Software
Houzz Logo Print
laurie_edm

Self Seeders in Zone 3

20 years ago

I am looking for some of the experienced advice I've been reading in this forum. This is my second season in Zone 3, with a south facing back yard & tons of enriched soil. I've never had it so good! However, my lack of experience in such a warm zone has brought many surpises. Last year's bachelor buttons, amaranthys (love-lies-bleeding) & comsos self-seeded like crazy. Also malva sylvestris, which I previously grew as an annual, & a Z5 dark purple mallow or malva. I'm not sure if this was due to the extremely mild winter we had or if there are more annuals I need to beware of. (Crazy Gardner - thanks - I've clipped a list you made in another conversation)

Comments (12)

  • 20 years ago

    Calendula, Johny-jump ups, pansy, Chamomile, borage, allysum, sweet william.

    Perennials that self-seed. purple coneflower, shastas, rudbeckia, golden margarites, lupines and delphs.

    I'm sure others can add to this list.

    Happy Gardening,
    Sierra

  • 20 years ago

    Other perennials besides the ones listed already that self seed in my garden...blue fescue, pinks, heliopsis (both regular and loraine sunshine), salvias, some lilies (the ones with bulbets), cranesbills, Jacob's Ladder and some yarrow (especially the pastel mixture).

    Trees that self seed...elm and maple.

    Shrubs that self seed...cotoneaster and spirea.

    These are another few for your list you are making.

    Brenda

  • 20 years ago

    The perennial bachelor's button (Centaurea montana) will take over your garden if you let it. Along with: Globe Thistle (Echinopsis) and Sea Holly (Erignium planum).

    Forget-me-nots and poppies, of course.

    Malva moschata (Musk mallow)!!! (Even seeding in my lawn!!)

    Dandelions. :-) (Just had to add that one.)

    Columbines will pop up everywhere, but they're always welcome in my garden.

    Achilliea erythropoda (a very small lady's mantle. I've never had the large one self-seed, but I may be cutting off the flowers before that happens.)

    Clematis--especially alpina and integrifolia.

    Veronica--not sure of the variety--maybe spicata. My neighbours across the street planted it--now, it's all over my garden, front and back yards. That's OK, because I love it.

    Digtalis grandiflora (yellow, perennial foxglove).

    Hmmmm. I'm sure there's more that others will add.

    Doris

  • 20 years ago

    Some more annuals: Marigolds, Love-in-a-Mist (Nigella), Nicotiana (especially the large white ones), Morning Glories (some types more than others), Dill (not that it's a garden flower but the warning is warranted).

    Perennials & shrubs: Columbine, Hollyhocks, Nanking Cherry

    Welcome to the Far North forum, glad to have you here :0)

    -Gillian

  • 20 years ago

    I've got a few to add that have self seeded this year for me in my Edm. garden.

    Schizanthus
    Helichrysum - straw flower
    Gaillardia 'grandiflora'
    Hesperis matronalis - Sweet Rocket, Dame's Rocket
    Layia platyglossa - Tidy Tips
    Portulaca - not alot but some

    There's probably more, but I either can't remember or I pulled them as I saw them for control.

    Welcome to FN, Laurie.

    Shauna

  • 20 years ago

    Just wanted to say hi and welcome to our Far North forum, hope you'll enjoy it here!

    Sharon

  • 20 years ago

    Thank-you everyone. I will be much more careful in my planning & purchasing. Gone are the days when an annual was an annual & most perennials were too, lol.

  • 20 years ago

    Hi & Welcome to the Far North forum!

    Here's a few more that I noticed in my garden:

    Asters
    Nemophila 'Baby Blue Eyes' - I'm assuming 'Penny Black' will too.
    Sunflowers

    Ang

  • 20 years ago

    I know you've had trouble with self-seeding, but the majority of those mentioned I would not actually go out of my way to avoid.

    I avoid plants that are invasive via roots, but self-seeders I just pull out if I don't want them all. The only one that has ever really annoyed me is morning glories.

    Just a thought.

  • 20 years ago

    Welcome..I dont think I can add any more to the list except for the lowly viola and pansy..savona

  • 20 years ago

    I have to agree wholeheartedly with Gil (northspruce) about leaving the self seeding. I pull where I don't want them, too. But this year, I have an area that is almost self-seeded and it looks really nice and natural with one type plant between another between another. I couldn't get those combinations that way, if I tried.

    Shauna

  • 20 years ago

    It's not that I want to avoid self seeders completely but I've got some huge problems right now. The back 1/2 of the yard was previously vegetables. I planted it last year with a few perennials & lots of annuals to fill in, leaving pathways etc. If I wasn't constantly pulling, hoeing & spraying this year the entire area would have been over run & the plants I chose this year wouldn't have light to grow. & I am absolutely sure I didn't plant that snapdragon I just noticed blooming under the apple tree.

Sponsored
Peabody Landscape Group
Average rating: 3.5 out of 5 stars8 Reviews
Columbus' Reliable Landscape Design & Contracting