Software
Houzz Logo Print
cascadians

Cross a Rabbit + Poplar Tree = Poison Eater

19 years ago

[ Fair Use: For Educational / Research / Discussion Purposes Only ]

SEATTLE POST-INTELLIGENCER

http://seattlepi.nwsource.com/local/335572_transgenic16.html

Tuesday, October 16, 2007, 8:56/a PT, by Lisa Stiffler, Seattle Post-Intelligencer

Mutants or saviors? Rabbit genes create trees that eat poisons

UW scientists create transgenic poplars that neutralize toxins quickly

Super trees that suck up and destroy toxic chemicals from the air and water faster than regular trees are the latest creation by scientists at the University of Washington.

When the scientists stick a rabbit gene into poplar trees, the trees become dramatically better at eliminating a dozen kinds of pollutants commonly found on poisoned properties.

The trees could prevent the need for digging up tons of soil or pumping out millions of gallons of water for treatment and disposal. They naturally render a list of cancer-causing pollutants -- benzene, trichloroethylene (TCE), vinyl chloride, chloroform -- non-toxic.

But while the poplars could benefit cleanup projects, they raise a multitude of ecological and ethical concerns.

Many people are worried about transgenic organisms, in which a gene from one species is inserted into another, whether it's corn that produces a pig vaccine or a soybean that makes its own pesticide. There are concerns that mutant plants could spread, entering the food supply and threatening human health. Or they could interbreed with normal plants, transferring herbicide resistance to weeds, for example. No one can predict all of the potential side effects of a new gene on the host plant or other plants and animals.

When it comes to the pollution-consuming poplars, "it's really a question of trading some of the unknown risks of planting genetically modified trees with the positive environmental benefits," said Andrew Light, a UW professor of philosophy and public affairs. "This is a real dilemma for the environmental community."

In the UW project, a gene from a rabbit is added to the poplar's DNA. The gene contains the instructions for an enzyme that breaks down pollutants. A very similar enzyme naturally exists in the plant, but scientists have not been able to isolate the poplar's version in order to boost its production.

"It's a beautiful thing that a rabbit gene is perfectly readable by a plant. Look at how connected life is," said Sharon Doty, a professor with the UW's College of Forest Resources. She's the lead author of the poplar research published Monday in The Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences.

"It's a beautiful thing," she said. "I don't think it's something to fear."

Others are not so smitten.

"It's commendable to be thinking about finding ways to reverse some of the pollution that has been caused in the past, but in doing so we have to make sure we don't cause new problems at the same time," said Doug Gurian-Sherman, a Washington, D.C.-based senior scientist with the Union of Concerned Scientists.

"There are a lot of unknowns here," he said.

Non-edible transgenic plants have captured little public attention -- with the notable exception of the attack on the UW's Center for Urban Horticulture six years ago. A group of eco-terrorists firebombed the center in an effort to sabotage research on genetically modified poplar trees by a researcher who is not part of Doty's study.

Doty said researchers remain worried about the threat of attack, but hope people understand the potential benefits of their work.

There are other experiments under way nationwide with trees and plants genetically modified to help with pollution cleanup -- cottonwoods with an unusual affinity for mercury, Indian mustard plants that soak up selenium.

The poplars created by the UW scientists are unique for being able to remove and destroy "several of the most widespread and dangerous pollutants." But that versatility also could prove problematic. Because the enzyme is unusually flexible and able to attack multiple chemicals, there's a greater likelihood that it might affect the trees and other organisms in unexpected ways.

There are still years of research ahead before the first of these poplars could be tested on an actual contaminated site. The results showing speedier destruction of toxics compared with normal trees -- TCE 53 times faster, benzene 10 times faster, chloroform nine times faster -- come from poplars only a few inches tall that are grown in solutions in the lab.

Tests growing the trees in soil have begun in a controlled setting. It could be five years or more before a field test could get started.

And the trees wouldn't work for every cleanup. Their roots grow 10 feet deep on average, depending in part on the soil type. Chemicals such as TCE are heavier than water and can sink.

The pollution "pretty quickly gets below the root zone of a tree," said Marcia Knadle, a hydrogeologist with the Environmental Protection Agency's Risk Evaluation Unit in Seattle.

Once planted outdoors, there are strategies for preventing the spread of the mutant poplars, according to the research led by Doty and the UW's Stuart Strand with contributions from 13 other university scientists. They could be cut down before they begin producing flowers at around 8 years of age. There are genes that could be added to the trees to make them less fertile, but that technology is not ready for use.

While the poplars aren't grown as crops and thus less threatening to people, the trees could become more widespread and can thrive without human care, Gurian-Sherman said. The mutant trees could put forest ecosystems at risk.

The poplars will require approval for use by the U.S. Department of Agriculture. Scientists working on the poplars said the USDA regulatory hurdles are too stringent; Gurian-Sherman said they're not protective enough to safeguard people and the environment.

Doty remains eager to see her trees sponging up waste at Superfund and other fouled sites. A breast cancer survivor who lost her father to pancreatic cancer, she's worried about the pollution in our air and water.

"Something is clearly wrong with our environment if children are dying of cancer," Doty said. "That's a lot of the motivation for me. I've got to do something about this."

Here is a link that might be useful: Mutants or saviors? Rabbit genes create trees that eat poisons

Comments (19)

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Title should be:

    Mix A Cottonwood With A Cottontail ;^D

    Seems no lack of job opportunities for those with science degrees!

    This tree would MULTIPLY !!!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Interesting one. On balance, it seems this could be beneficial, unlike most of the currently released transgenic plants, which are aimed at destroying biodiversity.

    Resin

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Whoever thought of THAT!? That's the question I have.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Maybe while they're at it they can make this tree resistant to decay and rot and wood that is 10x stronger than steel.
    Very interesting article thanks for posting it.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    >Interesting one. On balance, it seems this could be beneficial, unlike most of >the currently released transgenic plants, which are aimed at destroying >biodiversity.

    Could you clarify this comment? Are you saying the *motive* behind the creation of "most of the currently released transgenic plants" is to destroy biodiversity?

    Alex

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This struck me as odd, never concentrated on animal x tree. Remember there was an article some time back about a goat x spider? I get an instinctive ooooky reaction but don't know enough botany, biology, chemistry, genetics, etc to make an informed evaluation. Do know that black cottonwood poplars self-seed at astonishing rates and rabbits breed like, well, rabbits, so this seems like a prolific possibility.

    Just imagine all the combos you can make to create special effects ... Frankenstein x Luther Burbank scenarios.

    What other transgenic plants are out there and what has been the result?
    Invasive species?

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Could you clarify this comment?"
    "What other transgenic plants are out there and what has been the result?"

    As mentioned in the article above:

    soybean that makes its own pesticide - results in loss of insect life as no insects can survive in the crop.

    herbicide resistant crop plants - enables growers to use more frequent and higher concentrations of herbicides without damaging the crop, thereby completely eliminating all competing wild flowers and leaving (apart from the crop) a totally sterile environment.

    Resin

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "what has been the result?"

    Here's the result:

    Here is a link that might be useful: http://stateofthebirds.audubon.org/cbid/browseSpecies.php

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This is all just so wrong. Wisdom must accompany intelligence - just because it can be done doesn't mean it should be done.

    Here's another result that has been seen from genetically modified plants having unintended consequences when let out of the laboratory:

    FataMorgana

    Here is a link that might be useful: Monarchs and Bt corn: questions and answers

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    There have been serveral attempts to cross DNA between the kingdoms. Does anyone remember the tomato X flounder cross? The BT splice is corn X bacteria.

    There are a lot of ersatz Frankensteins out there, crafting genetic chimeras. It's human nature to dabble. It's also human nature to be cursory!

    Regarding the Monarch study, I think the article is merely suggestive and not yet conclusive.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tomato article

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    could this new science help with shortcomings of paulowias, which seem to be an insistent, persistent topic on this forum. There ought to be some way of improving them so we don't spend so much time trying to talk others out of buying them. I don't know about the scientific wonders posted this week....I checked and its only a crescent moon tonight.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    >"what has been the result?"
    >Here's the result:
    > >Here is a link that might be useful: http://stateofthebirds.audubon.org/cbid/>browseSpecies.php

    Are you sure that's the link you meant to post? It lists the decline of several bird species since 1967. The first commercial transgenic crop was in the mid 90's. I didn't read every entry, but I looked at 5 or 6, and none mentioned transgenic crops at all. They did mention loss of habitat due to agriculture and logging, but I don't think transgenic technology has led to an increase in the farmed acreage.

    Alex

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    As mentioned in the article above:

    >soybean that makes its own pesticide - results in loss of insect life as no >insects can survive in the crop.

    How does this compare to spraying a field of non GM soybean with pesticide several times a season? And what you mean to say is that no insect can survive eating the leaves and beans. Of course there are still insects around.

    >herbicide resistant crop plants - enables growers to use more frequent and >higher concentrations of herbicides without damaging the crop,
    thereby >completely eliminating all competing wild flowers and leaving (apart from the >crop) a totally sterile environment.

    "a totally sterile environment"?! - this is hyperbole. There are many forms of life in a field of a RoundUp Ready crop. Insects, bacteria, fungi, worms, spiders to name a few.

    There are legitimate concerns and tradeoffs about GM crops, just like there is with any technology. When people spout hyperbole as above, it creates the impression among some that the only people who are concerned are whacko environmentalists who do not deserve serious attention. It discourages serious discussion on the topic.

    Resin, your first comment ("...aimed at destroying biodiversity") was inflammatory by clearly suggesting that it was the intent of the researchers to destroy biodiversity.

    Alex

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    >There are a lot of ersatz Frankensteins out there,

    I've always found it interesting when GM plants are compared to Frankensteins monster (eg "Frankenfoods"), when the monster was not transgenic, but grafted together. Thankfully, no one seems to protest grafted fruit trees!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    This message has kind of gotten hijacked from the original post to an argument over the risks/benefits of genetic engineering.

    Certainly genetically engineered crops are being developed to produce a marketable result (GM seeds) and side effects may not be of the utmost concern. However, an underlying theme of developing these crops is to reduce the potential side effects of other pesticides by reducing their use and substituting pesticides that are safer, non-toxic or less toxic to non-target species, and have a reduced potential to cause damage to non-target species or areas.

    There is the potential for Bt crops to kill Monarch caterpillers, however it is still probably less toxic than the alternatives. Bt crops do not produce a bug free field. Many species of insects are immune to Bt. Caterpillars are generally not immune to it. Insects that are not eating the corn are not a target of the Bt corn, and Monarchs do not eat the corn. The risk lies in the movement of corn pollen carrying the Bt to the Monarch's food source. Still, the bloom period for corn will run a couple weeks in the summer. The rest of the growing season, it is not shedding any Bt material. Thus, there is risk to non-target Monarch larvae for a couple weeks. Adults would not be harmed, just larvae during this period. Without Bt corn, the control of insect pests in the crop would generally require sprays or soil treatments that would kill a much broader spectrum of insects, including all adult Monarchs that might be in the field. Thus while the use of Bt crops might not be totally safe for non-target species, it is still probably much safer than the alternatives, and it is more effective on the target pests. Seems like a winning solution here--and with time it can still be improved. But if the early steps aren't profitable for the developers, they will never move on to develop even safer products down the road.

    With herbicide resistant crops, the plants are producing and carrying no pesticides. What the genes do is allow farmers to spray the crop with broad spectrum, low toxicity herbicides and the plant has the ability to deactivate the herbicide quickly so it suffers no damage.

    There are valid concerns with these technologies, however we need to explore them as they offer the potential to reduce the use of toxic pesticides and non-target damage dramatically compared to conventional technologies.

    When it comes to the potential for the bunny cottonwoods to spread by seed or cross into other poplars growing wild, Monsanto had techniques to render their genetically modified crop seeds sterile so they could not transfer into other plants, however that was killed with the help of those claiming that potential outcrossing was a terrible risk. Sometimes I think the anti-GM people are less interested in controlling the risks of GM technology than they are in finding issues to generate memberships and donations to feather their nests and perpetuate the discord.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I believe it is impossible to account for all the variability and variety in the natural world. How can any scientist in a lab say exactly what effects a thing they created, a thing that has never lived in the world before is really going to have? Here's an article published this month on the possible unintended effects of Bt corn on the caddisfly. Did anyone consider the caddisfly? What else hasn't been considered?

    No thanks. I'll pass on trees cooked up in a lab. I don't believe the risks out weigh the benefits and I'm sure there are other alternatives to be found that do not include genetically modified organisms.

    I must say I do find the last paragraph of the previous post to be amusing in that Monsanto and "anti-GM" people are both mentioned and that it is the "anti-GM" folks that are supposed to be monetarily motivated. What was the yearly revenue for Monsanto last year? How many billions?

    FataMorgana

    Here is a link that might be useful: Genetically Engineered Corn Could Harm Aquatic Ecosystems

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "With herbicide resistant crops, the plants are producing and carrying no pesticides. What the genes do is allow farmers to spray the crop with broad spectrum, low toxicity herbicides and the plant has the ability to deactivate the herbicide quickly so it suffers no damage"

    What would be nice would be to introduce the same genes for herbicide tolerance into other, native wild plant species, so they have some chance of avoiding complete extinction by being able to survive being sprayed. At the moment, they don't.

    Or even better, a ban on herbicides.

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I saw a picture in a Geograhic Magazine that showed a Tobacco plant that glowed in the dark. It had been gene spliced with a gene that causes chemical light in a firefly or some similiar creature. The purpose was to study the Tobacco mosaic virus.
    I'm waitng for glow in the dark trees, shrubs, perennials, and lawns. Maybe just a specimen tree or two.
    Maybe they can gene splice a handcart to some trees so the rootball will have wheels. The possibilities are endless!

  • 19 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    They say Atlantis fell in part because the scientists went overboard creating odd creatures, mixing and matching and having "unexpecteds." I worked for a year at OHSU and this was in the news:
    "ANDi, the first transgenic Rhesus monkey, carries the gene for a green fluorescent protein derived from Jellyfish, but he doesn't glow yet, as have other mammals, like mice, who have undergone this sort of procedure."

    Since I want long green silky thick hair all over, the article interested me, but don't know if I'll be able to re-make this bod in this lifetime. Someday, though, it will be like going to the dept store make-up counter, just the genetic makeover to-order.

    In any case it would be prudent for these frankenarboranimalists to thoroughly test their creatures before letting them out into the world. Thanks to all for all the posts -- learning a lot on gardenweb!

    Botann, you would like some Ents in your fabulous garden.