Software
Houzz Logo Print
carnivorous_freak

dormancy indoors

21 years ago

How do you think I should provide a good dormancy indoors? I am growing a vft and Byron I beleive said in my last post "biggest vft" they do not need a yearly dormancy to stay healthy but all of the websites I've been to say they do need a yearly dormancy now what?

Comments (20)

  • 21 years ago

    Go to this site:

    http://home.petflytrap.com/users/scottychaos/cpnavigatorpage.html

    This guy explains how he first takes all of his dormancy requiring plants and cuts off their leaves, seals them all in zip-lock bags, then stores them in his fridge for the winter. Once spring rolls around, he takes them out and the growing begins. Seeing this guy's example, I'm planning on doing the exact same come dormancy time.

  • 21 years ago

    If it was me? I would cut off all the leaves leaving stubs dont cut to into the Rhymzone, (the white part), and put a anti Fungle Powder Sulfer based on the top soil, and put the plants into a large plastic bag, water the plants one last time, and in they go for Halloweentill about Valentines, no specific date. If no Fridge is avilble then kinda just put them in a unheated grage or shed, if thats not avilible then dont know exactly what to tell you.

  • 21 years ago

    Venus' flytraps DO need dormancy in order for them to survive. If you ignore their dormancy rest, nothing will be left but a Rotten, leaveless Bulb. Try it and you'll find it out on your own. I did that same mistake in the past with my first venus' flytrap; i ignored about giving it it's dormancy period, and guess what happened? yes it died. In the wild, ALL venus' flytraps go through dormancy period, even seedlings. If you live in an area that gives you a really cold climate during winter, you can leave your plant outdoors, otherwise, you can place it inside a ziplock bag and into the fridge(but make sure the plant's media is bearly moist before storing the pot inside the fridge, otherwise, fungus will begin to grow in a very wet media if stored inside the ziplock-bag into the fridge)you can resume your plant's growth around february through march. everytime you give your plant its dormancy period, it explodes into many growing rhyzomes after introduced to full sun again after dormancy. You see, venus' flytraps grow from bulbs, Its Bulb rests through winters.. it also reserves energy inside the bulb for next season's growth. if the bulb doesn't aquire it's rest, the plant/bulb dies.. Imagine how you would feel being at work or at school without a week from sleep.. pretty crappy no? well think of it the same way about the venus' flytraps.. they do indeed need atleast 3-4 months of dormancy period rest..

  • 21 years ago

    Let me explain again. I never said that VFTs do not need dormancy. They need dormancy when they want to go dormant. They do not need dormancy if they do not want to.

    Pushing dormancy on a VFT is just a waste of time, and it is also dangerous to the plant. Also, many plants that you place on artificial dormancy come out and do not register what has happened as a dormant stage, so they might go dormant again in a couple of months and leave you wondering why did the plant went dormant again so soon?

    The Fridge Method

    This is a method that has many flawds. One, you can forget your plant, and leave it there for more than the right amount of time. Two, the plant can get fungy and die pretty quickly if you forget to check it. Three, sometimes the humidity tends to move to one side and makes that side very wet while another very dry. If the plant is in the wet side, it may die of rot.

    When you place the plant dormant on a windosill and water it every day, you are always aware that the plant is there. You check the plant every day, for you water it every day. So it has better chances to survive.

    I have tried many theories. I am just giving the one that best works for the plants I have.

    {{gwi:554453}}

    This is a Big Mouth. It has not been dormant for five years. To keep its size from growing too large I feed it only once every seven months or so.

  • 21 years ago

    Thanks but how do you know when or when not the plant wants to go dormant? Thanks

  • 21 years ago

    Hi Byron, I can fully understand what you are saying.
    For those growers that have their plants outdoors year round, I would imagine if it is at all possible this would be the more natural way (better way?) to go about things for the plant as it can grow in a far closer way as it would in nature.

    Im hoping to create a small bog sometime, although my pitchers are growing in a crazy way (under temps over 108 F!!) I have heard that a fellow grower in SLC did not have much luck in keeping his VFT's alive outdoors in the type of heat that is experienced here.

    Anyhow, it is clear from both your pictures and your papers that whatever you are doing, the plants sure do like.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Byron 1,
    Also how do you put your plants into dormancy? Im asking for YOUR method on your vft's and sarracenia. THANKS AGAIN

  • 21 years ago

    You know when your plant is going dormant because the growth slows down or stops completely. Then, the leaves begin to burn until a few or none remain.

    Most of the time, I place my plants on an east facing window during dormancy, keeping the moisture very low. So I water them with a sprayer every morning. The next morning the peatmoss is lighter in appearance, and I have to spray again.

    Sometimes they come out of dormancy in three to four months some longer. Those who take longer I replant them and place them under florecent lighting. After that they come back alive in a few weeks.

    My Sarracenias are growing outside, so I do not touch them. They go dormant naturally during winter. The VFTs that are growing outside in full sun, I do not touch ether.

    The onces that I have to take care are the onces that grow under the porch roof during the summer time because that is when they go dormant due to the lack of sun during the summer time.

  • 21 years ago

    The signs of Venus' flytraps going to dormancy are simply Weak Signs of growth(usually around Late October) , all leaves and traps turn brown and die off & The plant stops growing completely.. and the new sent leaves from the center of the bulb growth shorter or stop growing. I just simply gave my advice.(it's your choice to listen or not) Who would forget a very precious, valuable plant inside a fridge anyway? Maybe some one who doesn't give a crap about it? Definatly not me; i check my plants if they're Ok inside the fridge once every 2 weeks, and it does just fine, i've done the fridge method for the past 2 years.. and nothing has gone wrong. Southern CA has very hot summers and very warm falls.. in order for me to offer my plant's dormancy is by placing them in the fridge, i have no other choice. Venus' flytraps do need dormancy to survive, However, if it's bought off-season(October-december)it is usually ok to keep growing it, but if you live in a very cold area, it will go dormant anyway. If you ignore the plant's survival needs while not being experienced by growing the plant, you may lose your plant. just giving you some experienced advice..

  • 21 years ago

    I really believe dormancy happens because of 2 reasons.
    The shortening of the light interval aka photo period,during the fall months and also the cooler temperatures.
    I also think the reason so many people fail to raise their first flytrap bought at a box stores(LOWE"S WALMART HOME DEPOT etc) is that the plants have been articially forced to grow under lights and a improperly aerated media. Then placed totally in the darkest corner of the store near the ckeckout stand to be bought on a whim. They are never properly watered(distlled ot low mieral) and the big wholesale nursery that produces them is jest into to make money and don't really care if the plants die.The store don't care becasue if the plants die they get their money back.
    ....stepping down off my soap box.
    Thanx for listening and keep 'em plants growin'
    Lois

  • 21 years ago

    Geeee Xymox, do I notice a little anger towards my advice?

    I am the one growing Big Mouth and Royal Reds with almost two inch size traps. Which, by the way, you could have had one if you would have been honest to me remember?

    I got over a thoulsand plants now and about ten cultivars of my own, including an all purple flytrap, one that cralws around as it grows (really weird!), a very short leaf VFT "Wally" and a sawtooth red giant.

    I have been studying this plant for more than seven years. God it seems like five! And I have learned many things about the plant.

    Dormancy is triggered more by the photo period. But it can also be triggered by the plant getting weak as well. This can happend if you let your plant flower, and it is not strong enough. It can also happen if the environment is too hot and the plant can not handle growing properly.

    Cold temperatures usually do not make the plant go dormant. This is why I used to place a perfectly growing VFT inside the frindge, just to take it out a few months later, and to my surprise, it went dormant again!

    Drying out the soil a bit gradually or accidentally makes the plant go dormant quite often too.

    I have got nothing a gainst you Xymox, if you keep growing your plants some day soon you are going to reach the same conslussion.

    I used to be all for dormancy this and dromancy that. Every time the plant had a problem it was dormancy.

  • 21 years ago

    Byron_1, I believe all to well that you do know what you are doing.
    New advice can be hard to swallow, just like me and my "CP's dont all need this high humidity" thing.
    I made the leap from tidbits that I got online, and this was then furthered by the guys at cobraplant.
    I think terrariums are great if you have the money to create an ideal setup. (if the plant MUST have a high humidity)
    A good terrarium setup can also be a beutiful thing, but if you are a normal grower that just loves these plants and wants them to be healthy, then this is where I climb off the band wagon and think adapting them to the outside air is the best thing.
    I feel that the best way for people to know is to try.
    I was sceptical about this humidity deal from start, heck I did'nt like the whole fish bowl thing from start.
    I made the leap, took the chance and my plants are SUPERB.

    I feel that those that are willing should try your methods, even if it is with 1 or 2 of their VFT's, they could then even compare these with ones that are "forced" into dormency.

    Reports back from further people would be a great thing, I am currently creating new plants from leaf cuttings.
    I will be trying your methods and reporting back on the plants progress so that everyone can see my results as well.

    Your PDF document online was one of the first papers I read on the VFT, I took a lot of your advise and applied it to my plants with great success.

    I think people need to do what they are happy with, but at the same time try different thing to expand their understanding.

    Just my 2 cents worth.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Don't worry Byron, i face nothing against you either. I am here to help, not argue; arguing is for babies... I am just giving my personal advice, but people who haven't EVEN growned for a YEAR will most likely face failure to mimick your method. VFT dormancy is very important.. and yes.. i was being honest to you(not my fault the package was lost, things happen).. i have some divisions that is growing at the moment.. but the plants are a bit small, but it's packed with nice traps..(btw they're divisions(not full growned plants) from my giant vft) why do you want more giant vfts anyway? haven't you got enough? I only have 3 giant clones, and it makes me happy enough. I only have these giant clones, the original giant from best carnivorous plants, the Bigmouth cultivar, and the vigorous(this guy grows freaking tall and makes traps 1 inch and 6 centimeters! sometimes the tall leaves bend sideways due to its big traps) Well anyway...dormancy is an important factor for the vft.. i said what i had to to say..

  • 21 years ago

    Hello Xymox,

    I am a Southern Californian grower who grows VFTs outdoors year round. The plants get dormancy in the winters all right. However, I live a bit inland so my winter lows are colder and the highs are a bit warmer. I just leave all my VFTs outside. I can't estabalish much about dormancy since I moved twice and the first winter my plants spent was in a shaded but very warm apartment patio, then moved to a colder spot when I moved into a house. Anyway, most the plants did go dormant. Some went very deep into it and lost all its foliage save 2 shoots. Among them were the "Blood Red Traps" and "Green Dragons". Some were just lingering around a cruise control state and producing small traps on and off and still keeping about half of the previous year's foliage. Among these were "Big Mouth", "Royal Red", "Prostrate", and some others. One plant completely refused to go dormant and grew large rosettes with large deep red traps throughout the winter and spring months. That plant was the "Dingley Giant"(I think I previously mentioned how this plant particularly despises hot summers). But despite any of the ways the plants behaves during the winter, they all still gorw with vigor after dormancy. The "Dingley Giant", instead of growing ground rosettes vigorously, grows large traps on tall leaves vigorously(however by midsummer the plant sometimes gets burns) Anyway, so dormancy in Southern California is very much possible. You'll have to experiement with it. This year I plan to leave my VFTs out in full sun during the winter. This is ok since the plants are getting full sun right now.

    I hope the little issue with the packages is behind you and Byron. You both post the nicest VFT pictures on this forum.

    Over and out,
    Phong

  • 21 years ago

    Hi Xymox,

    Arguing is for babies, so it would be a good idea to give our opinions without making the other person feel unwantned.

    All of my ideas are backed up by research and experience. So when you say only some one who does not gives a crap about this would do that, you are kind of givin an indirect insult to what the other writer is suggesting.

    If I did not like my plants, I would not have so many of them. I have a web site telling people how to take care of them, and I love to do conversations on this forum about them.

    When it comes to dormancy, I always say that dormancy is needed when the plant wants to go through it, but it is not needed when the plant does not want to.

  • 21 years ago

    Hey Byron

    Im curious about your opinion on one thing though (I dont think I asked this correctly)
    With your experience of plants going into dormency when they need it, if I was in a warm coastal location that got no snow and the winters were not icey, under such conditions, do you feel that a VFT grown there would go into dormency when the plant needed it even though the temp would be nowhere near the 40-50 F?

    Just curious about any experience you may have seen or heard of under such circumstances.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Hi Sheldon,

    This is something that I am afraid to answer. I can not believe when I found that this plant can live and trive like this.

    I hope and pray that the VFT can not survive in hot conditions troughout the year.

    The plants I have outside get winter dormancy. Some are not dormant during winter but they get the temperature changes.

    The ones in my terrarium get a cool temperature of 75F throughout winter and about 84F during summer. These are not what I could consider tropical temperatures, so I am hoping that this plant can not survive tropical temperatures for years.

    How many people place their VFT after spending three months in the fridge, then take them out, and for some reason do not grow. And you wait and wait and then you look and find that the bulb has rotted. I have had that happen to me too much.

    The plants I like a lot, I watch closely; watering them every day with a sprayer until they come out of it.

    I got some tiny bulbs right now that have gone dormant. These once I place in live spagnum moss in a pot with a top for moisture. That is the only way to prevent them from dieing. They have to grow in a moist environment near the air conditioning until they get the growth going well again. They will never make it in the fridge.

    Yes tiny plants can go dormant if given the right photo period. Even some seedlings can deploy flower stalks, which you should cut off if you want the seedling to grow.

  • 21 years ago

    Hey Byron_1

    Just thought Id let you know that I found a CP's nursery online back home in South Africa, from what I read on their dormency text, its asif they dont go to the extremes of putting the plants in a fridge, but simply leave the plant to go into dormency, once this occurs they then advise the normal steps of less water.
    I have emailed them asking how they go abouts dormency for all the american plants they grow.

    I will post their reply once I receive it.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

  • 21 years ago

    Hi Sheldon,

    I have seen pictures of South Africa on TV, and it appears to be a cool humid place. Many plants of many types grow there.

    It is probably a nice place to grow CPs. I just hope that the goverment does not allowes them to grow in the wild. I am concern with VFTs disturbing the native CPs on other parts of the world.

  • 21 years ago

    Yes

    Well the climate is hot and humid or in the central location of SA it is quite dry.
    The likes of Capensis and Aliciae grow in my home town which is on the coast and is EXTREMLY humid.
    I dont know how a VFT would survive in the wild as the temperatures are quite high and the winters are not that cold.
    It is so difficult to get CP's down there from South African suppliers as is.
    Infact the easiest way to get SA CP's is from USA/Britian suppliers!!.

    In my childhood I have only seen 1 single VFT, this was the only time I say a nursery carry a few, they all soon died due to care problems.

    Cheers

    Sheldon

Sponsored