Software
Houzz Logo Print
melandgav

Should all hardwood floors in a house match?

14 years ago
We are planning to replace all the carpeting on the second floor of our home (three bedrooms and hallway) with hardwood. The main floor of the house already has oak flooring throughout, in a golden colour (installed by the previous owners when they built the house about 12 years ago). My question is: should the hardwood we choose for the second floor "match" the main level in terms of species and colour or can we go with something different? We will be keeping carpet on the stairs (we have two small boys) and the banister and spindles are oak like the main floor. The way our stairs are configured, you do not see the second floor landing/hallway when standing at the bottom of the stairs. Also, the only place where the new floor will butt up against the existing railing/ spindles is in about a 3-4 foot section on the second floor overlooking the staircase.

We are liking maple flooring in cinnamon and butterscotch shades.

Comments (33)

  • 14 years ago
    HI -- I don't think it has to , but I think it may look better. Ask some carpet stores or installers if they have done anything like this and get their take on it. I think if the two floors are not too far removed from each other in color, it will be fine.
  • 14 years ago
    yes useing two different hardwood floors is fine. You can even use different woods like a light maple floor with a mid to dark cherry wood floor.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    It will be fine to mix hardwood flooring in the situation you describe.
  • 14 years ago
    Thanks for your post, melandgav. We have the same dilemma, but trickier because the transition is from the formal front of the house and staircase to the casual back of the house. We are having our staicase rebuilt in oak and my husband is determined to have the original floors in the formals refinished, so we will be selecting stain soon...
  • 13 years ago
    Do my wood floors on my main level have to be the same color as my staircase ( which has a runner on it)?
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    If it has a runner, that usually means that the outside edges of the wood steps are not covered and are therefore visible. It will look better if the floors on the main level are very close in color to that of the stairs. What change did you have in mind?
    Carolyn Albert-Kincl, ASID
  • 13 years ago
    Going from an a clear finish to a very dark finish-FYI bannister ( huge bridal staircase) is very dark with a dark pineapple finial at base
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    If the banister is dark then it seems to me that your dark floor would work. But be aware that a dark floor is a pain to take care of because i shows every little thing!
  • 13 years ago
    My franch house has honey colored wood floors. My kitchen is laminate and I want to replace with wood floors. It appears I have hardwood in kitchen but laminate is glued onto it and they are afraid of asbestos. They want to lay ontop of current laminate. Should I invest into seeing if I can save original wood floors (two have said they wont be nice) or go with a darker wood slightly distressed barnwood look. Everyone keeps saying if you try to match and its off it is worse that making a statement of the kitchen being its own room with the darker floors. HELP!
  • PRO
    13 years ago
    @paula, it would be good if you could pose this question as a separate design dilemma as answers on this one should be related to the original question. We'd love to help you!
  • 13 years ago
    We just did the same thing. Our home built in 1948 has the narrow red oak plank flooring. We refinished it in natural. We added a second story addition that is dedicated two our two kids. We chose 3.5 inch hickory in a mid tone color. It was pre finished. The cost of doing the second floor in the old fashion narrow plank was to costly and we thought the hickory would hide any blemishes it might get as our kids grow.
  • 13 years ago
    Hi Hparks74 - do you have pics of the contrast between two floors. We too have narrow oak plank flooring throughout our 1800 square foot beach house which has been refinished in natural, but want to do all of the three bedrooms in different Cali Bamboo flooring with a different color, but our oak flooring does go up the stairs to the landing adjoining the bedrooms. I still think it would look good, and want something with less work to install and tougher wood that hides blemishes. Just not sure how it would look.
  • 12 years ago
    Hello, we have the same delemia. Our first floor has dark hard wood floors and we are planning to remove the carpet on the second floor and on the stairs. We are planning to have a washed out gray color wood flooring on the second floor but not sure what color we should use for the stairs since it transitions between both dark and light color floors. Please help!
  • 12 years ago
    Need to replace oak flooring in foyer. I have been advised to go darker. However, the beginning of the staircase to the second floor has a different stain-darker than the current oak floor. Carpet runner. Can I go a bit darker on the floor? The wood doesn't meet directly.
  • 11 years ago

    Hi, does anyone on the thread have some updates or photos? I am facing a similar dilemma thanks!


  • 10 years ago

    im wanting to pull my carpet up and leave the rest on my stairs my question is can I use different wood floors if my dining room and living room space the dining room has narrow hardwood and a light color I want to go with a wider hardwood and darker wood will that match

  • 10 years ago

    I have a similar question. I need to change the 1960 strip oak flooring in my bedrooms but I am not ready to change the upstairs hallway and stairs yet (currently carpeted) That is for a future downstairs project. Does the flooring in my bedrooms have to match the hallway?

  • 10 years ago
    I have light hardwood floors thru my house, my wife wants to put hardwood floors in the 3 bedrooms on the same floor should we. Help
  • 10 years ago

    I think you guys need to start your own questions rather than attaching them to this older thread...

  • 10 years ago
    I am currently selecting flooring for my new home through a builder and have a huge dilemma. We like the hickory floors that we have found however our stairs are red oak and are straight in the middle of the house and the banister on the upstairs and main floor are long and span the length of the house meaning you will see where the floor meets the pickets. I know they said they will try to match the color but having the floors bump up to the stairs and along the span of hallway I am concerned as red oak is pinkish and hickory being a whiter wood. Has anyone seen anything like this what should I do.. There was an oak flooring but it was the new modern grey and we didn't like it, any help would be great
  • PRO
    10 years ago
    I think you can get away with diff woods if you solved the transition..
  • 9 years ago

    I have 3 bedrooms and a hallway upstairs. We put different colors and also different finished in each bedroom. Our bedroom we have a shiny finish and I did not want that finish in the bedroom that our grandchildren used.

  • 9 years ago

    I have a 2 story house and some people say the kitchen color wood has to blend with wood floors on the stairs and upstairs or it has to flow. My kitchen will not be in sight near my stairs. Also i am going with a lighter wood floor and my furniture is on the lighter side. Can i blend in with an area rug?

  • 9 years ago

    The wood is like a taupe color. Is that a fad?


  • 9 years ago

    I have cream color tile with light browns and light, light grey color through out my home. would you place any colors of wood tile in each bedrooms. their all separated from one another except two are side by side, exiting into the cream tile.The cream tile measures 12x12. My master bed exit into my living room.

  • 8 years ago

    Hello! I have a similar dilemma. I have attached some photos. I am refinishing and can stain all the floors downstairs to the darker picture shown in two stains photos. Only issue is upstairs is a lighter wood color. The banister is where I wonder if it would matter if I go with the darker stain and the stairs because that would stay as is. The color upstairs is similar to the photo of the kitchen. Would love any thoughts or opinions. Is it okay to have two different colors in main floor vs upper floor? The bottom photos are from real estate listing so furniture would be different.

  • 8 years ago

    I just re-did my dining room floor to a medium dark wood see picture below. The opening of the dinning room faces the banister going upstairs see second picture. I want to redo my banister, stair and all the rooms upstairs to a very light color wood (white/beige). Can I do the light stain or do I have to keep it all dark?


  • 6 years ago

    I have dark hardwood floors and same colour stairs going upstairs which matches to landing area. Rooms have carpet and I want change to hardwood. We were thinking to install light colour hardwood in rooms so rooms would look bright and bigger. Friends and family including contractors suggesting to match hardwood with downstairs because upper floor landing has same hardwood. Reasons are given resale value and people would Not like different Colour hardwood fLoot considering the fact landing area doesnt match

  • 6 years ago

    I do prefer when wood floors match throughout a house, even when they may not be continually connected. When I do not see this, I feel like the house is somehow disjointed. Funny thing is that other than that and same type of interior doors and door knobs everywhere, I like everything else to be somewhat unique.

  • 6 years ago

    I have hardwoods in every room. They all match. If someone wants to use a different species upstairs, then the stair treads, risers, railings, balusters, can be the integrating factors that help join two different types of flooring. I've posted an example.


  • 5 years ago
    last modified: 5 years ago

    Someone please help! Carpet was stripped, 4 bedrooms/hallway on third level laminated in grey. I have no idea what to do with stairs,

    and carpet is not an option.


  • 5 years ago

    Maybe do grey stain and black stain