Software
Houzz Logo Print
zippo1_gw

Can box elders grow on undisturbed soil?

17 years ago

Got to wondering about this, Seems like no matter where on my property ground Is disturbed these things show up, however got to wondering If they can do that on undisturbed soil. As many seeds as they produce the females that Is, It would seem hard to believe that they couldn't grow on undisturbed soil. But I'm looking for someone who might know the answer to this question for a 100% certainty so I can satisfy my curiosity.

Comments (13)

  • 17 years ago

    I think the secret is in your definition of "undisturbed".

    If you're talking about dry compacted soil w/o leaf or other cover from the sun then I'd say the percentage of germination of any seed that falls there gets close to 0.0001%.

    Till that same soil where the seed's contact area with the dirt increases and exposure decreases and more seeds will survive to germination.

  • 17 years ago

    But I'm looking for someone who might know the answer to this question for a 100% certainty so I can satisfy my curiosity.

    =========>>>> really???

    if trees can grow in the cracks in cement ... i dont see what impact the type of soil will have ... the seeds will either germinate.. or they wont ...

    soil is soil .. to a seed ... is it going to commit seed suicide.. if the soil type is wrong ... ????

    i guess i dont accept your premise ...

    good luck on that quest for knowledge ....

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Seed germination is affected by several factors. Some seeds need light to germinate and won't germinate very well until they are exposed to light (as when the ground is disturbed, exposing them to more light). Some seeds prefer to be lightly covered (e.g., don't need light but perhaps need the covering for moisture?). There are a bunch of other factors like temperature, seed coat scarification, etc., of course.

  • 17 years ago

    Elders usually grow on disturbed soil here

    Resin

  • 17 years ago

    Good point Ken. Eventually something is bound to sprout almost anyplace. Lord knows I pull enough ash seedlings out from the cracks around my place.

    Just all in the odds I suppose.

  • 17 years ago

    This picture was taken Wednesday in SE Minnesota. I'm not sure what's in this old silo (most likely chopped corn aka silage), but pretty sure its not soil. Based on condition of this old farmstead, I doubt its been disturbed. This A. negundo seems to like its digs.

    {{gwi:440651}}

    {{gwi:440652}}

  • 17 years ago

    Since some just can't seem to understand what undisturbed means then let me explain, undisturbed In the way I ask the question means NO human intervention or disturbance In any way form or fashion, Just simply nature and thats It. So again do Box elders or those of you who feel the need to use Its scientific name Acer negundo grow where the ground has not been disturbed In ANY way? Think forest, fields, meadows etc with NO disturbance of ANY kind by people. Yes I know trees can grow in cracks in pavement but once again that is a human disturbed area.

  • 17 years ago

    Presumably they predated a human presence in their native range, so some level, yes, they can grow in areas without human disturbance. Perhaps with far less efficiency (say, trees produced per million seeds, or something like that), but they can.

    Richard.

  • 17 years ago

    I know someone that has them all over their property - seedlings coming up by the thousands with no intervention or disturbance on his part. So yes, they can. As Richard said, they managed for many years without many people being around and did just fine.

  • 17 years ago

    If you really define "undisturbed" that strictly, your study area would be pretty limited. Almost everywhere (even most national parks and wilderness areas) has been noticeably changed by people. There are few old growth forests, natural prairies, etc these days.

  • 17 years ago

    Not all disturbance is human in origin - gaps in forest created by storms, landslides, lightning-caused fires, floods, large mammals, etc., can all provide for seed germination opportunities for plants which need disturbed ground.

    Resin

  • 17 years ago

    Yes, these trees can easily grow on undisturbed dirt, as long as conditions are right - it likes sun & moisture.
    Our neighbors have a few Box Elders and a section of their backyard left naturally wooded. The trees were here before they built their house.
    From what I've observed - I mostly see saplings at the edge of their wooded area. (Eventually this wooded area will only contain Box Elder, Siberian Elm, Garlic Mustard & Black Walnut.)
    One of the forest preserve districts around here classified this tree as invasive, especially in prairies, and I've seen it on a Wisconsin list.

  • 17 years ago

    In our area here in SW Michigan Box Elders grow like weeds-disturbed or undisturbed alike. They can survive in a wide range of soils/soil conditions. When the soil ph ranges between 5-5.5 they grow their best, but can tolerate ph as high as 7. They are very common here and most consider them a weed.

    Their branches are brittle and become wind damaged easily. As they get older they drop a lot of small dead branches. They attract a lot of 'Box Elder Bugs' (Boisea trivittatus) that seem able to get into even the tightest built home. For most this is the biggest negative when it comes to having them.

    My Grandma use to tap them for their sap to mix with maple tree sap to make syrup from. You can not taste the difference.

    If you find one that has been allowed to grow undisturbed out in a field with no other trees near they have a very rustic look about them-almost artistic with their broken and fallen limbs hanging down combining with their natural shape when viewed from afar. Even this "dandelion" has its beauty!

    As most have said they survived pre-man and will probably survive post-man (not to be confused with your letter carrier).