Software
Houzz Logo Print
dublinbay

Red HT that tolerates some partial shade?

16 years ago

I know we've had red HT threads before, but I'm looking for something slightly different--a red fragrant HT that can tolerate several hours of mid-afternoon light shade.

Right now I have Valencia in that spot because I read it is somewhat shade tolerant, but the colors in my bed would balance out so much better if I had a red one there. (I have another spot to which I can move Valencia.)

Oh yes--it must have some disease-resistance or I won't let it into my garden.

So, a red HT--somewhat light-shade tolerant; fragrant; good disease-resistance (for a HT); but of course, beautiful.

And probably one that doesn't get real tall.

Thanks for your help. Must go check the Xmas dinner now.

Merry Christmas,

Kate

Comments (6)

  • 16 years ago

    I like Oklahoma! My mom has one in her garden and it gets a lot of afternoon shade. As long as it gets some nice morning sun (6-8 hours) it should do fine.

    Oklahoma is a really dark red rose and it smells wonderful...like old roses. It also looks good with yellow or pink, since it's such a dark red with no orange tones. I think it only gets about 4' tall in our area, so it might work for you :) Merry Christmas!

  • 16 years ago

    Another one to consider is Firefighter. It is red, disease resistant and fragrant.

  • 16 years ago

    Hi Kate, we're in different climates, but I'm no spray and all of my roses grow in less than ideal sun conditions cause that's all I have. :)

    Have you considered Royal William? I hesitate to recommend a rose I've only had for one year, but it shows real promise. Very disease resistant (here,) nicely bushy, bloomed a lot (especially for only a 1st year rose.) It's a Kordes (I purchased from Palatine Roses, who sells it as Duftzauber) and I have seen it recommended as one of the easiest/best roses for beginners. So far fragrance is only light-medium to my nose-which surprised me-but hoping that will improve with time.

    For comparison, I have both Oklahoma (5 years old) and Firefighter (3 years old), both of which have stronger fragrance than Royal William.

    I prefer the darker color and heavier fragrance of Oklahoma to FF and I agree it has both very good disease resistance and shade tolerance. Absolutely magnificent blooms especially in cooler weather, rich deep sophisticated burgundy red-I can't think of another red HT I like better-it just hardly blooms!

    Firefighter blooms much more than Oklahoma-and those blooms last longer than Oklahoma-but Firefighter is NOT disease resistant (here) and in fairness that may be worsened because it is growing in part sun instead of full sun. Because of it's strong fragrance, productivity, and lasting qualities, I think Firefighter would be a candidate for "best overall red HT" if it shows good resistance in your area or, of course, if you spray. But I expect F.F. might just continue to decline on me since it almost completely defoliates from blackspot each year.

    Hence why I have such high hopes for Royal William :)

    Hope that helps...
    Dawn

    Here is a link that might be useful: Royal William at helpmefind.com

  • 16 years ago

    Littlesmokie- Your Oklahoma doesn't bloom often? My mom's rose blooms all the time, but maybe it's because we have a hotter summer here? If anything, when it's really hot, the flowers don't last long, but none of the roses do well when it gets over 90 degrees for a few weeks. The only one I have that did well is Tamora and even that rose had a tough time. That's one reason I try to give all the roses, here, some afternoon shade :)

  • 16 years ago

    Traviata,

    I have 3, one is under an oak tree. There is enough shade to make the surrounding ferns happy. It's is on it's own root (rooted by me). Normally, it's about 9'high x 5'wide. Under the oak it's about 2/3 as big.
    In full sun it's a constant bloomer, under the oak it still blooms well enough. Foliage is dark green, bloom is bright red (not dark like the description in Helpmefind). It's BS resistant but not BS proof (very little is BS proof around here). It is not fragrant, however. It is not a classic HT with the high center but is classified as one.
    It gets no winter dieback for me. It's a very rewarding plant, any effort I put in to it pays off (which isn't much just spring fert, spray for BS, prune out old wood).
    It's one of my favorites.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Traviata

  • 16 years ago

    In general, the more fragrant a red is the less disease resistant it tends to be.
    Firefighter and Oklahoma are super fragrant but here in my zone are disease problems. I actually SP'd Oklahoma because it couldn't keep any clean foliage. Firefighter can get BS very bad but I spray and that helps.
    I think that Royal William and Veterans' Honor would come closest to what you want in my opinion from my hands-on experience with them. Both are decently fragrant and mostly disease resistant but not perfect. However, they don't defoliate with BS for me.
    Beloved, Olympiad, Pride of England, and Dream Scarlett are my most disease resistant, vigorous growing reds and have gorgeous flowers but are virtually scentless.
    Ingrid Bergman is supposed so be lightly fragrant and disease resistant but I have tried growing it twice and it hasn't lived very long for me for some reason.
    Chrysler Imperial is about the same as Firefighter but will stay relatively clean with spraying, but that won't do you any good since you don't spray.
    John