Software
Houzz Logo Print
thisbetty

short lived coneflowers

19 years ago

Carolina Gardening (I think) ran an article about the short or semi-short or unpredictable life of coneflowers in his garden.

Mine have unpredictable, tho I only really noticed this when I began to pay so much for Ruby Giant, Sunrise, etc. Earlier Magnus and Bravado were so ignored that I just didn't keep up with them as I should have - some were planted way too late in the fall.

Anyway, what hass been your experience with the new improved

coneflowers? Sunrise and Sunset are so beautiful.

Comments (9)

  • 19 years ago

    In my experience, they are not what they're cracked up to be. Not real hardy, kinda wimpy, in fact. I like the old purple Magnus and my Doppleganger. I do have some white ones that are nice as well, but the oranges poop out for me.

    Sally

  • 19 years ago

    I have never had huge success with any of them - they all need a bit of management in my garden. I can usually keep a clump going for three years with little effort but by the fourth summer they are pretty much shot if they come back at all. I have overheard pro flower growers say something about about an aster disease that affects coneflowers in this area and since I have wild and cultivated asters in my yard that may be where my problem is.

    I have seen the sunrise orange ones thrive in the Raleigh area with little or no care so some people can get them to succeed here. And I have seen most of the wild forms in their native habitats and it makes you wonder why this group would have any problems in a garden. Echinacea purpurea growing wild in the mountains (hills) of Arkansas, in rocky forest soil in the deep shade! blooms 4 feet high or taller!! during a drought!!!

  • 19 years ago

    I have Sunrise and it has come back reliably for the third year even though it's in an unwatered border in full sun and competing with a shrubby tree and other perennials nearby. I really didn't think it would be that hardy but I guess they suffer most when overwintering in damp or heavily mulched beds.

  • 19 years ago

    I got suckered into buying "harvest moon". My SO once played the song for me and told me this was "our song" ha. So I bought two and had them in a spot where they would be treated well since they were 7.95 each. Only one came back and it looks pretty puny for its second year. They were both in an amended bed (sandy loam).

    At work we have all the new eichs and rudbeckias. I've never really been tempted by them since I love the tried and true old-fashioned varieties. Though I was bowled away by Magnus and have quite a few of them. Talking with customers I have heard from them also that they are not very reliable. I like to warn customers who are buying them since they usually all have that "big ticket" price. That said we had an absolutely gorgeous sunrise in our beds at work. Everyone who saw them bought one. Adele

  • 19 years ago

    I think a lot of it has to do with drainage (as does so much of gardening, for that matter). I see huge, floriferous clumps of echinacea in hilly areas (while visiting Boone, NC last summer, for instance). Mine are doing well if they return for a third year, and I'm sure it has to do with my heavy clay soil. I like the look of coneflowers in the garden, and their attractiveness to wildlife, so I buy two or three cheap seedlings every other year or so at the local wildflower sale, but it's not a plant I'd pay more than a few dollars to plant. This also illustrates the fact that not all perennials are created equal, despite what the nursery industry would have us believe; daylilies and peonies can last forever, but other things live too long to be called biennial, so everything gets labeled perennial.

  • 19 years ago

    I have grown magnus and White Swan for a number of years. They reseed and do well. I love that you don't have to dead head and the birds, especially goldfinch, will come and feast on the seeds. They are growing just outside the tall windows in the den and certainly provide on a good show. Nancy

  • 19 years ago

    My experience has not been good--I've got a number of the older tried and true cultivars, and last year got really excited about the Big Sky series (Sunset, etc). Bought three different ones, planted them in the same location/conditions as the others and....you guessed it...they definitely did not do well. One died last summer, one didn't come back after the winter, and the one that is left (Sunset, I believe) is tiny and struggling.

    They are still fairly expensive when you consider that their offspring will not be true to type. You are, essentially, buying a plant that at best will last probably 2-3 years...

  • 19 years ago

    Thank you for comments. The magazine article did mention the neccessity of very good drainage - esp. for E. purpurea. I also remember staring at coneflowers surviving the most miserable hot weather - the color faded but they usually survived. I have also read that their taproots make them so DT, but also a little harded to move if too much root is severed.

    I think the E. "Sunrise" is so beautiful - that soft cream yellow is hard to find in summer. It survived 2006-summer - 2007-summer.

  • 19 years ago

    The new ones are delicate and come with a big price tag. I tend to buy mine when the price is below 6.00 BUT Magnus is very reliable for me to the point where I have to pull them up and throw them away (I did this once now I know better ) I was complaining about their delicacy when they first hit the market because I paid 18.00 for an orange meadowbrite it bloomed once and died ....

Sponsored