Software
Houzz Logo Print
kwoods_gw

High ph S. purpurea?

20 years ago

I understand some S. purpurea are found in calcareous fens around the Great Lakes in alkaline conditions. Anyone evr tried growing these? Anyone know of a source for these? Genetic adaptation or if put in acid conditions would they "revert"? Any ideas/info appreciated.

Comments (12)

  • 20 years ago

    this article may have something you can use

    "MORPHOLOGICAL VARIATION IN SARRACENIA PURPUREA
    (SARRACENIACEAE): GEOGRAPHIC, ENVIRONMENTAL,
    AND TAXONOMIC CORRELATES"

    hope it helps,
    James

    Here is a link that might be useful: article

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks James. Not sure if it helps but it is definitely interesting.

    It seems like the study is designed w/ a bult in bias towards giving S. purpurea rosea special taxonomic status so it can be protected. I think that's an admirable goal but not sure if the study actually proves it is a distinct species. It does speak to the variability of S. purpurea across it's range and I like the fact that it accounts for enviornmental factors rather than just morphology. Any plant w/ such a huge range is bound to have a lot of variability and some subspecies but I tend to be a lumper so I can certainly wait for the eventual gene sequencing of the species(s).

    Taxonomy is interesting from an intellectual standpoint but I'm often unsure of the "splitting hairs" aspect of it from a pragmatic point of view.

    I also like that the study speaks to the cost of production of traps. If taken to it's logical conclusion that means the high ph, higher nutrient pitcher plants are fighting their nature and becoming more civilised. Eventually they will become more reliant on photsynthesis and abandon their blood thirsty habits. A sad prospect.

    Still looking for seeds of high ph S. purpurea.

  • 20 years ago

    I didnÂt know if there would be anything of use to you or not, but I thought the information was interesting and applicable to your quest.

    I also came to the same conclusions; your search will probably result with a specimen having large wings, narrow mouths and thin lips.

    Keep us posted please, I am interested in your results.

    Good luck
    James

  • 20 years ago

    Hey KWoods,

    My two cents on these plants. I would guess that in fact there are no high pH dependent/tolerant S. purpurea, or for that matter ones that couldn't grow in these calcareous habitats. Rather, being a far ranging species, it probably just is capable of living in a greater variety of habitats. I'd put money on it that a normal plant put in a high pH fen would live and look much like the plants already there, or conversely, a plant from the fen would behave much like a normal plant in an acidic bog. That would a more interesting experiment to me than simply growing seeds from a fen plant. Still, I wish you luck on getting a hold of some seed. PF

  • 20 years ago

    Hi PF,

    I'm already a bit ahead of you ;o). I have seed from "control" S. purpurea, purpurea and venosa as well just for fun. All I need now is some seeds from plants found in alkaline conditions. The plants do exist (found in waters surrounding the great lakes) and based on morphology they are "different". Whether it's the enviornment or a genetic adaptation, who knows? That's what I'm curious about. Might make a nice paper for someone since I can't seem to find any related studies. Alas, I'm just a hobbiest having fun indulging my curiosity.

    "I'd put money on it that a normal plant put in a high pH fen would live and look much like the plants already there," I'd say that's easy money for me ;o) I'll try it but we already have a pretty good idea of the outcome. Put a normal S purpurea in alkaline substrate and you get a dead S. purpurea :o( That's why I want to try it from seed. I think the "ph shock" of moving either adult plant would have an effect you couldn't easily control for.

    So far still can't locate any seeds.

  • 20 years ago

    PF

    You are nearly perfect in your assessment. I remember reading about S purpurea purpurea in the great lakes region. Plants from that region have a different growth habit than those grown in acidic conditions. But when transplanted to more acidic conditions they become all but indistinguishable from those found in acidic habitats. However it is was noted that SPP from acidic bogs show a significant reduction in viability when transplanted to an alkaline medium. This suggests there is a bit of genetic tolerance to the alkaline environment.

    If you are into such things this may indicate the beginnings of Âspeciation within the SPP population. Wait around for a couple hundred thousand years and we may have a new and distinct alkaline bog pitcher incapable of growing in acidic conditions.

  • 20 years ago

    Clay, that's exactly what I'm interested in! Do you remember where you read this? Was it base on scientific study or just anecdotal?

  • 20 years ago

    I'll try to find it but I have limited time these days.

    It was from a book but it referenced a journal article.

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks again Clay. I think one thing that might help is an article called "A critical review of published variants of Sarracenia purpurea" by Schnell but I can't seem to locate it, only citations.

    Had no idea S purpurea had such a wide ph range! 5.2 -8.9 according to the Linquist article. 8.9?.... that's crazy!

  • 20 years ago

    OK, how about planting "normal seeds" on an alkaline substrate? I'd predict that either none would grow (which might support the notion that there is in fact a pH tolerant plant), or that fewer than average would grow (which might support the notion that this species has the genetic capacity to withstand alkaline conditions).

    Worth a try if you've already got seeds! PF

  • 20 years ago

    You should check out "Carnivorous Plants of the United States and Canada" by Don Schnell. It has some interesting info on the S.purpurea growing in alkine soil.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting