Software
Houzz Logo Print
madeyna

whats a good conifer soil

15 years ago

I have clay but not heavy clay in my new conifer bed. Its on a slight slope, and I live in the northwest. I have already tilled it several times can I just go ahead and plant it out next spring or should I add sand and manure then till again. I have horses so manure is really easy to come by. The sand I have to drive an hour to get but will do so if its really needed. What I would really like to hear is go ahead multch it and plant it out in the sping. For multch what would be better cedar bark or fir bark?

Comments (12)

  • 15 years ago

    Really guessing, but this sounds like a typical situation where the contractor moved the topsoil and left you with the clay subsoil, really not great in which to grow stuff. If you have horses, you should have sufficient cheap material to amend it to where it will decently support your conifers.

    I'd also check with your local Master Gardeners; you can reach them through the local cooperative extension office. (I'm paid to say that.)

  • 15 years ago

    "whats a good conifer soil".

    Whatever you have that is there naturally. That is where all the roots will end up in several years. You can amend all you want to but the roots won't say around long enough to justify the money spent on it. Forget the sand and save the money for another conifer purchase. Plant when leaves fall and don't amend anything. By planting now your plants will be settled in, acclimated, and ready for spring.

    Fir bark will provide that "finished" look, retain moisture and help with weed control. Does contain slivers but a less expensive alternative to some other ground cover products.

    Cedar Bark: Larger than the Fir Walk-on Bark and more red in color. Helps retain moisture and control erosion on sloped area. Economical ground cover for large areas.

    The choice is yours. Google it.

    Dave

  • 15 years ago

    Thanks for the info. I was planning on planting in the spring because I have already tilled the soil in the bed several times and its really soft and fluffy right now. We live on a hill overlooking the Columbia river so really high winds are the norm around here. I am afraid anything planted in that soft soil will just fall over if done right before our heavy long long long rainy season hits and turns it into soupy mud. Usually when I till something the soil takes few months to settle back down. We only got about two weeks of summer this year so the soil is still damp underneath. The great thing about the northwest though is conifers are everywhere.

  • 15 years ago

    IMHO.. conifers.. and trees .. NEVER NEED FERTILIZER.. and that is what manure is ... unless well rotted and can be considered only compost ... and even that we dont really recommend ..

    plant in native soil.. unless a soil test indicates something is missing from your soil ... and then only add such.. no guessing here ... and as i recall vast swathes of the PNW are covered in conifers.. so my guts tell me .. but for the clay.. you probably do not need anything.. but the local extension office might answer that generally .. very quickly ...

    never amend a planting hole ONLY .... and that is different than what you are doing to the whole bed .... but if your plant reaches below the fluffy stuff.. do not amend that bottom of the hole ...

    what is the source of your plants.. do you plan on bare rooting and untangling the roots??? if so.. then TIMING IS EVERYTHING ... it must be done when the plant is dormant.. and i do not know when that is for your zone.. perhaps firefighter will can chime in ...

    i am concerned that you are preparing a bed for perennials.. and annuals.. instead of thinking about all the other variables requisite in the planting of a tree/conifer ...

    the absolutely most important thing about soil and trees/conifers ... especially clay .. is drainage .... many peeps in heavy clay.. actually plant half of the root mass above ground level .... creating a berm of sorts with high draining soil ... thereby creating the requisite drainage.. until the conifer can put its roots where it wants .... if you drown it.. before it grows up.. you will lose ...

    i think we need a more generalized overview of the whole conifer side of the project.. to give you truly useful guidance ...

    good luck

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    Do NOT add sand. You will only make it worse. Since you have "clay but not heavy clay" you should be fine, especially being on a slope. Composted manure certainly will not hurt anything at anytime, even as a top dressing later and adding fresh now should be ok by spring.

    tj

  • 15 years ago

    Ken and Dave nailed it pretty well here in my novice opinion. First, I have found that with regular watering, the only way you can kill a conifer in the PNW is if it is in REALLY bad clay. Make a hole, fill it to the brim with water. If it takes more then 15-20 minutes to drain, you may have problems. If it takes an hour or two, don't plant any conifers there. For your plant timing, I'd say now would be OK if you were planting small conifers. Big ones with small root systems, ie. your typical nursery plant, would be troublesome if it's as windy as you say. If it's not too windy, give them the Winter to root in - they will grow all Winter(the roots I mean) and this will help them start off next year.

    If you're really concerned about wind, that's fine, I'd plant next March or early April.

    Washington has a HUGE variance in zones, everything from Winter lows of -20 to Winter lows of 45, depending on where you live/how high up.

    I can plant year round in my climate, and ir sounds like pasadena is in an area with similar temps.

  • 15 years ago

    How about soil for a potted Conifer? I just got a little Monkey Puzzle.

    More gritty soil like a Bonsai? Larger pieces of shredded wood mixed with peat?

    The biggest thing I've learned about bagged potting soil is that most people say it is horrible and lousy for potted long term plants.

  • 15 years ago

    Josh (greenman28) gave a good lesson on container soils at the link.

    tj

    Here is a link that might be useful: Near the Bottom

  • 15 years ago

    I do have areas where the clay is heavy enough that a hole filled with water doesn,t drain for weeks but this area was chosen for the soil. The bed is only a few hundred feet long by ten too twenty feet wide and I don,t want to create a ton of shade ( I already have a acre of dense old growth) so I am limited on what I can put in. I have been driving around looking at conifers in town and lurking on here. I am on the Washington side of the Columbia river about 40 miles from Portland right on a hill overlooking the river towards the coast.

  • 15 years ago

    What are you looking to plant in the prepared area?

    Species or dwarf cultivars. 1-2 ft. specimens or something larger?

    Dave

  • 15 years ago

    I know NW soils somewhat and all those great conifers have their roots in the topsoil over a clay subsoil. Where the topsoil has been removed, growth is poor. I wasn't recommending the manure for nutrients, horse manure is not that great a source, too much carbon that needs breaking down, but does contribute structurally so that the trees have something to grow in. However, I would recommend that you get a local opinion from your county extension service; they should know best.

  • 15 years ago

    I talked to the local nursery today and they told me to just plant it out. If I soften the soil on the top foot or so it will only encourage the roots to branch out rather than down. They also told me to avoid planting in the heavier clay areas. I do have one heavy clay area at the end of the bed I will plant out but I think it will be minatures and I will more or less drie well under each plant by digging a deep hole(4 feet) with a post hole digger and filling halfway with rocks. I have had to do that for thuga emerald breed arborvitae in the past and it works well. I want the bed to house other plants as well. The upper 100 or so feet already has medium sized fur trees my husband limbed up 12 feet, I will be planting hydrangeas under there and the middle part that has the most slope I amended with cedar sawdust and sand and that will have a few small conifers for structure then the rest will be planted out in iris and roses. The next couple of hundred feet of the bed was going to be all conifers with the exception of one contorted filbert but I have been looking at alot of conifer gardens and I like the look of using conifers for structure and then lightly planting out with other plants for seasonal color. So I don,t know whats going to go in with the conifers yet but something will. Looking around here I have at least a few conifers in all my flower beds but this bed will be more or less devoted to them. I want so tall narrow funky shaped ones. I am going to town soon and I will take a picture of a conifer garden I really enjoy. Its a very long bed that follows our driveway up , its a total of 500 feet give or take a little. I think the pasture fence on that side was 700 feet when we fenced it but I,m not doing it that far.