Software
Houzz Logo Print
contrary_grow

Soil requirements confuse me

18 years ago

As I'm reading The Well Tended Perennial Garden and other resources, I see references to rich soil, soil high in organic content, lean soil, fertile soil, etc. I don't know what lean soil is and is rich soil the same as fertile soil? Also, since every plant seems to have different requirements, how in the world can you ever fill a bed? How important is it to pay attention to these kinds of requirements? Isn't it more important to provide well-draining soil for all plants? Sorry for all the questions, but my head is whirling.

Thanks for any help you can give me,

Mary

Comments (8)

  • 18 years ago

    I know what you mean Mary as I am in the same predicament. All I can tell you is that most perennials require a good draining soil that has a good supply of nutrients available for the plant. There are different ways of saying the same thing and that is VERY confusing to us "newbies".

    What I am doing is choosing the plants that have similar requirements for each of my beds and amending the soil to meet those requirements. I am starting from scratch with rather poor soil (ie: very little nutrient value available for plants and compacted as well from years of lack of care) so I am going to be tilling all the grass under and then cleaning out the roots and anything else I don't want growing back as much as I can, then I will be getting some "garden soil" delivered. Which for me, is a half and half mixture of top soil and mushroom soil. I am still going to be adding some composted manure to the mix as well even though I've been told I don't need to. Then, once I get all that done and planted I will be mulching with some aged horse manure that I can get for free from the stable around the corner.

    Sorry for such a long post.... just don't worry so much about it as I'm sure you will do just fine.

    ttfn
    Mystic.

  • 18 years ago

    Lean soil = grows a few spindly weeds
    Fertile soil = weeds grow well
    Rich Soil = weeds are head high
    Soil high in organic content = contains mulch and weeds grow head high. Soil looks like rich chocolate cake.

    That's how I determine.

    Nell

  • 18 years ago

    Hi Mary, You are in my zone. I'm in northeast Mississippi. What general area are you in? My interpretation, after about 25 yrs of gardening, is that rich = fertile = high in organic content. And poor = lean soil. Most plants benefit from a high organic matter content, meaning lots of compost, plant-based mulch (not rocks), and most plants like good drainage. Organic material helps drainage and fertility and helps most plants thrive. The exception would be some herbs and wildflowers that like dry lean soil, and some desert plants that might like rocks and alot of sand, and some bog-type plants that might like wet conditions.
    I've never done it, but it can be very helpful to get a soil test and then you will know the type soil (clay, sand predominates) and the organic matter percent, pH, and minerals etc. Then you can amend the soil (add things to it and incorporate it in) more scientifically. Many of us just keep adding organic mulches and organic matter aka compost and don't really need to know the exact composition of the original soil because it just gets better and better every year with the compost. If you choose to do a soil test, get in touch with your county agent or master gardener group (usually assoc. with the county agent or agricultural extension agent - found in phone book) and they can interpret the results as well. You will be pretty well informed at that point and have some good contacts that I'm sure you will use again and again to pick their brains. Most soil tests are inexpensive like 6 dollars or so. My understanding is that store-bought test kits are not as accurate. Hope this helps you some. Happy gardening. Laurie

  • 18 years ago

    LOL, Nell. Mary, I have that book and read from it for reference. I haven't read the whole thing from cover to cover, but have started to in the past, and plan to pick it up again when I get the chance. I like how she describes ways of cutting back and deadheading different plants.

    As far as soil goes, I just do my best applying compost, and I put Canadian spaghnum (sp) moss into new beds to help with drainage. I don't know if that's what your soil needs. I think ours is pretty good here, but on the clayey side. I know I mix plants with somewhat different requirements, and usually have success. Plants have different ranges of what they can tolerate as far as ph and amount of water. Look at the tags to see how much water they need. That's what I need to pay attention to so the ones that need it will get enough water.

    If you find plants sold for your zone that you like, plant them and see how they do.

    I hope that was helpful,
    Sue

  • 18 years ago

    Oh, so that's how you tell, Nell. I'm pretty sure I have all kinds then.

    Laurie, I'm also in Mississippi - in Florence just south of Jackson. I have clay soil which definitely needs to be amended in order to grow anything (other than spindly weeds).

    I have been adding compost to my beds as well as a bedding mixture that I buy at a local nursery. I guess I'll just quit worrying about what the requirements are for each individual plant - I suspect more plants like organic soil than not.

    Thanks for the help and reassurance, everyone.

  • 18 years ago

    I also have clay soils and need lean soil for many native wildflowers. I just do not add much in the way of nitrogen for these plants. Here we get some free county compost and that is a great ammendment for these plants. It has so much wood in it, that it breaks down the nitrogen it had. Pine bark soil ammender is another great thing to add, which is acidifying so if the plant does not grow well in "pine scrub" (which some natives do, especially in Missisippi)then I throw in a scant handful of lime. My goal is well draining, just not nutritious because our red clay here is plenty food enough.

    My friend Nita owns a nursery near Jackson!

    GGG

  • 18 years ago

    I have two types of soil on my property. There are sandy areas and areas with red adobe clay. I only add peat moss, also known as Sphagnum moss, to the sandy soil. I want to improve water retention in the sandy areas. Peat moss added to clay soil can cause too much water retention (poor drainage), which can essentially drown a plant or create root rot.

    There is big controversy over the use of peat. Some folks claim peat is a non-renewable resource, and that mining peat puts too much carbon dioxide into the atmosphere. I believe the Canadian peat industry is being managed in sustainable fashion. I support the Canadian peat industry.

    Glynis is correct in saying that clay soil has plenty food enough, because clay is rich in mineral nutrients. There are compost amendments specifically for breaking up clay soil, so that it isn't too hard.

    Nell's description of various soil types is humorous and spot on. If weeds grow well, so will most of the desired plants. There are plants which prefer lean soil, which do not require fertilization more than once a year. Russian sage is one such plant.

    Soil is a living ecosystem. Many chemical fertilizers and pesticides kill the ecosystem. Miracle Gro will give some nutrients to a plant, but it does nothing for the ecosystem of soil. Organic gardening means the gardener is working with the ecosystem to enhance it. Fertile soil grows healthy plants, which are less susceptible to disease and insect pests.

    I have various gardens because I batch plants which have different needs. The plants which prefer lean soil go in some areas. The plants requiring fertile soil go in other beds.

    I create fertile soil by adding compost, manure, and using organic fertilizers such as seaweed and kelp based products which will enhance the soil. Earth Juice is my favorite all round fertilizer. It contains: bat manure, kelp, potash, feather meal, blood meal, oat bran, and steamed bone meal. You are wondering about the oat bran? Some grains are beneficial to soil building.

    Lorna

  • 18 years ago

    Too funny, Nell. lol!

    Knowing your soil type is the first requirement. If you have lots of property like some of us then tests in several locations you wish to garden in will be needed. After you know your soil type and needs you can then proceed to amend it, if necessary. I say if necessary because many gardeners add copious amounts of amendments without ever knowing if they are actually needed and are surprised to learn much of what they are adding is not necessary.

    So find out what your soil needs, then add to it, if necessary. I don't think compost ever hurts except for some very lean loving plants. But too much nitrogen is not a good thing and can lead to all sorts of pest problem not to mention blooming problems, especially on roses.

    Diana

Sponsored