I've been told that this was a sign of downy mildew, and the silvery areas were where the fungus had killed tissues. But based on Anita's observations, It's probably possible that this is a seasonal change that's not a problem.

    I like MichaelG's approach.

    Jeri

  • 15 years ago

    meriberi, we can see the spots clearly enough in those images.

    Again, I doubt that anyone knows what it is; it could be harmful or not, but the fact that it is only on the top of the canes might suggest that it is something other than a fungal infection.

    Anita, silvery patches are very common in my garden. It kills the outermost layer of bark but doesn't seem to hurt the canes much. I think it is the aftermath of a fungal infection, one not serious enough to attract the attention of pathologists, since it is not mentioned in the handbooks.