Software
Houzz Logo Print
treebarb

Living Christmas trees

16 years ago

Happy Thanksgiving all!

I got an email from my favorite local nursery. They'll have living Christmas trees in stock next week. I haven't had a live tree in years and never had any luck planting them after the holidays. If I buy one, I wouldn't bring it in the house, I'd dig the hole, set the pot in it and leave it till spring for planting.

I'm interested in your thoughts on live Christmas trees. Are they more expensive around the holidays than they would be in the spring? Is it worth buying a tree you won't be planting for 5 months? I'm about 30 minutes north of Denver. My soil is 7.9 ph, clay loam, low in nitrogen and phosporus, low SAR. The planting site would be north east of the house, morning sun with afternoon shade. I'm at 5300 ft elevation. I have 4 Austrian pines that are doing well here. I planted a windbreak with 30 Rocky Mountain Juniper seedlings in the spring and they have all survived so far. I must confess I killed 5 Colorado Blue spruce about 5 years ago. It was early in my tree planting years, I amended the heck out of the soil and didn't dig wide enough holes. I've learned a bit since then but am leery of trying CBS again. I'm leaning towards planting a Douglas fir, White fir or a Scotch pine. Do you think I'd be better off waiting till spring to buy and plant a smaller tree?

Have a great holiday and thanks for your input!

Barb

Comments (14)

  • 16 years ago

    i dont understand barb???

    why buy a LIVE XMAS TREE ... on the supposition that you are NOT going to bring it in the house ... and it otherwise being TOTALLY out of tree planting season????

    if you are just going to plant it in the yard.. i would tend to suggest you just buy it a proper planting time in spring ....

    happy holidays

    ken

    PS: yeah... yeah... yeah.. i know she might be able to GET AWAY WITH IT .... but why risk it????

  • 16 years ago

    Barb, buying the tree now for the sake of wanting to have it to decorate in your yard says one thing about how much risk you might be willing to take. But if you're really more just after the tree for the yard and you don't really care if it is there to decorate for this season, I'd wait for two reasons......

    1) In your area the ground does come to a hard freeze so you really have pushed the planting season too far for the roots to get a chance to settle in.

    2) You cannot trust the condition of the tree near as much as you can at the local nursery at other times of the year. More often than not, Christmas trees ( live or cut ) have not been cared for as well - or at least you don't know if they have. You don't know how long they've been packed and loaded awaiting the proper seasonal shipping time.

    Just my 2 cents

    mark

  • 16 years ago

    I was thinking of buying a living C-tree this year too. Have not done so before because really, I'd not have had any good place to plant it later. Now I do. My intentions would be to bring it inside for a spell. Reading on another GW forum, opinions seemed to run that 5 days to a week was about the longest one could expect to be able to have it indoors and still be viable for planting.

    If I do this, it will be a fir of some type.

    Wondering if any of you guys have experience in this and opinions thereof. And this brings up another question: A potted conifer in the nursery, unsold, will be outdoors over winter. Most likely, healed in in chips or the like. How is it more stressful for this same plant to be placed into soil over winter, albeit, very late. We've not experienced much cold yet, though that will change to some degree soon. There is no frost in the ground yet, including up north where the plant would be going.

    I can partially answer my own question to say that, if upon de-potting the plant, the usual circling and girdling roots are found, I can see why attempting to remedy this so late would be bad. I planted some very nice looking Abies nordmanniana late last fall which needed root work. They did not do well. But for the sake of this discussion, let's say that the roots are okay and need no adjustment. How is this any more stressful than what the plant was going to experience anyway? And again, thoughts generally on the whole "living Christmas tree" thing.

    +oM

  • 16 years ago

    i did it years ago ...

    forced air furnace was the biggest issue ... lack of humidity .... closed off all doors.. so the room stayed around 50 ..... spritzed them every day .... was working full time .... so the house wasnt all that warm much of the day ...

    pre-dug hole.. filled with bags of leaves... in case the ground was frozen when i went to plant ... had the soil in a wheelbarrow in the heated garage ....

    used mini lights.. and only had them on for xmas day ....

    took them outside .... tempered it for a few days ....threw in hole.. threw in soil ... threw leaves on top ... moved to perm position in spring .... they were ball and burlap.. which i stuck in pots ....

    my biggest fear was ruining the carpet and the wood floors under ...

    they did just fine

    heat and humidity are the variables that need to be addressed ....

    ken

  • 16 years ago

    Thnx Ken. I'ma going out in a bit to see what, if anything, is available at this time. Going to concentrate on Abies balsamea or fraseri

    +oM

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the input! I have a fake tree for the house that I'm putting up this weekend. I like a tree in the living room for a good long time and I knew a live tree wouldn't take that. It is probably too late to plant here, spring would be better. I was just curious as to what luck any of you might have had with the live ones, outside. Have a great holiday!
    Barb

  • 16 years ago

    i live in the boston area. last year 9 days before x-mas i bought a 4-5 ft canaan fir for 30 bucks, watered it, left it on outdoor patio for 7 days, brought it inside, decorated with lights for only 3 days to minimize risk of coming out of dormancy, then planted outside in pre-dug hole filled with leaves approx. 2x the root ball diameter. i put a little milorganite (2 handfuls) in hole and copper fungicide around root ball prior to planting on 12/26 (area tends to get wet, especially during spring thaw (why i chose canaan over douglas or balsam - better wet soil tolerance). this spring the buds grew, tree grew 6-8 inches in partial sun, now has buds throughout and will hopefully make it throught 2nd winter. i may repeat this year with another canaan.

  • 16 years ago

    Sounds nice, JK. Canaan=balsamea x fraseri, no? I'm finding it difficult to source living x-mas trees here. Must have fallen off in popularity.

    I'm surprised that Canaan fir, or any fir really, would exhibit greater tolerance to wet soils than balsam. The latter will often be found in swamps here, as well as drier sites.

    +oM

  • 16 years ago

    Canaan fir = Abies balsamea var. phaerolepis. Took the time to look this up the other day since we are selling them as cut trees for the first time this season :-)

    As to the living trees, we sold a great many of them at a former nursery - perhaps half as many as the cut varieties. One of the reasons they were so popular is that they were accepted back at the nursery after Christmas for a planting project that was charged with reforesting local salmon streams (all native species). Despite a January planting date, less than ideal planting conditions as well as some pretty amatuer planting help, the bulk of these trees survive. It's going to depend on the source and their supplier, but a live Xmas tree should not be in any different shape than one you would purchase in season to plant in your landscape. How successfully they will transition from a very temporary indoor setting to the outdoors is going to be heavily dependant on how long they are inside, the treatment they receive inside and how easy it is to get them climatized and replanted outside. I'd think this would be much easier accomplished in areas where the ground does not freeze and planting can take place at any time.

  • 16 years ago

    Thnx GG. I'm seeing that now, that what I really should have done is found an acceptable potted or B&B fir back a month or two ago and just used it for this purpose. On the other hand, there may be some suitable trees showing up at various types of stores as we get more into the holiday season.

    Also somewhat problematic is that firs are not nearly as common as spruce species at garden centers generally. I don't know that I've ever seen balsamea or the like being offered as a landscape plant.

    Anyway, just a thought. If it doesn't happen, that's okay.

    +oM

  • 16 years ago

    I put 4 live blue spruce out for Christmas, decorated them with lights in my entry way ... then moved them into my garden (raised beds) and covered them with mulch and watered them. Then planted them in early Spring ... and they erupted with growth and are all doing great in my backyard.

  • 16 years ago

    Noticed Home Depot had little Italian Stone Pine living Christmas trees for sale down here. That is one of the few conifers that might live in this area's temperatures, rainfall, and soil pH. Never see them for sale any other time other than Christmas, so down here if you want one, get it while you can.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for sharing your experiences. Bunkers, did you leave the pots above ground in your raised beds or dig holes for them? The new trend in nurseries seems to be putting a pot in the ground, then putting the potted tree in the pot in the ground. Wisconsitom, I have the same question as to how doing this at your home would differ from the care the tree would get at a nursery over winter. I have a juniper bonsai and the the folks on the Bonsai forum recommended I bury my bonsai, pot and all for the winter. What would the negatives be in trying this?
    Scotjute, I did see the trees at HD, too. The Colorado stores have Austrian Pines, Fat Albert and Bacheri Spruce. They are pretty trees.

  • 16 years ago

    I have an Italian stone pine Christmas tree that I got in 1989-90. It has been transplanted into new pots three times over the years. It is now about three ft. tall not including the pot. I keep it short by pruning and thinning it periodically. (Bonsai is one of my hobbies.) I bring it in and decorate it about a week before Christmas. I have a bunch of small ornaments and small lights that I put on it. I love it and cannot imagine Christmas without it. I estimate that it has saved me about a thousand dollars over the years in the cut trees I did not buy.