Software
Houzz Logo Print
ken_adrian

Abies n. 'Golden Spreader'

ok.. fess up..

how many of you have coveted it...

and how many have you killed trying to grow it..

and what is your zone..

i have lost two... in z5 .. AND WILL NOT TRY AGAIN .... and i wish i hadnt wasted the money on the second ...

any suggestions why it is so problematic ...

personally. i dont think its a z5 plant ... or its a summer heat thing ... or both.. or maybe they just dont like me ...

ken

Comments (19)

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Ken. I fess up -- I really covet this plant and will be trying again this year. As I mentioned in a previous post, I killed my first one last summer. My theory based on very limited experience is that the summer heat and humidity, combined with dry soil, kills firs. My Golden Spreader did fine until August, then browned and died quickly. I probably didn't keep it watered enough. It was planted in partial shade, but in soil that tends to dry and drain quickly.

    The only 2 firs I have had any luck with are a small Abies procera 'Glauca' and a very small Abies koreana
    'Silberlocke' seedling which are planted in a fair amount of shade in cool, moist soil. I bought a 3' Abies koreana 'Silberlocke' and a 3' Abies koreana 'Aurea' in late July, 2007, at a going-out-of-business sale, put them in the same cool shady area, and they died almost immediately. Then I got a concolor last summer, put it in nearly full sun, and it went through the summer fine. A large Canaan Fir in partial shade is struggling. A local collector told me recently she believes the trick to success with firs in our area is fall planting. I'm also thinking that the smaller the better to adjust and establish to the heat and humidity.

    I don't know -- firs are just a mystery to me. If anyone has any suggestions on getting them to live (I don't even care about thriving!) in heat and humidity, I'ld love to hear it.

    Kim

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Ken-

    Well Bob Fincham does not think it is a zone 5 conifer either. He lists it as zone 6.

    I got one from Bob 3-4 years ago and it is still alive- but has hardly grown any. I thought last winter would kill it, but maybe this one will. Summer heat/humidity may be a factor like you said too.

    How bout this weather- Dec 6, already snowed 4-5 times- and geesus it is cold-

    shannon

  • 17 years ago

    hey shannon.. how about single digit wind chills in MI .. in dec .... yikes... what will the REAL winter bring ....

    kim.. i do all kinds of firs in my cold winter.. hot summer local ...

    NOT normandi though .... and there in lies the rub ... so dont over generalized it to all firs... its the second latin name that is the difference .. for me in z5 anyway ...

    ken

  • 17 years ago

    I have Golden Spreader and I have seen Golden Spreaders doing well in Pennsylvania and Ohio. Nordman fir is very tolerant of different soil types and some heat too. The problem with Golden Spreader is the desire to put it in full sun, when it belongs in part shade- especially in winter. It can tolerate zone 5 temps, but not winter sun therefore you have to find a place where the sun angle is not strong in the winter. 2 or 3 hours of winter sun is perfect for it either in the morning or in the afternoon, but not both. I've seen them burn to a crisp in full sun and then it ends up looking sparse and unattractive.

  • 17 years ago

    The weather is really messed up this year. We had a VERY late spring(was snowing here in late April - very unusual for Washington state) and now our fall seems to be extending well into December as well. I have several trees that are just now starting to color over(Sugar maples mostly) and temps each day has generally been around 50 with a few 55's mixed in. I'm already praying for some snow.

    I've had two 'Golden Spreaders' for about 18 months now and it's been doing OK but growing *very* slowly and one I had in 6 or so hours of sunlight was burning some. Moved them both to a shady spot.

    Came up with a cool idea for one too, I've put it almost directly behind the dawn redwood 'Ogon'. Ogon gets bright gold with good sun while it should shade golden spreader from harsh summer rays then when Ogon drops it's needles in winter, 'Golden Spreader' should color nicely in the cool winter air. I'm hoping it works great.

    Will

  • 17 years ago

    Nikki in Toronto expresses my exact thoughts. Same as Will.

    Never grew one myself. Just know about this cultivar.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    Hi Will and Dax. Will, you might not have a problem with burning at all in the Pacific northwest because your temps are so mild without many extemes. Back east is different, but I still don't think zone 5 cold is the problem as much as zone 5 cold accompanied with winter sun- much like some broadleaved evergreens. Here, I wouldn't plant Golden Spreader under anything that is deciduous because it would get more sun in the winter than in the summer which is a no-no with some yellows and variegates. Im always careful to place sun sensitive plants close to another larger evergreen that might screen it in winter.

    This just happens to be one of my favorite plants because its so adaptable (for a fir) to clay soil. I have two Golden Spreaders and have spent a lot of time figguring out this plant and I think I've got it nailed! ;) One is "hidden" next to a 10-12ft Horstmann Silberlocke so that the Silberlocke is to its South therefore blocking any afternoon sun since my lot has a slope facing South. NEVER anyburn. The first one I bought about 10 years ago when I would buy a plant and plop it anywhere expecting it to thrive- Naive, huh? It was placed in full summer sun and strong afternoon winter sun. It was too much for it to take and it burned a bit so I moved it to a lower location, protected by a line of white pine where it still received full summer sun (6 hours) but due to the lower sun angle in winter, only 3 hours of winter sun. Its much better!

    I'm going to give one of them to a friend to start her conifer collection because I've ordered two nice ones in 10 gallons from Iselis for the spring. If you want a large one, which some times helps to start with a larger plant, contact a local nursery that sells iselis plants. I heard they have a lot of interesting stock this year, which I presume is due to collectors not spending with the economy in bad shape in the States.

  • 17 years ago

    Dave -- Thanks for that explanation, which affirms the experiences I have had with all abies (except concolor, which I understand to be more tolerant of heat and humidity). Cool, moist soil (found only in shady areas, at least on our property), and starting out with small plants, seems to be the trick in high heat, high humidity locations. I'm sure our midwestern conditions are similar. Are your new abies from Dax grafted on firma?

    Thanks, Kim

  • 17 years ago

    Sorry -- don't know what the problem is: I've had two Golden Spreaders for a few years now (bought in different years), and haven't had any problems.
    I think one was from Greer's and one from Coenosium.

    As shannon says, they're very slow growing.

    But I put them in spots with little afternoon sun exposure, and they're just fine -- no "burning" or anything.

    I'm quite optimistic about both of them.

    Maybe I'll post a picture or two next year.

  • 17 years ago

    I am located in southern NH - z 5. My first year with Abies n. 'Gold Spreader' I had some tip burn, there after though no tip burn and beautiful color. I give it morning sun and some light filtered sun during the afternoon. Looks great, very little growth and we are going on 4 years now.

  • 17 years ago

    I have a two year graft of A. n. 'Golden Spreader.' I coveted it so much that I took a chance on it in my high heat/high humidity Zone 7A SE U.S. Summers.

    It has remained potted since I received it a year ago and has been kept in the coolest place that I have. I am treating it with kid gloves. For now, it lives.

    The potential good news is that the root stock is A. firma.

    PlantMarker

  • 17 years ago

    Canaan fir understock. That's the ticket as well as firma. Most will use Abies fraseri I believe which is still heat tolerant but not like these.

    Definitely Dave. I'll be doing some grafting this winter. Not a lot though as I need to make money selling annuals and perennials for spring/summer 09. You have a seedling of Abies nordmanniana var. ambrolauri as well.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    Dax..have you considered doing custom grafting?
    You have guaranteed client base on this forum!

    Barbara

  • 17 years ago

    Zone 6 Rhode Island -- Klehm's Song Sparrow Nursery sent me a beautiful specimen early in the Summer -- it had a bit of scorching when it arrived but that cleared up quickly under what are apparently optimal conditions for it here...morning sun, afternoon shade. They do need soem shade. Of course a Rhode Island winter will tell the tale....should I use Wilt Pruf? Or is that primarily for dwarves with juvenile foliage. Klehm's is famous for peonies, but they have some very nice conifers. I can't wait for the 2009 catalog.

  • 17 years ago

    I haven't Barbara, but I could yes. And I do for people right here! :)

    I have a big ideas for my future. I cannot divulge my idea, wish i could... and I'll run a specialty nursery like Bethlehem Nursery, my friend Dennis Dodge.

    Klehm's is one of the best nursery catalogs to obtain for information alone. Save em all folks, they come in handy.

    Dax

  • 17 years ago

    A. fraseri will succumb to the heat and humidity where I live in this cauldron of the Piedmont area of N.C. Interestingly, a forty minute drive will carry you right into the heart of one of N.C.'s largest "industries" - Christmas tree farms. A. fraseri abound over hill and over dale as far as the eye can see. Of course, that forty minute drive takes you a few thousand feet upward in elevation!

    PlantMarker

  • 17 years ago

    Excessive wet does in furs>>>14" in June, low spot down back.

    Have GS about 3-4 years?? Did nothing so moved to the front yard that is about 5-10 degrees cooler in summer, yea we have quite a few micro climes here. Doing much better, probably croak now that I said that:-)

  • 17 years ago

    t h u s i e !

    Hello.

    I must just be luckier than hell in Illinois because we can grow just about anything where I am which is the mississippi river valley - as I've mentioned before here but easy to forget, the mississippi runs east-west here and the only place anywhere it does so. That means nothing probably. There's a reason people stopped here to become farmers. The four seasons are ideal.

    Not to bust on ya'all without 4 very distinct seasons, but we get the entire package from insect kill all the way to rain in all four seasons, in fact, snowfall being counted as rain, we get as much precipitation as Portland, OR.

    Interesting enough.... despite high humidity carrying even into the nightime where it's thick as smoke - there's always usually the rain once or twice every two weeks during all this heat and that really makes the difference. That's why the corn's here and the soy beans... Alright blabbing enough.... but firs grow here. and big-time.

    later,

    Dax