Software
Houzz Logo Print
trancefusion

what to do with this plum tree?

16 years ago

This tree seems to have suffered winter damage (splayed limbs and cracked off limbs near the center), as well as agressive pruning by the previous owner.

How can I get it to a more natural appearance?

{{gwi:456311}}

Comments (15)

  • 16 years ago

    Based on that one picture, I'd probably take off a few of the lower outside limbs (back to the main branch) to give it a less spreading look. I'd also remove any branch stubs (the picture is too small to tell for sure, but I think I see some).

    Multiple, higher-resolution pictures might lead to more ideas, but there's nothing like seeing the tree in person.

  • 16 years ago

    I'd put something in the ground nearby to replace it and wait patiently until the inevitable decline, personally.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    Hah, it's pretty "declined" as is..

    Yes there are some cracked off branch stubs. There's a few branches that have started shooting up off the leaders at the base of the tree, but the deer have been browsing them. I could always fence it.

    Any suggestions for another small ornamental tree for that spot? As you can see, there isn't much room between the porch and the driveway.

  • 16 years ago

    That plum's "natual appearance" is splintered and splayed limbs. Serviceberry would be my replacement suggestion.

    tj

  • 16 years ago

    so you think this is how it is supposed to look? Like it is healthy? Do you recommend removing it?

  • 16 years ago

    that is a 90 year old man .... and unlike the man.. needs to be put out of your misery ..

    most likely planted by the builder ... its way past its prime ...

    be done with it ...

    nothing will work there.. if you do not figure out the deer issue ...

    w/o a picture of the whole front of the house.. its hard to give you advice on the landscaping ..

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Hey, I like that plum tree.

    Look, it isnt going to live forever but if you like purple leaves and the bit of flowers it probably still makes keep it there. I would prune it less aggressively than most it seems. Old dog has lived that long so you are just cleaning it up. Maybe take some weight off them outside branches.

    Planning for the future wouldnt be a bad idea. Perhaps stuck a japanese maple or one of the brightly colored conifers there. Something with color. In three, five, ten? Years when the plum has declined past servicable your replacement will be larger.

  • 16 years ago

    Not necessarily old, just messed with by man and nature. I'd just leave it alone, unless taken out by something like the arrival of a destructive borer biggest ax hanging over its head probably additional snow damage rather than senescence. If it means enough to you hiring an arborist to cable it might be possible.

  • 16 years ago

    That tree would be very difficult for me to 'love', especially in a focal place. I think that I would feel just a leeetle bit of resentment towards it every time I looked at it. Don't be held hostage by the tree just because it's there. Unless you are attached to it, of course.

  • 16 years ago

    i think rhizo captured what i meant to say ...

    if this were out in my 5 acre... with a lawnchair and a cooler of beer i could spend a lot of time enjoying it ...

    on the prime focal point of the corner of the house... its a nightmare.. and not in a location where i would want a 5 year pruning renovation project ...

    YOU CAN DO SO MUCH BETTER IN FRONT OF YOUR PRETTY HOUSE .... dump the old man ...

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Hmmm. I'm not sure 'resentment' is how I would feel if that were my place (maybe a tiny bit), but now that the silence has been broached I'm personally a little peeved that a 20.00 cheap, trite plum from the BigBox was slapped in that spot and there are certainly scores of better ideas for replacing, many of them including well-placed moss rock and highly ornamental woodies and a large drift of early spring bulbs.

    One wonders where these builders get their 'designs' from - my small landscape design business in CA was the beneficiary of the fact that there are many poorly-trained "designers" out there and their landscapes usually need major fixing. Once that thing is out of there you will see that there are many opportunities for a nice planting there. Saw and mattock work on a cool morning goes to the top of the honeydew list.

    Dan

  • 16 years ago

    well.. i blamed the builder..

    but there is just a big a chance.. it was the first owner [who i was thinking commissioned the building] ...

    who saw those pretty purple leaves at the bigboxstore.. on that cute little 2 foot plant.. in fall .. when it was 80% off.. lol ... and thought it would make a nice addition to the front of the house ...

    ken

    ps: and if the poster is the guilty party.. forgive me... lol .... listen.. plants hit a maturity.. or age.. wherein they simply no longer fit the aesthetic of the location ... in other words.. they just arent all that cute anymore ... and my position is that you can do so much better ... in one project.. rather than a 5 year attempt to renovate it.. in which you may or may not like what you end up with ...

  • 16 years ago

    Foliage color goes well with color of house. Since specimen branches at ground level not likely to have been sold as a tree by a retail outlet, unless it froze to the ground and grew back or was cut down, came back from very low stump.

    Or it is a big Prunus x cistena that was sold in shrub form, as they often are.

  • 16 years ago

    I don't know anything about the tree except that it looks unhealthy to me. We just moved in. It's our first place so I don't know much about landscaping (yet).

    However, I want to get rid of pretty much everything and start fresh. My wife has little faith and thinks I am just trying to axe perfectly good trees. I just wanted to make sure I wasn't crazy..

    I'll admit it will be tough regardless as there seem to be a steady stream of deer flowing throughout the day.

  • 16 years ago

    If you fence them out it will be a lot better. Otherwise you are constantly subject to their behavior.

    And its variations, including nibbling things down to stubble during a hard winter that were not touched for years beforehand.