Software
Houzz Logo Print
cascadians

Do Roots Come UP for Air?

18 years ago

Anyone ever heard of massive amount of spider-web looking roots coming up for air when the ground gets really saturated with rain?

Just 2 days ago I was looking at these arctic blue willow tree wells which were dark brown dirt, and today there's no dirt to be seen, only a massive web of fine roots very thick covering the entire well and rim. It's been raining massive amounts and most of the yard is submerged. These tree wells are near a very full creeklet.

If I put a lot of birdseed out on the ground for an extended period of time the birds will peck some of the dirt away exposing some roots but I've never put seeds in these arctic blue willow tree wells. It has not sunk so where could the rich dark brown earth have gone in the last 2 days unless these roots surfaced to breathe?

Or is it possible the tree could have actually grown such massive web of roots in 2 days? It's been between 30 and 45 degrees with some snow but mostly copious rain.

Will take a picture when possible and have it put on a CD at Costco then photobucket then on this thread but meanwhile have you ever heard of roots rising to the surface and above ground to breathe?

I'm afraid when we soon have a hard freeze the tree will croak. These are arctic blue weeping willows with big smithiana rootstock suckers now bigger than the arctic trunk. Will prune out a lot of the suckers in a couple of weeks when it gets colder and supposedly trees go dormant. They're not dormant at all now, growing like crazy even though leaf-less and forming their big fuzzy catkins.

When it stops raining should I cover these big webs of fine roots with dirt to protect against freezing?

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    No, I don't think they rise to breathe. Roots will survive in those areas of soil where there is adequate aeration, therefore in an established root system, you will see the roots proliferate in those areas, giving the impression they "grew to seek air". Better put, they failed to produce roots where there wasn't.

    Given the soil hadn't washed away, and if they were in wells, the soil likely didn't wash, I'd suspect a collapse of the air spaces or degradation of the tilth of the soil caused by the particles of earth floating and then collapsing as the water drained. I don't know if you have frost heave in your climate, either, but in my area, the soil expands as it freezes the water in the surface area of the soil and when it thaws, it leaves cracks, crevices and craters in the soil surface.

    Other thoughts?

  • 18 years ago

    Tree roots sometimes emerge from the ground under humid conditions, as in a woodland. And where soil aeration is interfered with, as when a smothering layer (plastic, carpeting, thick newspapers...) is left in place for awhile over root zones these barriers to gaseous exchange will often be found later to have a mat of above-ground roots plastering the bottoms of them, with the soil beneath mostly empty.

    Roots grow in the pore spaces between soil particles. Where conditions are humid enough, as on the trunks and branches of trees in rain forests myriad small flowering plants grow their entire lives completely disconnected from the ground. Some, such as bromeliads and orchids may be attached to bare or nearly bare sections of branch, the damp atmosphere keeping them alive. No soil required.

  • 18 years ago

    If there are roots exposed, and if you are expecting freezing weather, I would put dirt or mulch over the root area, no deeper than 4" (2" for dirt), as widely as you can, and put no mulch in the 2-4" next to the trunk.

    Is it possible that what you are seeing is not roots but part of a fungal body? I understand the hyphae (sp?) of fungus can look like a root mass - judging from what I have seen, I would believe that. Beyond that, if the rain hasn't washed away fine dirt at the surface, and the birds haven't been scratching around at the base of the willows, I have no idea.

  • 18 years ago

    Don't think it's fungus but roots. Will take pictures tomorrow if possible. It was supposed to snow a lot today but no flakes here. The shape of the well, which is raised a bit on a little mound, is the same as it was, but now instead of dirt it's very thick roots. Quite freaky so fast. Thanks for all the info. After taking pictures I'll put 2" of dirt (have some 4-way-blend in buckets) over the roots.

    When the yard drains I'll have to examine every tree well to see where else this has happened. I know trees want air but aren't they smart enough to know shooting out roots above ground like this makes them susceptible to freezing? and burning drying in summer?

  • 18 years ago

    Salix purpurea is very hardy, hence "Arctic". You can sometimes also see willows sending out sheets of fresh-looking roots into water in local wetlands. You would have encountered a quantity of root growth at this time of the year on your trees because fall is when most elongation of existing roots occurs (60% of annual total).

  • 18 years ago

    Thanks, yes I've been praying this long warm very wet fall would stimulate lots of root growth. The first batch of trees was planted Dec05 so they're about to enter their 3rd year after planting when they supposedly will "leap!" The 5 salix purpurea pendulas were planted in that 1st batch so maybe this actually is the promised root growth. It's just that there were no roots at all visible 2 days ago and now thick root web is the ONLY thing visible. Thought they'd slow down when it started freezing but that hasn't happened yet.

    Their rootstock is smithiana which has made many enormous sprouts (now trees) since last spring, up from the ground and also the trunk. Zounds! Really needed the tall shade they produce but they're literally crowding out some evergreens so very soon I'll be pruning several out. Will take pictures.

    I hope these arctic willows have grown as many roots UNDER the ground as they've suddenly grown on top of the ground.

    Have a purple robe locust planted Dec05 in the patio where I scatter seeds for the juncos and just a couple days ago saw very big roots exposed in its well and beyond, but just big root not web matt of fine roots. Thought the dirt eroded there from rain and bird pecking. Will take pictures of this also.

    Must say that first batch of about 200 trees are showing signs of really beginning to establish now. Their branches and trunks are thickening and elongating all this autumn and I'm very excited about spring. I planted way too many trees in here so will have to prune a lot and shape.

    My housemate can't believe these arctic roots either! It's like science fiction looking at them compared to the earth a couple days ago.

    Really appreciate everybody's expertise and advice. THANK YOU !!

  • 18 years ago

    If the roots are coming from your plantings and they're all grafted onto Salix X smithiana then actually those would be the roots you are seeing, rather than S. purpurea roots.

  • 18 years ago

    Yep, the purpurea graft is about 5' up, quite visible. From there down all smithiana, an extraordinarily vigorous willow which grows and suckers insanely fast and has big fluffy bright yellow catkins in the spring. Didn't know this when I bought the trees (they were small dead sticks on sale for $5 each at the nursery; they had dried out) but called the origin on the tag last spring when the suckers went bonkers. All the willows have been an interesting experiment.

    The 2 original Prairie Cascades are very very fast and spectacular. They look like something from under the ocean now, glowing golden and shooting out so many branches it's a jungle. Going to be very busy soon with pruning. Will try to take pictures today. Right now it's still raining hard and the yard is completely submerged. The creeklets drain it off within a couple days but we've had so much rain it may take longer.