Software
Houzz Logo Print
lavender_lass

Containing bee balm

16 years ago

I would love to put bee balm in my garden, but I don't want it taking over the whole area. I'd like to add some mints too, but same problem. Pots are okay for annuals, but not for perennials with my cold winters. My mom is thinking maybe large coffee cans, with the top and bottom cut out, sunk into the ground around the plant. Has anyone ever tried this idea, or can you recommend any others possibilities?

Comments (24)

  • 16 years ago

    I know bamboo can be contained using 16" deep metal barriers. I would think the metal coffee cans would work until they rust. What about something plastic? Can you use 3gal nursery pots sunk into the soil? Just plant the whole thing?

    What about annual bee balms? Monarda fistula and monarda citrodiora are purple. I don't know of an annual red or pink.

  • 16 years ago

    I just got my copy of Garden Gate and they used a 12" section of 12" diameter PVC pipe, sunk it in the ground about 10" so that only 2" were sticking out. would not have to worry about that rusting...... I would have to paint it tho, not to leave it white!

  • 16 years ago

    PVC piping might work if it went deep enough. I know that I planted clerodendrum bungeii in a pot thinking it would contain it and it is coming up in areas at least 10 to 15 feet away from where it was intially planted.

    Perennial bee balm is a mildew magnet in my area. Perhaps an annual type suggested by Token might be the best way to go. I may have to look into the two purple annual types he mentioned since I have never grown an annual purple variety before.

  • 16 years ago

    I can't give advice on whether the coffee can or another type of container would work, but no matter how you try to contain it, it is still going to increase, which means digging it out to separate it. So one thing to consider is how difficult it will be to dig it out of a bottomless container. I would opt for plastic rather than metal. You don't want to get a cut on your hand from metal that's been sitting degrading in soil. Even if your tetanus shots are up to date, there's lots of nasty bacteria just waiting to infect you.

  • 16 years ago

    I grew citriodora this year. I saved tons of seeds, but they got a bit of mold so I tossed them into the beds. I hope at least a few survived. I bought more from T&M seeds. Bergamo is another one I have seeds for. Got it from valueseeds.com

    Here's the citriodora.

    {{gwi:415393}}

    After I cut it back in early summer, it rebloomed. It got cut back once more in mid summer and bloomed again, although not as well. It never got mildew.

    This was a month after the first hatchet job.

  • 16 years ago

    Mints can be contained in plastic pots with the bottoms cut out. I leave an inch or so above ground, so the 3 gal. black or green pots are perfect. Mint and bee balm tend to be surface, or close-to-the-surface runners, so you need that bit out of ground. They will get pot-bound, but you can just put a spade in beside the pot to leverage it out.

    Tom, that annual bee balm looks good, I may need to try that!!

    Nancy.

  • 16 years ago

    Thanks for the info Token. No mildew is a good thing! ;)

  • 16 years ago

    use a 5inch or 6 inch edger. Often these are in plastic or maybe in aluminum. The plastic I use to edge my lawn. However because these are sold in coils, it`s very hard to straighten out. Aluminum edgers are much more pliant and easy to reshape.

  • 16 years ago

    Thansks for the ideas. PVC pipe sounds interesting, but I think aluminum edger might be easier, especially if you have to divide the bee balm later on.

    I doubt mildew would be a problem here, it's so dry in the summer. I'm in Washington, but unlike Seattle, the east side of the state has hot, dry summers and long, cold winters. The good thing is I haven't had to do anything to my roses. No blackspot, rust, or anything else, just have to water a lot :)

    I really want to try the red bee balm with the purple centers. Mom got some last year and it's pretty, but spreads like crazy. I'm hoping the containment will work, because I'd love to put some in with my roses, herbs and perennials. Also would like to add some mints in the same area, which would be great for tea!

  • 16 years ago

    I am very excited about re-introducing bee balm into my garden this year. All pretty mildew resistant varieties, and I now have lots of space.

    Mint is not contained in bottomless pots in the South. You need to put it in a pot with NO HOLE here and I even put it on risers to keep it away from any soil. I planted it the first year we moved here, in the ground and it took me three years to get rid of it in a contained area (but I didn't just want mint there exclusively). It is a horrible pest in our Holy Comforter gardens and I have to dig at least a foot to get it out.
    For some reason our bee balm doesn't spread much at Holy C.

    WHy not try corrugated metal, that way you could cut it into strips and have it much deeper than 6' metal edging which isn't going to contain it at all. I use the corrugated metal roofing against my fences, down deep into the soil to help contain my neighbors bermuda grass. It works!

  • 16 years ago

    I read recently on another forum here (I think) that someone had used 5 gallon plastic buckets with the bottom cut out to contain mint with success. That would be quite a bit deeper than pots and also durable with no sharp edges. I may try that because I would love to grow chocolate mint again. The mint I planted at my old house has probably spread across two counties by now.

  • 16 years ago

    Mechele- Plastic buckets sound like a good idea. They won't rust and they would be deeper and hopefully keep the roots under control. Two counties (LOL) at least chocolate mint smells good, right? It could be worse. Out here we have wormwood, not so nice :)

    GGG- Metal is a problem with all the snow we have here. With the coffee cans, I was going to have to put some kind of tape around the top to keep them from rusting. Plastic would probably work better. I'm glad you're trying bee balm again!

  • 16 years ago

    I know Bee Balm can become a pest but nothing like mint or bamboo..my advice to anybody NEVER plant mint or bamboo unless you want to live with it for life! It's a good thing the previous owner of our house is already deceased so she can't hear the verbal brutality I have for her. Shame she didn't take her mint with her!

  • 16 years ago

    I never tried it, but with people mentioning coffee cans etc,what about plastic ice cream buckets with the bottom cut off. Or cheap plastic buckets from the dollar store?
    Tammy

  • 16 years ago

    I never tried it with mint. I asked years ago I think and everybody that responded saying a sunk container will not contain mint. I keep my mint and catnip in pots and just store outside during the winter. They come back no problem. I just need to cut back before they set seed.

    As for bee balm, I say just go for it. I put in 4 types last year and if they get out of control I'll just divide and give away.

    Melissa1977

  • 16 years ago

    Thank you for the great responses. I've kind of had a change in garden plans (again) so the few bee balm I try may be easy to contain after all. I put in spearmint this summer (which I love) and planted it between the house and the side walkway. Anything that escapes can just be mowed :) It looks so pretty there and it's also supposed to keep the mice away from the house. Even with the barn kitties, there are a lot of field mice out here in the pastures!

  • 16 years ago

    Ll, what are your new plans? Im curious... isnt it nice to have a little time to change your mind before spring comes?

  • 16 years ago

    Lilyfinch- Merry Christmas Eve!

    My new plan is to postpone the rose garden (at least for a while) and put mostly vegetables in the potager. I already ordered a few roses, which I'm moving into the place I was going to put the bee balm and some herbs. I am thinking about putting in an old-fashioned rose bed in front of the lilac hedge, which would be a great place for the bee balm and some herbs, kind of a potpourri/tea garden, but that's for later this summer or next year...if I have any money left :)

    After talking to my nephew the other day, he really wants a big vegetable/flower garden this year (he's 10) and he can't do one at his house. They have a big dog, who runs all over the back yard and digs everything up, as dogs like to do (LOL) I told him that I was planning to give him a little garden of his own next summer and he said, "You mean for the watermelons?" He really likes watermelons and plans to grow about four next summer. I also need to put some tomatoes in that same garden, since it's against the house and is the only area that stays warm enough at night for those plants to have a chance of ripening with our short summers.

    Anyway, my nephew informed me he also wants to try lots of vegetables, but especially peas (he found out how good they taste last summer eating them right off the vine) and lots of flowers, including nasturtiums and marigolds...and a red rose. Not sure where that came from, but cool!

    So, new plan is to make a vegetable garden with asparagus and strawberries on one side, with a lattice fence and purple raspberries behind it. We also will have two red roses (he can help me pick them out next summer) and some herbs in the back of the garden. Other side and front beds (only 2' deep) will have cherry tomatoes and mini veggies, purple broccoli, bush beans and lots of lettuce and salad stuff. He also wants corn, mini-pumpkins, potatoes and climbing beans. What do you say to that??? A child who wants to grow vegetables and maybe even eat them....I guess roses will have to wait a while :)

  • 16 years ago

    My experience: perennial bee balm, Monarda didyma, spreads fast but is shallow, easily uprooted. I don't worry about it as long as I clean up the bed once per year, and love the scent which helps ID it. Pencil thick roots, slightly pink, a few hair roots? Yup, that's the bee balm!

    For containing stuff like mint... I'm lucky, have a friend who's a mason. The excess flue tiles he cuts to fit a chimney are perfect! They're like bottomless clay pots, only harder.

    Check it out. Flue tiles come in circles and rectangles, and you can cut them to length with a skill saw.

  • 16 years ago

    Couldn't you just plant other plants really close to the bee balm so that the roots don't have much room to spread? Seems to work for plants that aren't nightmarishly aggressive like mint. Bee balm doesn't spread by underground runners or by branches that just touch the ground. It likes to form around it's original planting location in a nice clump. Easily contained by not giving it a lot of space to form a massive clump.

  • 16 years ago

    solana, you are so lucky with the mason friend!!!!The flues can be cut with a skill saw? Any idea if a special blade is needed?

    Martha Stewart Living had an article that set a concrete bottom in a flue to make an instant pot - it was neat and I wanted to do it but the flues were too tall.......

  • 16 years ago

    linda0210, you're right! A diamond blade for the skill saw is best for cutting flue tile, brick, etc. It doesn't have to be the best quality for garden use: the blade I bought for ~$6 10 years ago is still going strong. Do wear eye protection, though, and let everything cool for a few minutes if it gets hot.

  • 16 years ago

    Couldn't you just plant other plants really close to the bee balm so that the roots don't have much room to spread?Seems to work for plants that aren't nightmarishly aggressive like mint.

    Not my experience with mint at all. Down here in the south the stuff spreads like kudzu if left to its own devices!

  • 16 years ago

    I planted bee balm this spring and I can tell you that it spread like wildfire. The root mat right under the mulch is at least 5 feet wide and takes a lot of effort to pull out. I spent fall cleanup tearing it out for more than an hour. For me, it just didn't flower enough and was covered in powdery mildew. I plan to dig it up and give it away in the spring. I may try some of the newer varieties.

Sponsored
Industry Leading General Contractors in Franklin County, Ohio