Software
Houzz Logo Print
xyus_quebec

Question on princeton elm?

18 years ago

Hi everyone

i have a little question on princeton elm. So here it goes, i have read in books that Princeton elm were selected in 1920 and available in 1932. Trees planted in those years should have produced a legacy? Anyone been growing seeds originated from Princeton elm, i would like to know if they will exhibit DED resistance.

Comments (4)

  • 18 years ago

    I have kept my eyes open for this information, but have not found anything definitive.

    Almost certainly some of the offspring will be resistant and some will not, but I do not know what the ratio will be. I've seen one statement predicting that the majority of "Valley Forge" seedlings will be resistant, but there was no reference to a study or any formal testing to back it up.

    The answer may vary depending on the pollen source. As I understand it, American elm is only partially self fertile, so a Princeton tree with no other cultivar around would not produce many viable seeds, but for those seeds, both "parents" would be Princeton, so to speak. If another variety of elm is around, the large majority of the seeds will be the result of cross pollination. Without knowing the genetics of DED resistance in Princeton, I would have to guess that seeds resulting from self pollination have a better chance of producing DED resistant trees.

    I have one Valley Forge and one Princeton. If I ever get a good sized piece of land, I'll definitely plant some seeds from those two!

    If you happen to find real information on this subject, please post it (or a link) here.

    Alex

  • 18 years ago

    I had my thought on that. Like you said princeton elm will never breed together because they share the same genetic background in resulting from the propagating of cultivar which are cuttings. If Princeton elms breed with normal elm like other plants they will share a part of their parents' genetic, i would love to know which part of the descent will actually have this genetic. The thing will elms is when they are young they have resistance to DED as they grow old they loos their "protection" against DED. Infecting tissue might not be a good test to accurate results.

    I have been looking foward to this information, i have look in scientific library and no information is available. Sems like we will have to do our own test, good luck with you elms.

    Are your elms big enough to seed? My main goal is to have the maximum genetic diversity with a DED resistance and it,s seems that Princeton is a good choice!

  • 18 years ago

    My Valley Forge has been in the ground for 5 years, is about 25 feet tall, but has not yet flowered. I planted the Princeton this summer, it is about 6 feet tall, so I don't expect it to flower for some time.

    Assuming the Valley Forge flowers first, I will get a first hand look at how many viable seeds a lone elm can produce, with no other elm around for pollination.

    Alex

  • 18 years ago

    Alexander, my deceased (from Elm yellows) 20' Valley Forge elm produced flowers & even some seeds this spring only in its 5th season.

    Similarly, my Chinese elm planted at the same time is also producing a few seeds right now -- it's a fall bloomer. I doubt the seeds are viable tho -- no nearby pollinators.