Software
Houzz Logo Print
tomahawkclaim

Roundup

15 years ago

Rain last week melted all our snow. On Wednesday, Jan 5th, with temps in the 20s I filled my Roundup spray bottle and went into the garden, attacking creeping jennie and wild ivy. I've done this before on warm days in February; in April when I can really get into my gardens, the weeds are just a rotted mat I can rake up. This is the earliest and coldest I've tried to kill perennial weeds. I'll let you know the results. Nance

Comments (14)

  • 15 years ago

    i have the same intentions... for the 8th year in a row ...

    but will probably not get around to it until august...

    lol

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    My Roundup jug says that temps have to be above 50 degrees for it to work, with better results above 60 degrees when the weeds are actively growing. Do they sell different Roundup in colder regions?

    -Babka

  • 15 years ago

    nope...

    generic roundup .. to be effective.. needs to be applied to an ACTIVELY GROWING plant ... it will not work on any type of dormant plant.. so its useless in summer drought.. and winter ...

    BUT .. and there usually is a big but involved ... once applied ... it doesnt simply disappear ... it simply starts working when the plant become active ... as tomahawk notes ... the upside being.. the hosta are dead to the ground.. so spraying is a rather easy thing to do ..

    i am sure the 'sticker' in the solution helps that ...

    its akin to us northern folks.. throwing fertilizer on the last snow of winter [which i dont really advocate when heavy late frost/freeze is a possibility] ... it surely does nothing for dormant plants ... but works its way into the soil.. so its ready to go.. when the SOIL starts warming ... [especially since snow melt is usually about the AIR warming] ...

    make sense babka???

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    I read more of the Round-up info. Rainproof 10 minutes after spraying. So it stays on the leaves and gets absorbed when the weather warms and the weeds begin growing. That is Great! Nance, you have a good plan, indeed.

    It also says that it breaks down when it hits the soil.

    Yes, Ken, now it all makes sense to me. You reminded me of those days way back when I used to sprinkle fertilizer on top of the snow in my vegetable garden in Chicagoland. I had forgotten all about that.

    -Babka

  • 15 years ago

    Be careful. Some on the forum mentioned their hosta sticking their noses out of the ground back in December and if you are one of those folks, then skip the Round-up.

    tj

  • 15 years ago

    I agree that you shouldn't do this if any of your good plants have popped up, but if they haven't, winter dormancy for valuable perennials is a great time to kill perennial weeds because you don't kill the good stuff. I was tempted to do this in Jan because come Feb daffodils are tempted to start emerging and I don't want to kill them. Nance

  • 15 years ago

    someone named dan.. once suggested that the dormant pips are immune to roundup..

    i never tested the theory ...

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    I would be careful using Roundup. I was using it carefully but still ended up killing a large S$S and Azaleas. Who knows what will happen to the Roundup when sprayed months ahead of when to be used by the plant. Can that get washed off by rain and transfered to other plants? I have the crown with pips of a large Elegans now showing after the last rains.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    I would be extremely careful about using Roundup as an over-the-top spray. If there is ANY green at all showing, even at the very base of plants, you can kill or injure desireable perennials. If you want Over-the Top, get that but read the instructions carefully to see what plants are and are not susceptible. Roundup should never be used as a generic, over the top weed killer as what looks dormant may not be under those dead top leaves.

  • 15 years ago

    I was using it carefully but still ended up killing a large S$S and Azaleas.

    ===>>> that is counter intuitive ... how do you carefully spray a 4 foot SS or azalea???

    Can that get washed off by rain and transferred to other plants?

    ==>>> the label says it becomes inert in the soil ...

    but read the instructions carefully to see what plants are and are not susceptible.

    ===>>> ALWAYS.. not just with roundup or its generics which are half the price ...

    Roundup should never be used as a generic

    ===>>> again.. i meant the cheap generic glycophosphate based sprays .. ALWAYS use according to labeled instructions and USES ...

    i have used 1000's of gallons of roundup and its generics in my hosta beds and in my conifer collection .. ACCORDING TO THE LABEL ... and can not assign any losses to it ... when properly applied and used ... other than the targeted weeds ....

    if you spray and cause damage other than what you are aiming at.. then i would propose that it is sprayer misuse.. rather than a roundup issue .... learn to use your sprayer.. before filling it with killer ... practice with water. and learn how to adjust it ... including LOW PRESSURE ... this aint french perfume.. you do not atomize your spray ... large drops .. fall to the ground due to gravity .. they do not drift .... learn how to make large drops from your sprayer ...

    ken

  • 15 years ago

    if you spray and cause damage other than what you are aiming at.. then i would propose that it is sprayer misuse.. rather than a roundup issue .... learn to use your sprayer.. before filling it with killer ... practice with water. and learn how to adjust it ... including LOW PRESSURE ... this aint french perfume.. you do not atomize your spray ... large drops .. fall to the ground due to gravity .. they do not drift .... learn how to make large drops from your sprayer ... >

    The only time I use Roundup in a tank sprayer is if I plan to kill large swaths of grass. I KNOW I cannot be super accurate with the sprayer I have, plus I do not like to carry around such a large sprayer. Last year, I ended up buying a single bottle of the blue Roundup and refilling it as needed with the concentrate. I like that the bottle has a "foam" feature on it where I can see EXACTLY where it's going.

  • 15 years ago

    Roundup is systemic. That means any green growing part it gets on will absorb it into the plant, and therefore into the roots. It can still be washed off before it gets dry if you spray it on the wrong plant and will be rendered inert when it touches the soil.
    Perhaps generic was not the word I should have used, especially since you seem to have glommed on to it, Ken. I should have just said that it is not meant to spray over any plant bed that is assumed to be dormant, because it may not be as dormant as it looks. It can be sprayed on the trunks of trees to kill poison ivy or other invasive vines, without damage to the tree. You can also spray it on dormant bermuda lawns to kill lawn weeds.

    Also, if Roundup is mixed at more than the recommended strength, you will probably get top kill and the leaves will be dead before it can be carried down into the roots, so it will not be effective.

    It does get locked into the soil and remains inert, until it breaks down. If you are spraying weeds in August that are covered with dust, it will lock into the dust and not get to the plants, and won't work.

    I use glyphosate occasionally, but never over any bed of plants, and only on targeted weeds, being very careful not to get it on anything I don't want to kill, shielding it with a piece of cardboard or something to be sure. And you CAN get overspray and drift on a breezy day, if you read the expanded label it specifically warns against that.

    It is also VERY toxic to amphibians, toads, frogs, lizards, etc--the slug fighters in your garden.

  • 15 years ago

    I had the experience with using a pre-mixed bottle of Roundup to kill invasive groundcovers. Azaleas had no low leaves, but have roots just under the soil surface. I killed 2 azaleas, might be by spray drifting onto the stems, or possibly into the roots just under the surface. Therefore, I do not believe it kills only when sprayed on green plant parts. I also used Roundup spray against grass in a driveway crack, and miraculously no grass seedlings will grow there.
    Bernd

  • 15 years ago

    If you must use glyphosate on ground covers under plants, use the mop method. There is a sponge applicator just for that kind of thing, or a towel soaked in it, wrung out (so it doesn't drip) and wrapped around a rake, to drag over the plants you want to kill. No danger of unseen overspray that way. You can also soak a sponge in it, and wipe the targeted weeds with it by hand (be sure and use a chemical-proof glove, it IS after all systemic. And that means you, too.

Sponsored
Whisler Home Improvement
Average rating: 5 out of 5 stars9 Reviews
Franklin County's Committed Home Improvement Professionals