Software
Houzz Logo Print
pkapeckopickldpepprz

Name that pest game

Ok On my 3 citrus trees I am monitoring the growth or lack there of, and I spotted these today on all trees on the underside of leaves.

{{gwi:640812}}

{{gwi:640814}}

Any idea what I am up against? Scale isn't black and neither are aphids. Are these friend or foe? Never seen them before on any of my plants. Maybe this is the reason for no growth on my Tangelo, and 2 grapefruit trees?

Comments (28)

  • 20 years ago

    Those pics above are on my Ruby Red Grapefruit tree. This next pic I found on my Tangelo tree.

    {{gwi:640816}}

  • 20 years ago

    If Liberace had Citrus trees I'm sure this would be his prized possession with the exquisite black encrusted onyx stones.

  • 20 years ago

    Im sure that 1 leaf alone would pull in $10-$15,000 if it was authenticated as from Liberace's orchard.

  • 20 years ago

    Gawd! Those look like scales to me. But I am not an authority on this.
    Just don't send them my way!

  • 20 years ago

    Anyone's guess is as good as mine. I thought scales were rust or brown colored and I thought they attach themselves to bark not leaves? Strange as the roses I tend have scales on the stems but not the leaves and they are reddish brown or white.

  • 20 years ago

    Pepperz looks like scale to me, too..I believe there are different colored scale bugs. Hard and soft shell also.
    BTW, scale live on all parts of plants. They attach to bark, leaves, (upper and lower) too. God, I really hope you find a solution to this problem.
    Are the leaves you posted on trees growing in the ground or pots? Toni

  • 20 years ago

    They are growing in the ground. I sprayed organicide last week which says it kills scale insects. How often should I spray this? 1 X a week or more? Also with Fish Emulsion spray have any effect on them since they are established?

  • 20 years ago

    Citrus blackfly, without a doubt. It's a species of whitefly, and the adults are denim-blue. But you're seeing crawlers and pupae, which are black. Normally under excellent biological control; it becomes a problem only if you are spraying too often, with something that is killing off the biological control agent (a wasp). So the best thing to do is hold off on all sprays of any kind. They'll quickly disappear.

    Back in the '70s, before we had the parasites, people worried that blackfly could be the doom of the citrus industry in Florida. But once the parasites were introduced, they quickly became a non-issue.

  • 20 years ago

    Strange that these would be black fly due to me spraying as I just sprayed for the first time in years only 2 weeks ago. These look like an infestation that must have occured long before I sprayed? Any other opinions? Doing nothing is what led me to this situation to begin with.

  • 20 years ago

    Pepperz how many leavee have these bugs? They remind me of Papaya seeds..(S)
    If it was my tree, I'd be hosing daily. W/semi-strong spray..try spraying those suckers off.
    WAter won't hurt your plants, but too many chemcals will.
    I don't know about the Orangacide, (I've never used it so haven't any comments) but you can use FE once a month. It may not kill established bugs, (not sure) but may help kill future generations. I hope..I feel terrible for you, that leaf really looks bad. Toni

  • 20 years ago

    Those things are gross! They definitely look like the pics of the Citrus Blackfly larva I just looked up. There are a bunch of sites with recommendations on how to get rid of them. Just do a search for Citrus Blackfly. Good luck with your trees.
    Karyn

  • 20 years ago

    Karyn, I was just thinking about you..lol..Haven't seen you in a while..where have you been hiding?

  • 20 years ago

    There's no question at all that they're citrus blackfly (Aleurocanthus woglumi). And yes, they certainly could have started the infestation before you sprayed anything. I'm not saying that spraying "causes" an infestation; what I'm saying is that they only become really bad and damaging to the tree, if it's sprayed. Left unsprayed, their natural parasites will always get them under control quickly, anywhere in Florida. In fact that is true of all the common scales and whitefly species on Florida citrus.

    If you have good eyes or a magnifying glass, check the backs of the biggest ones (the pupae), and see if there are exit holes -- like a drilled hole in the center of the back. If so, you already have parasites present and taking care of the problem. They're rather like the thing in the "Alien" movies -- grows up in the blackfly, then burst out when mature, killing their blackfly host.

  • 20 years ago

    Ok I will check with a magnifying glass. If I use only FE, that should be safe to not kill off the beneficial predators, right? I think if I use Neem Oil or Organicide again it will only be monthly.

    Just curious how these citrus blackfly were able to get this bad if I never sprayed before 2 weeks ago. Where were the natural parasites I wonder?

  • 20 years ago

    pka, why spray anything? The very best thing you can do for a citrus tree in Florida is NOT spray it. At the very most, spray it no more than twice a year, and that's really overkill. Most home dooryard citrus problems here are due to overspraying. The one time you really may want to spray is June or July (early morning or late evening to avoid the heat of the day) with a petroleum-based spray oil, to control rust mites and greasy spot disease. Incidentally, such a spray will also control whiteflies and several scales, but if it weren't for the rust mites and greasy spot, there would be no reason to spray for those other pests. And as for the rust mites, they are just cosmetic -- they do no significant damage to internal fruit quality or total yield. But they do make the fruit look bad. Greasy Spot, on the other hand, is damaging to the tree, in that it knocks off too many leaves in the late fall and winter, so your yield the following year is reduced, and the tree is somewhat less cold-hardy this winter. For those two reasons, you may want to spray. But if you don't, the tree will grow and produce just fine anyway. The vast majority of home citrus trees in the state are never sprayed at all, and they grow and produce massive crops every year with no significant problems.

    Also if I'm seeing your last photo correctly, it's one badly affected leaf among a bunch of clean leaves. Is that correct? If so, you don't have a significant problem there.

    I certainly don't want to be argumentative, but in 26 years of teaching citrus pest- and disease-management at the college level, I've talked with countless home hobbyist growers as well as commercial growers, and it really is true that hobbyists tend to spray again and again for trivial reasons, and they are doing a disservice to their trees.

  • 20 years ago

    Malcolm, the ironic thing like is you recommend doing what I was doing until I started seeing problems. Up until 2 weeks ago and I got fed up with the decline with my 3 Citrus trees (shown in this thread My Once Beautiful Citrus Trees) I had never sprayed pesticide or fed fertilizer for years. If what you're saying is true my negligence of my trees should be thriving and healthy. Upon the initial pruning I noticed spider mites, leaf miner damage, ants, spiders, and now citrus black fly. By your own theory by my not spraying these pests are just part of an eco-system that will not harm my plants. I know enough about spider mites to know the predators that feed on them never quite keep them under control without any help either chemically or organically.

    If you've come up with a solution that requires no spaying, and will rid plants of pests or a way to live with the pests that won't harm the plants there is a whole array of growers out there that would love to hear this solution, especially rose growers.

  • 20 years ago

    Peppers, I understand both your and MM's logic. I think he assumed you had been using large and long usages of pesticides.
    Is this correct, Malcolm?
    In your case, since you recently started treating, I'd continue.
    I'm not one to debate w/MM's, he's 5 levels up from me when it comes to growing citrus, but I think it was a misunderstaning.
    That's one problems w/computers/forums.

    If it were my tree/s and all the bugs you mentioned, you bet your sweet bottom I'd use something to rid them, including daily spraying (water) on leaves.
    Apparently, your trees have blackfly. To be honest I never heard of them until MM's brought it to attention. Whitefly is bad enough, but now there's another to add. Sheesh.

    I can see by the pics you posted your trees are well cared for. Insects are inevitable. Especially in Fl..is that where you're located? Seems the further south a person goes, the more bugs hang around.

    So, which chemicals? are you using now? How often do you apply? Are you following container directions? Even though it's important you spray, please don't overdo it. Toni

  • 20 years ago

    Spider mites never damage citrus trees significantly in Florida. Yes you can find them, sometimes in large numbers. Their effect on production and fruit quality is nil. Always. Now, I never recommended not fertilizing. Unfertilized trees in Florida do NOT thrive for very long. Our soils are inherently lacking in several nutrients, especially N and K, and a good nutritional program is very important if you want your trees to thrive and produce.

    And yes, unsprayed citrus trees will always have lots of different pests in them. Just ignore them. I should say that this is not my personal theory; it is the result of nearly a century of research by USDA, UF, and other pest-oriented organizations dealing with Florida citrus. It is the standard, officially recommended method, and the method we've used on our college arboretum for at least 50 years. We grow beautiful citrus with no more than a bit of rust mite injury.

    Yes, we grow most of our roses without any sprays of any kind. We have selected for disease-resistant types, but insects and mites are simply not a problem, except for thrips in the spring, and we just live with them; the population soon crashes.

    I'm not an organic purist. I don't have anything against the use of the proper pesticide when it is merited. But on citrus trees in Florida, it is seldom merited.

  • 20 years ago

    Ok Malcon thanks for your thoughts and advice. SO by the pics in the other thread can you conclude the problem I was facing is just a lack of fertilizing feeding? Like hopefulauthor said I guess the worst thing now would be to overcompensate for my lack of care of these trees. What's a good feeding schedule this time of year ot should I just wait till the spring for the next? So far I have only sprayed Organicide (once) and Fish Emulsion (twice), and sprinkled citrus food (once) and watered with Miracid (once 1/4 strength). Thanks for your replies. I just want to see my trees survive.

  • 20 years ago

    No I can't be sure from the photos that nutrition is the only problem. The trees look very thin on leaves -- have they been pruned recently? Have you tested the soil for pH? Do you see any wilting of the leaves at times when the soil is moist? (I'm trying to rule out blight and/or tristeza here) Where in Fla. are you? (thinking of potential for freeze injury). How old are these trees?

    If they were in my yard, here's what I would do:
    1. I would not fertilize heavily just now. Probably what you've already done is ok. But I would get the soil tested for pH and correct that through the winter, if necessary. Try to get the soil into the pH 6.0-6.5 range. A bit lower is ok if the trees are on Swingle or another Poncirus hybrid rootstock (sprouts from ground level will have 3 leaflets rather than one)

    2. I would keep a large circle of soil bare around the base of the tree with no mulches or other additives of any kind. I would particularly avoid putting anything against the trunk.

    3. In mid-February, I'd apply a good citrus fertilizer, approximately equal amounts of N and K and less P (10-2-10 or similar) with micronutrients, at a pound per inch of trunk diameter or per foot of tree canopy diameter, whichever is greater.

    4. If greasy spot disease is s severe problem, I would spray once, around July 1, with a citrus-labeled oil spray; otherwise I would not do any spraying of pesticides. You should be able to see greasy spot on older leaves right now, if it's present -- looks like drops of used motor oil on the undersides of the leaves, with corresponding yellow-brown spots on the top sides. The symptoms develop this time of the year, but the only time it can be controlled is summer.

    5. If the soil is alkaline and I can't bring that down (sometimes a problem in extreme south Florida), I would consider a nutritional spray of the micronutrients in February.

    6. Your tangelo tree -- I have my doubts that that's what it is anymore. I think it likely died to below the graft union, and the tree that came up is now rootstock variety. Not sure from the pictures, but the leaves look very small to be tangelo. Is that possible? There appears to be a fruit on it -- is that fruit a tangelo?

    7. Thinking of more potential problems that could cause the symptoms being seen -- Do any of the leaves lave little semi-circular notches cut from the edges? (trying to rule out root weevil injury, the adults of which will notch the leaves). Are there any rotted lesions at the base of the trunk, where it enters the soil? (thinking of phytophthora foot rot)

  • 20 years ago

    Malcolm thanks for the detailed questions. You wrote:

    >>>>>No I can't be sure from the photos that nutrition is the only problem. The trees look very thin on leaves -- have they been pruned recently?The leaves pretty much dropped and the bud dropped over the summer as well. Wasn't pruned to look like that at all. I did prune excess dead limbs because the leaves disappearwed so it actually looked worse before I pruned.

    >>>>>How old are these trees?As far as the age of the trees the Tangelo and the middle grapefruit tree are oldest at least 20 years old. The Ruby Red is approx 17 years old.

    I'm in SW Florida, so no problem with freezing.

    To answer your numbered questions:

    2) Whats the best way to remove all the grass/weeds from under the drip line? Took me a while to get it back by hand, to the small area I laid down the mulch.

    3) The fertilizer I bought was a small bag of Vigoro Citrust/Avacado fertilizer 12-5-8. I used 1 cup sprinkled around the drip line. After walking off the square footage it is about 12x10 (120sq ft) The packaging states 5 1/2 cups for 100 sq ft, so you can see I always err on the side of caution. I was worried the measly 1 cup I sprinkled might be too strong and that was 2 weeks ago.

    4) Nothing that looks like greasy spot was identified on my trees.

    5) I haven't checked the PH but I will get that done soon.

    6) I think you may be correct. When the tree died the new sapling came up from the root area, so you are correct about it being below the graft. The fruits that grew last year didn't taste like a Tangelo, more like a bitter lemon. The few fruit on it now are pretty small the largest being not much larger than a golf ball.

    7) Havent seen any notches in the leaves so I doubt that is the problem. As for weevils though my potted hot pepper plants there was a problem with some kind of borer weevil that burrowed into the stems and fruit. Apparantly the only advice I recieved was to burn my plants as there is no control for them.

    No rotted lesions at the base of the tree either.

    -----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

    I will also add that I have never purposely irrigated the trees once they were established. Should I be watering these at least weekly? During this time there is not much rain but in years past it never seemed to need water other than the rain.

  • 20 years ago

    Were these trees damaged by a hurricane recently? Did your yard flood after a hurricane? Any salt intrusion then? Those are also possibilities for trees to look like yours do -- "thin". You're certainly not over-fertilizing!

    No, weekly watering is not necessary. If the trees actually wilt, you should deeply water them, but otherwise, established dooryard trees shouldn't need much supplemental water.

    We kill weeds and grass under our trees with Roundup. It's quite safe to use under a citrus tree as long as you don't get it misting up into the green parts of the tree.

    You are fortunate not to have greasy spot. It is nearly ubiquitous in Florida citrus trees, especially on grapefruit and limes.

  • 20 years ago

    Malcolm trees weren't damaged by the hurricanes' winds or flooding. Instead of Roundup I will spend a little time each day to hand till the area under the trees. Thanks.

  • 20 years ago

    hopefulauthor wrote: "Apparently, your trees have blackfly. ... Whitefly is bad enough, but now there's another to add."

    Citrus blackfly *is* a whitefly. See this page:
    http://creatures.ifas.ufl.edu/citrus/citrus_blackfly.htm

    Here is a link that might be useful: details about citrus blackfly

  • 20 years ago

    Thanks Jean..

  • 20 years ago

    I was looking at the link above, for blackfly from the UF/IFAS website, and from there, I linked to the home dooryard pest control site. EEK! That pamphlet, dated 1994, recommends spraying your trees with Benlate (no longer labeled for any use in Florida) and Ethion (a restricted-use insecticide, not for sale to the public in the last decade or so)! They really need to update their information. Also, I'm not sure where they got the dates of discovery of blackfly in the various counties, but we had them here in Lakeland (Polk County) before the outbreak in Manatee County. Fortunately for us, they arrived with the parasites close behind; Manatee County had an infamous outbreak in that they got blackflies without parasites for a few months. And without parasites they can be quite devastating. But once the State introduced parasites to the area, they were quickly brought under control. My pest management class finds blackfly on our campus every year, without fail. But in a collection of over 100 trees, with a dozen or so students scouting for them, we seldom find more than 3 or 4 infested leaves in an entire semester, and almost always, those leaves show at least some pupae with parasite exit holes. So the level of ongoing control is extraordinarily good.

  • 20 years ago

    Malcolm, 3 winters ago, I had a terrible whitefly infestation. I mean bad..I thought all my plants would die, that's how bad they were.
    Anyway, I never got the black stuff first..why is that? When I brought my plants in from the great outdoors, that's when I noticed the first whitefly (white not black) bugs on leaves..before I knew it almost all my plants had these terrible pests.
    This is what baffles me about blackfly/whitefly..Toni

  • 20 years ago

    Toni, I'm not sure I understand the question. There are 4 common whiteflies on Florida citrus (and likely many others in other parts of the world). Ours are:

    Citrus whitefly -- always pure white, no silky hairs on the leaf. Often seen in large colonies which fly in a cloud if disturbed

    Cloudy-wing whitefly -- like cwf, but with a darker, grey spot on each wing. Also no sily hairs on the leaf

    Wooly whitefly -- bigger than the others, pure white, almost always seen individually, on the underside of grapefruit leaves, in a mass of silky hairs they've secreted onto the leaf. reluctant to fly.

    Citrus blackfly -- the only one with black crawlers and pupae, matures into a deep blue adult. It is a "whitefly" in the biological sense, but no stage is ever white. Back in the '70s, before the parasites, these could build up large adult populations on the tree, but since then, I have seldom seen an adult; most of what is seen are the eggs, crawlers, and pupae, generally with parasite exit holes.

    I think your trees had one of the other species (maybe none of these, since you're not in Florida), and so black crawlers and pupae would not be expected. Am I missing something in the question?

    Malcolm

Sponsored
Snider & Metcalf Interior Design, LTD
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars25 Reviews
Leading Interior Designers in Columbus, Ohio & Ponte Vedra, Florida