Software
Houzz Logo Print
greyandamy

edith bogue magnolia

14 years ago

My lovely edith bogue magnolia too is starting to rot, soil issues, I've tried and tried to ammend under, around, so it's not so boggy, they say not to damage roots, but enough were damaged, or are rotting at tips, I tried to get under her, to suck up clay that came from ??? she is planted high, but she is also in the pathway of a potential water issue, I don't want to lose her too, do they get big tap roots?? Will her fleshy feeders get into the contaminated soil around her and rot more?? The garden center man said remove as much "water holding soil" as possible, even if that meant root damage, I try, I found some very girdled roots too, for what good that is.. she still has a good root span...3 feet???... but that's greatly decreased...

I don't want to lose her too, I know they DONT TRANSPLANT WELL, esp. now, esp. in this zone

I don't want to lose her too, her bark, leaves aren't showing overt signs yet...

Question, If I moved her (god knows how) into a pot and got rid of as much soil as possible prior (yes, more root damage)... and overwintered her in garage, am I more at risk of killing her than just letting nature take it's course with the $120 tree?? In spring, I don't know where I'd put her, somwhere.. she is raised, but I fear not enough

What is the reason behind not damaging roots? If I tried to make a really raised bed for her, how high would it have to be? Could there be something around it, like..lave rock, or something to help with drainage? Do I just, again, let be..

Amy

Comments (5)

  • 14 years ago

    We've got a common saucer magnolia growing in our front yard in pretty heavy clay - It is about 20 feet or so tall with equal spread. It isn't evergreen like Southern magnolia, but I imagine soil requirements are similar. Also, I've seen southern magnolia growing in red clay down in Tennessee.

  • 14 years ago

    I am not quite sure what the problem is here. Where is the 'rot' showing up--roots, leaves...? Also, not sure what you mean by 'contaminated' soil and 'the pathway of a potential water issue'. But will try to address some of your concerns. M. grandifloras, like all Magnolias, are relatively shallow rooted. Roots tend to be thick and rope-like and a deep tap root is not a concern. But, because they lack a lot of smaller fibrous roots, they do tend to resent being moved more so than other trees. However, your tree sounds like it is on the small side, and it can be most successfully moved if necessary. When I moved several years ago, I dug one out of the ground, containerized it and planted it into the ground at my new home where it has done quite well. Magnolias love water but will not succeed if your the area is boggy--no way. Occasional flooding is not generally a problem. I suppose the ground drainage could be improved but I don't know enough about this to advise you. You might want the help of an arborist or landscaper as just about any tree will have 'issues' with boggy soils with the possible exception of Bald Cypresses. If you do temporarily containerize it, you would need to protect it from the average cold of zone 6 winters. Good luck!

  • 14 years ago

    as per my response in the other post .. see link ... note price.. note size.. be ready to replace this one ...

    it needs to be in the ground...

    if you have drainage issues .. then you plant high ... putting only about half the root mass in your bad soil.. and mounding the rest with good draining soil ... this allows air and drainage to the roots... which is what is lacking in a bog ...

    most anything.. can grow in most any soil.. the issue is the transplanting.. and getting it to live long enough to put its own roots in whatever soil is there ... i will do a 2nd post with a link on planting.. which addresses such ...

    i dont think.. in your zone.. you should be having to dig up and garage most magnolia.. you are on the verge of loving it to death ...

    good luck

    ken

    ps: see!!! at the link.. you could buy all 4 for around $50 ... and who cares if one of the 4 dies ... compared to your investment in one ... i like to say.. i have more time than money.. so i buy small.. and lo and behold 5 years later.. i have 4 mags [usually.. lol] .. and i am still ahead of your cost ....

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 14 years ago

    here's the other link

    ken

    ps: brandon .. is there a better link for planting in clay????

    Here is a link that might be useful: link

  • 14 years ago

    some lady from a garden center is to come look at the dead river birch that shouldn't have died in 3 weeks, too bad yesterday it was trashed, it had no roots..she was to come 2 days back and didn't, I dont hold breath..

    ISsue with magnolia, I had the soil too boggy, the issue is sometime more recently she started losing all her bright right top feeder roots, lower down, they are not white, perhaps they aren't meant to be.. I planted her shallowly as the nursery had her, but even now I see 99% of time, what's in a pot is still too deep..the base, I'm trying to realize the "flare" is a big different... I'm just watching... it's one of my last trees, ya know...I would buy small but have had too much bad luck online places (plus shipping).. but now due to difficulty with strength .. they don't like to sell small..

    I don't have the money Ken, I'm obsessed as it's my outlet for dealing with the rest of my out-of-control.. and I used to have a gorgeous yard... and i'm an outside freak, can't be in... always was like that..I've been careless, too much, thinking.. not thinking clearly..

    Sorry if I wasn't clear, but all your answers helped a lot, thanks for taking the time..you are very kind! Oh, everyone tells me magnolias don't like clay...but oh well, I can't move another thing to a pot... I've no ... I hate life sometimes, it comes at you and never seems to give you a break.. I guess I deal with "stress" through the garden, until I can't anymore... I love the garden, just...wish I had ...a brain..

    THanks again,amy