Software
Houzz Logo Print
ururk

New foundation next to pine trees

17 years ago

We have 9 pine trees (blue spruce), all around 24 years old. They are approx 30 feet from the house, though could be closer (when all the snow melts, I'll be able to measure). They are about 50' tall. We might be adding on a small addition - year round sunroom - 10' from the house (a 10' x 12' room).

How do I figure out if there is any danger to the trees if a foundation is dug? I've read the following online about pine trees:

Tap root is very important

Tap root isn't as important as people say

Roots end at the dripline

Roots extend past the dripline twice the height of the tree

Roots live in the top 4" of soil

Cutting into the roots will cause dieback on that side of the tree

Some of it is conflicting advice. Any advice, or where to look (books) would be appreciative.

Comments (7)

  • 17 years ago

    If blue spruces (Picea pungens glauca) then not pines (Pinus species). Regardless of identity any substantial cutting or filling where roots occur may result in decline or even death of the trees. These are liable to extend well beyond the spread of their branches. Specific outcome cannot be predicted.

    Other construction hazards for trees are compaction of the root zones by vehicles and dumping of waste materials such as leftover concrete and cement mixer rinse water onto the rooting area.

  • 17 years ago

    define : FOUNDATION ....

    especially in regard to a sunroom ....

    are we talking 48 inches down through the permafrost zone in z5/6 .... or could we be talking cement pad???

    what is the building CODE for such ...

    at 40 feet away ... depending on the variables bboy notes... i would suggest you could easily avoid many of the problem causing variables ... since the project is so small... as compared to digging a basement for a 5000 sq ft ranch ....

    however ... i would assume loss ... of some.. and then be elated if nothing happened ...

    i would NOT be willing to wager any money on it all .. without being there in person to supervise ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    Foundation - 48" at least, cinder block (though... if the cost isn't too much different, we could go all the way down to the same level as the basement). A pad would be poured at the bottom (as opposed to loose soil). So there would be a 12' x 10' x 48" square hole.

    A year or two ago we had a tree expert out before to check the trees out (some browning - due to shading). Not too sure who we would call to make a determination, though. Is it even possible? I do realize there is a chance - always - that something could go wrong.

    I'll try to get measurements this week... the snow/cold/weather isn't cooperating, however.

    Thanks!

  • 17 years ago

    You may be focusing on the hole itself a bit too much and not heeding bboy's statement..."Other construction hazards for trees are compaction of the root zones by vehicles and dumping of waste materials such as leftover concrete and cement mixer rinse water onto the rooting area."

    I have a feeling the biggest threat to your trees is equipment coming and going, the actual digging of the hole, materials (cider block, soil) stored on top of the roots and the like. 50 foot trees and a lot of activity inside of 25 feet of them could be trouble. A lot may depend on what's on the other side of the trees and how those roots are.

    Ken is right, assume loss...

    tj

  • 17 years ago

    Blue spruce does not form a taproot of any importance. It is shallow-rooted, and its roots extend well out of the mythical fallacious "drip line". The main mass of its root system will be within 12-18 in. of the surface with roots going deeper only to the extent you force them to do so by underwatering.

  • 17 years ago

    Bboy is right. If you want to protect these trees make that part of the contract. Shoring can be used to minimize the excavation area beyond the foundation. Fencing should be installed adjacent to the excavation on the tree side and the contractor should not be allowed to cross this. Any dirt areas where they need to set up or drive equipment in the root zones but outside the fencing should be protected against compaction with either deep mulching, layering plywood, etc. I would not right-off these trees by digging 20 ft from them if you can avoid the the other hazards associated with construction. Just make sure you discuss this with your contractor so everyone is on the same page.

    Bill

  • 17 years ago

    Ok, thanks for the additional info. I measured one tree today - it was 35' away (perpendicular) from the house. I'll put up a diagram later when the snow is gone, or when I can measure them all. There are several trees, all staggered in a row about 60' long. House on one side, 40' of grass on the other.

    The biggest problem will be getting materials to the site, now that you mention it. Why? Because our lawn has trees all over, and getting the bricks to the location would mean either go in the front (trees) or the rear (septic / propane). Sigh.

    I guess this means having a contractor over for an estimate. I was hoping I could determine this myself, before getting an estimate for cost. Every time we've had a contractor over, they always "assure" us that the project will go smoothly, and then something goes awry. Which is why I try to do everything myself, when I can.