Software
Houzz Logo Print
katefisher_gw

Mr. Lincoln

19 years ago

You know I just cannot stop thinking about the rose 'Mr. Lincoln'. I can't explain why but everytime folks here start talking about red roses I think of this guy and how I want it next year. I don't think I will be able to resist buying in for the spring.

I know some people say its a dog. I'm willing to take that chance. However my question is for those who have grown this rose successfully may I ask from where you purchased it? I have an order going from Roses Unlimited so that's a definite option. There's also a huge nursery about an hour away that will probably carry it in the spring but I don't know if the rose itself would be better buying it from someone with a good reputation like RU.

I'm hoping someone here could advise me. Today was just such a gorgeous day here I wanted go to go dig up my entire garden, re arrange everything and start over like it was springtime! Guess I will have to satsify myself with planning for next year:)

Thank you.

Kate

Comments (23)

  • 19 years ago

    I have one from J&P. I've had it about 5 years. It's a tall rose, it can easily get over 6-7 feet. Mine blooms well most of the year, single long stemmed blooms. It does get blackspot, and I do spray. The scent is fantastic. My tends to be purplish when the blooms fade. But it's a definite stand out. I love it.

  • 19 years ago

    I would say go for it. My favorite scent is like that of Mr Lincoln. Other roses that have a very similar scent are Crimson Glory, and Chrysler Imperial- I am sure there are tons of other ones. Oklahoma is pretty close too. CI is probably the best bloomer of that bunch, along with OK. I have 4 Crimson Glories just to get cut flowers.

  • 19 years ago

    I have it, and 'Firefighter' absolutely outdoes it in every way--productivity, fragrance, and disease resistance.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks folks. Really appreciate your good thoughts. So buford yours was from J & P, jb where did you get yours if I may ask?
    I like what you said buford about it getting really tall. I don't mind that bit. I like the vigor.

    Hoovb I will check out 'Firefighter' also. Thank you greatly.

    Kate

  • 19 years ago

    Be patient with Mr. Lincoln. It is a rose that is slow to establish. I know that I almost shovel pruned it but some good friends here told me to wait and give him more time. They were absolutely right.

  • 19 years ago

    I was given a Mr. Lincoln 2 years ago. It was the only rose bush I ever had. The first year it didn't do much that impressed me and the next year I totally forgot about it. I literally never touched it! Once I remembered it I found that it was producing HUGE beautiful roses and the smell was amazing! That being said, It also had black spot so bad that there wasn't a single leaf left on the entier plant, but the blooms were still beautiful! I would definitely order one, but I guess you will have to spray it a lot!

  • 19 years ago

    Kate,

    Mr. Lincoln is a vigorous grower here. It took a few seasons to get going, but then I had a monster. Little winter dieback. He does require spraying for blackspot as do all my roses. ML also requires pruning twice during the growing season or else he will be over 10'.

  • 19 years ago

    In the past I've grown both Mister Lincoln and Oklahoma. I find that ML is more "red" than Oklahoma, and holds the color longer before "bluing" to a rich burgundy. Oklahoma's flowers alos have a tendency to nod. Now others will refute that claim but it was a recurring problem in my old garden.

    VINTAGE GARDENS sells a virus indexed Mister Lincoln. HEIRLOOM ROSES also claims to have a virus free clone. Both vendors sell this rose as an own root band (basically a rooted cutting). Mister Lincoln is so vigorous that he really doesn't need the help of a grafted rootstock.

    Good luck with your rose,

    Patrick

    Image of Mr. Lincoln by aurora1701e previously posted at the Roses Gallery
    {{gwi:343589}}

  • 19 years ago

    I'd definitely get this one from RU rather than locally. You can ask RU for details about their stock; they've acquired a lot of virus-indexed materials and they seem to specialize in older-variety HT's. I've so far ordered less than 20 plants, but everything I've gotten from RU has been superb.

  • 19 years ago

    Virus-indexed Mister Lincoln is the way to go. It will be bushier and more productive.

  • 19 years ago

    I have it too. It got very tall this year, it's first year. It did not produce a multitude of blooms, but the blooms it does produce are huge. In my area, I have heard the "regulars" like Veteran's Honor better but I'm happy with it and hoping for a strong 2nd year.

  • 19 years ago

    Kate, you have to get Mister Lincoln! I have one that was purchased form Raft Island Roses. I'm pretty sure mine is grafted because it is a super tall vase shape. I like the shape it is though, it fits in where it is and I have daylilies under him. The fragrance is incredible.

  • 19 years ago

    Thanks guys! Always so helpful.

    Ceterum and Aggie:

    I will give this guy time to grow up. I don't know if like Aggie most of you have had to spray but up here in Northern CA blackspot is a pretty minor issue. But if I must I will spray. I will try to grow it chemical free first and see how that goes.

    Harry:

    That's great. Thank you. I love the idea of a big, fat, crazy red rose bush in the garden. If I plant it in the front yard I will bear its potential height in mind.

    Patrick:

    Gorgeous photo. Like I really needed more enabling:) Good to know that Vintage Gardens and Heirloom are options also. That's what I needed to know. I will almost certainly be ordering from Heirloom also in the spring so that's helpful.

    Barbarag:

    I'm excited to read your good review of RU. That is since I have six roses on order from them already. If I go that way ML will be number 7. Yeah!

    Redsox and petaloid:

    I have considered Veterans Honor also. Probably I will try them both at some point. They both seem to have the potential for great beauty. Right now ML has really caught my fancy so I will start with him.

    Adrienne:

    I checked out an old picture of yours of Mister Lincoln last night. Love those fat blooms. Did you get yours from Heirloom Roses?

    As always much appreciated everyone.

    Kate

  • 19 years ago

    Do get a virus indexed Mister Lincoln. You'd be astonished that once established how much better the rose is!

    Also, if Vintage has it already to ship out with the spring line-up, I'd go for Vintage over Heirloom. I've had better performance and larger root stock from Vintage. If you have to custom order it, go to Heirloom. Their plants a somewhat smaller but they are also strong and quick to establish and start. Vintage takes up to 3 years to root custom stock. You get a good product, but I'm simply not that patient.

    The last rose I got from Vintage was Leonie Lamesch, a polyantha. It was a nice size root that tripled it's size in just a few short months. Sorry, don't have pictures on this computer. The last rose I got from Heirloom is a virus indexed Peace that has doubled it's size and given me several beautiful blooms. Both companies are highly recommended.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Gardening and Other Stuff

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you Julie.

    Is it springtime yet? I'm ready to start planting! I fear this may be a long winter with so much rose growing awaiting me in the spring.

    Appreciate your time.

    Kate

  • 11 years ago

    It's certainly not a dog. If you look at the pictures in a J&P catalog and didn't get what you saw there, you may be disappointed. But Mr. Lincoln is a great rose.

    First off, it's tall and lanky. It's never going to be shrub like. It's going to put out tall canes with blooms at the top. It makes a great cut rose. The color in my yard is more to the purple than dark red side. The fragrance is amazing.

    I had a Mr. Lincoln from J&P for over 10 years and it performed very well. However, I lost it in the polar vortex. It was my husband favorite rose. So I've replaced it. No blooms yet, but it's doing ok.


  • 11 years ago

    I have been recently tempted by this rose after seeing another poster's beautiful pic.

  • 11 years ago

    I found a really bushy Mr. Lincoln at Lowes of all places a few months back, priced at $9. It's still waiting for placement, though, but I've been giving it regular watering, and so far so good. It even has a few blossoms in the making, which I'll post photos of later on.


  • 11 years ago

    I have had mine for several years now. I have considered ditching it several times over the years. The blooms are huge and the scent, intoxicating. But, for me, it produces very few blooms. If you prune it fairly low so that it does not reach 6' it produces these small, flat flowers instead. If I had it to do again, I would choose a different red. But some people like it.


  • 11 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Mr Lincoln is great! love it ! You can get it in the roses from Walmart fresh off the truck from Tyler Texas.

  • 11 years ago

    I have tried Mr. Lincoln in the dry Nevada desert 3 times, and it never did well. Now I am trying Oklahoma, Chrysler Imperial and Firefighter to see how they do. Maybe I will be giving up on them too, but I have given up on Mister Lincoln for good. At least there is no black spot here to worry about. Mr. Lincoln might be fine in N. Calif, and it wouldn`t hurt to try it!

  • 11 years ago

    I did buy Firefighter this spring and the first blooms on it have been great. It's more of a true red than Mr. Lincoln.