Software
Houzz Logo Print
amccour

IKEA's cacti.

16 years ago

Fun observation.

Friend of mine got me a Mammilaria elongata (I think?) from IKEA last fall. I never bothered repotting it because it was almost winter and I figured that I wasn't really going to be watering it enough.

A few months ago, I started giving my cacti fairly small amounts of water every two weeks or so to acclimate them to more frequent and heavy summer waterings, as per... someone's recommendations. No issues with this, except for the M. elongata, which promptly rotted. After watering it like... once.

I thought that was sort of odd, but tossed it up to the rather poor potting mix IKEA would've been using.

After I actually got around to cutting it up to try and get some salvageable pieces to re-root (I'm not really a fan of Mamms. Can you tell? Sorry ;]) and it looked like it had been potted *way* too deeply.

So, on a hunch, I went and repotted an E. Trigona I got from the same IKEA muuuch more recently. It hadn't rotted, but I actually like E. Trigonas so I was more concerned about future issues with that. Anyway, same thing. I had to peel away about two inches or three of potting mix before I could actually find where the roots were. And the root system's sort of stunted because it was shoved against the bottom of the pot.

Anyway, maybe I've got it underpotted now, but it still looked like it was planted way too deeply, and with the soil way too compressed.

Has anyone ever seen anything similar? I'm not sure who IKEA's supplier is, but it does sort of bug me.

(The original potting mix was actually less bad than the Mamm's, which was pure peat. This was just mostly peat with some bark. In any case, I don't think what I put it in was much better, since I just cobbled it together from vermiculite, perlite, and some of the original mix after I sifted most of the peat out of it. Still too heavy, but my town lacks decent and affordable gardening stores so I'm forced to cobble stuff together from various Miracle Gro products. Irritating!).

Comments (22)

  • 16 years ago

    I have almost given up giving instructions here because no one listens, they know it all, that is why they ask questions.
    If you look back on previous post you will see me screaming no peat moss, water thoroughly only when needed. Change a new plants soil immediately. Exchange sick plants immediately. Don't water cactus in the winter, just let the rain do the job, cactus need cool winters no water to go dormant in order to flower in the summer. All Madagascar plants need warmth in winter, don't water plants unless they show the beginning of growth, no roots, no water. Use a chop stick to see if the soil is dry, your finger will work as well, use fast draining potting mix. it is not a soil. Ask if they like sun or shade. All plants flower so don't ask. Ask how low of temperatures they will tolerate. These are just a few of the basic pieces of information you will need. Not all plants are treated equal, I grew 350 Crassula at one time, some were summer growers, and other would die if I watered them in the summer. Most are winter grows. I used this as an example. If is doubt about package mix, add 50% pumice. or perlite which ever is available. Most of your problems are because you live in Zone 5. Are you on the East coast, that is another problem if you are a beginner, but it is doable. Cactis and Succulents are grown all over the world inside and outside growing conditions. I know this because I have traveled, and others from all of the wold have visited me here and at the Huntington Gardens, we learn from each other because we listen very carefully. This is a sharp group and they will help you, just ask more questions. Norma

  • 16 years ago

    While everything you've said is a valid point, I'm not entirely sure how that pertains to what I was talking about :)

  • 16 years ago

    Cacti lose their fine roots when left dry for a long time, and they must form new ones before they can take up water. So, if they are potted in peat (which is a good growing medium for various germs that attack cacti) and the water stays there for a long period, there is a substantial risk for rot. This is one reason why I don't use peat.

    Yes, I have seen similar deep planting of cuttings. It works for plants where new roots emerge from the side of the stems (Opuntia for example), not so well for other plants, as you have noticed. I guess the growers try to minimize the time it takes to get a plant stable enough for transporting.

    I don't know who IKEA's supplier is, but I have seen plants from the same source elsewhere, so I believe it is one of the mass-production nurseries in Holland, Southern Europe or Denmark, unless they use a local supplier for the US stores.

  • 16 years ago

    The Mamm was looking sort of dessicated and floppy which is why I tried watering it in the first place. And as I said, I only gave it a little water and because of that other stupid property of peat, where it basically becomes impossible to re-wet if it gets to dry, most of that water ran off anyway. Oh well. Ce la vie.

    Anyway, repotted another two IKEA cacti. This was interesting.

    1. I actually need an ID on this sometime, but it's some sort of globose (possibly columnar, eventually) cactus. It wasn't really potted TOO deeply although maybe a little more deeply than I would've like. Potting mix wasn't TERRIBLE. Still too much peat, but it had a lot of pine bark in it as well. Fairly easy to brush off, so I did that.

    And then I got to the core of the... soil column and found a rock-hard glob of what honestly looked like yard dirt. Good lord. I don't expect a lot from the included potting mix from cacti that come from big box stores, but seriously? Two completely different kinds of soil? I've never really seen that before.

    Anyway, this plant seems otherwise fine. I'm not potting it up again right away because I almost certainly damaged the roots and I'm assuming I want them to air-dry and callous over before I do anything else.

    2. The other one wasn't in great shape beforehand because it had been sort of infested by mealies and root mealies earlier this year. At that point I noticed that the plant was desperately underpotted, with the roots circling the outside of the pot in a thick mass which would probably have no capabilities of taking up water, which is probably what contributed to the mealies in the first place. In any case, it may or may not have rot/some sort of irreversible damage from the mealies. It has some dark patches on it although they look fairly superficial and haven't spread over the past two or three months. If they're not I can't really do anything about it anyway, so whatever happens happens.

    Anyway, I think this one may have also been potted too deeply as well. The center of balance on the pot felt... rather off, and a lot of the body seemed like it was buried as well, although maybe it's geophytic and that was normal.

    Potting mix here was incredibly odd. It was a mix of some grainy black substance with the consistency of clay and something that looked like tiny glass crystals and was probably some kind of coarse sand. I'm not sure why it was so clay-like. That could've been the mix itself, or possibly the result of the horitcultural oils I was using to treat the root mealies. In any case, it was a pain to clean out.

    So, what lesson have I learned from this? I really ought to be repotting cacti from big box stores as soon as I buy them.

  • 16 years ago

    Write IKEA and tell them of this blasphemous cactus treatment.

    Your last statement could not be more true, but I'd extend that to almost any nursery until you're sure you find one that doesn't use execrable soil.

  • 16 years ago

    I'm no longer surprised by anything I find in succulent soil from plants from the big box stores, like rocks and pieces of plastic.

    Home Depot used to take cacti in normal pots, place them in larger decorative pots, and fill the space inbetween with....sphagnum moss! Talk about sending the wrong message!

    Norma, with all due respect, I think people would listen to your advice if it were more directly targeted to the questions asked (as the OP mentioned) instead of turning into general statements. And I certainly disagree with your advice about Madagascan species (E. trigona is not one BTW)...certainly the majority of Madagascan Euphorbias will die if not watered at all during dormancy.

    -R

  • 16 years ago

    How many times have I said no peat moss. It is for tropicals. I was told today to try Palm tree mix. I don't know I haven't used it yet. Check it out if you are able to obtain it. Don't use Peat Moss with Cactus and Succulents, NOT PEAT MOSS WITH CACTUS AND SUCCULENTS, This is how it pertains, I did target the question asked, but I need people to learn how to read. I wasn't even referring to Madagasar species, they are not cactus, the person was discussing a Mamm. a new World species if the cactus genus. Paragraph #1 Jeesh read people read I don't mind to be corrected for a legitimate reason, but don't make up ones. Norma

  • 16 years ago

    Norma, did you forget to take your meds?

    -R

  • 16 years ago

    PS to R,

    AND, if said in jest, sorry, not funny!

  • 16 years ago

    Please stop glueing flowers and eyes on your cactus !

  • 16 years ago

    I have no idea what N is ranting about most of the time. I have been able to read since I was about 4 so I don't think that is the problem LOL!

    Yes, I have had the same encounter, a lot of plants are grown in beds not individual pots then dug for sale, that's why you get the original dirt and the "new" potting mix, they stick the dug up plant in the pot, add enough mix to fill it in and then ship it. I know it's done because I've seen it done with things like plumeria in Hawaii. Untrained low paid workers with no experience in plants, stick it in and make it stand up is pretty much it for instructions on planting.

    Guess what else? There are TROPICAL cactus! Yes, indeed there are tropical cactus, wow! They do grow all over the world, which does include the tropics. See? I can read, Norma said she traveled all over the world, I assume that includes tropical locations.
    Dragonfruit, which is a cactus, and is tropical, thrives in a much richer soil mix then most of us use on our other cactus/succulents/euphorbias/whatever, grow it in the mix preferred here and you get no fruit, no blooms, poor growth. Mine is in a, GASP!, PEAT based mix and growing like a weed. There are others in the yard but I have to fertilize them more often, growing in all that SAND-I do live on a SANDBAR after all.

    "All cactus are succulents but not all succulents are cactus" so really we're talking about succulents anyway.

    Good luck with your newly planted babies, I understand about making do with potting mixes, Houston may be a big city but I live in a small, very small and shrinking town 60 miles away, pretty long trip for potting supplies. I hate, hate, hate, hate perlite and refuse to use it.
    Tally HO!

  • 15 years ago

    @pirate_girl

    "AND, if said in jest, sorry, not funny!"

    I found it funny

    P.s.Norma is a massive retard

  • 15 years ago

    Incidentally, I have kept a number of Mammillaria species in pots over the years, and I have found that elongata seems more prone to rotting than the others I have grown. All but one of my elongata (probably of at least eight originally) have eventually rotted (i have variously kept cuttings, etc.), but I have done much better with other species.

  • 15 years ago

    I think what the old timers on this board forget is that for every one of you there are 10 new or occaisonal members. You may repeat yourself endlessly but it is to new people 80% of the time, so to yell at the newbies or occaisonal users is pointless and rude. It's a message board to post questions and share information, if you don't feel like answering a question b/c its a common question then don't answer it but the lectures about checking back through the archives are not helpful either. Try being helpful vs. being exasperated it may change your whole outlook on things.

  • 15 years ago

    two comments about the Ikea plants. 1), mammillaria elongatas are certainly not the most senstitive to rot of the mamms by a long shot... If they were I could never grow them as I rot about half the mammillaria species consistently. But this plant IS very sensitive to low light and watering (needs full sun) AND they are sensitive to water from above (likes to be watered from 'below'... in other words, be sure the plant is not buried too deeply and then put the whole pot in water and let the water get to the roots only.. .rotting on this one starts from above. Since I have watered that way, I have not killed one of these yet.

    2) it is not really Ikea's fault the Euphorbia trigona was planted so deeply. It was undoubtedly planted as a cutting, and you HAVE to plant cuttings deeply or they will simply fall over. You can, at a later time, if you want, raise them up, but I find this usually unecessary as the below tissues eventually harden into a form of woody material and adjust to their new below-ground life... not true with all cuttings or species, but most that root easily from cuttings work this way. Sometimes if you want to try, you can just set a cutting balanced on the surface and support it somehow, it will also often root. But this takes a LOT more work and time and a place like IKea, or just about ANY nursery is not going to bother.

  • 15 years ago

    PS Norma is a friend of mine and though she is eccentric, she always means well and is a wealth of succulent knowledge and vast experience. In person she is delightful... and 'delightfully quirky'. Sometimes we all get on a tangent, some of us more than others.

  • 15 years ago

    Amazing comments almost to the point of entertaining Short punch in here A neighbor of mine has a cactus called M elongata that's been in a deep heavy soil for years. I cringe too, yet even thou it is in a super saturated heavy soil of a deep PLASTIC container it grows and it's growing rather well if I may add
    It's not that you have gotten poor advice to not use peat for cactus fact is alot of the info you have read is cross talk chit chat, how it is intended for for better growing of cactus is beyound me too Perhaps a cyber nudge or two to someone else in there persistence or insistence to NOT USE peat is all it is.

    The Elongata I discribed is an oddity to even me, regardless of what is said or insulted upon in a public forum it grows. The the lesson I get to learn is this: Some plants NOT ALL have an ability to adapt to there environment regraldless of what insults others may share or the soil it rest in.

    Hypercritical: In one thread they are saying how great and knowledgeable the GW forum people are and then the GREAT AND KNOWLAGABLE say the opposite on a different thread
    On this thread my thought is.
    Adapting to an environment:
    If they think insulting makes my plants grow better then let them insult away. In reality it doesn't allow any plant to grow better but it did allow them to show there true self. IMO They should of spoke for themselves with at least an ounce of respect to another persons opinion

  • 15 years ago

    I don't grow many Mamm's, mostly because they aren't my interest, although I can see how others could get fascinated with the genus. My particular clone of M. elongata (one of the red-spined variants) is almost bullet-proof and has survived being neglected and temps below freezing.

    Norma may go a bit off the rails now and then, but she is incredibly generous with her observations and advice.

    lzrddr, great comment about Euphorbia cuttings. I think raising them (especially the species that stem from the base) might actually inhibit their growth, but I've never tried that, so it's pure speculation on my part.

    -R

  • 15 years ago

    I've emailed GW yesterday morning asking that Emma's post be removed.

    I sure wish folks who have spent no time here answering questions would refrain from advising those who have, but I guess that's like asking for the sun to rise in the West.

  • 15 years ago

    Bravo, Jeff.

    Christopher

  • 15 years ago

    Wow, I turn my back and we have a tornado of thorny prickly characters rubbing each other raw. Sometimes I think that this is just who we are. We are becoming like our plants like dog owners take on their dogs characteristics. WE grow prickly and throw barbs so easily. Lets not forget patience and tolerance as we extricate unwanted sharp entries.