Software
Houzz Logo Print
alexis717_df

Need Help on Deciding

17 years ago

Hello Everyone. Hope you are all staying warm inside, curled up with your catalogs. I know I am. I'm getting ready to place my orders and I would like to know what your experiences have been with these hosta..... good and bad. Out of this group I'm planning to order about a dozen. My soil is loam and I'm going to be planting several beds. Full Sun to Part (1/2 day) Shade/Filtered Shade.. Sorry the list is so long, but you know how it is ;)

Earth Angel

Carnival

Dream Weaver

Frosted Dimples

Sagae

September Sun

Stained Glass

Heatwave

Old Glory

Dancing in the Rain

Sum of All

Cinderella

Fried Green Tomatos

Earth Angel

Alex Summers

Paradigm

Dark Shadows

Rosedale Golden Goose

Rainforest Sunrise

El Capitan

Liberty

Dream Queen

Thanks everyone

Alexis

Comments (16)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Alexis,
    The only one that I have a problem with from your list is "Carnival".
    It looks really great until mid summer then the white in the margin chips away.It is a shame because it is one of my early spring favorites.Could be my fault but I have seen it do this in other gardens as well.JMHO.

    Denny

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Denny,
    Thank you for your response. Too bad, it looks so pretty and was one of my favorites. However, I only ask for advise when I am prepared to take it. So one down, eight or so to go.

    Thank you
    Alexis

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Earth Angel listed twice. Dream Queen and Dream Weaver nearly identical. September Sun/Old Glory/Stained Glass/Paradigm somewhat similar. Perhaps Paradigm the best of those four. Don

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Is anyone really impressed with 'Sum of All'?

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    No, but I really like Sum it Up.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sum of All is a total dog in my garden and I would NEVER recommend it. Dancin in the Rain does do well for me but I have heard a lot of people complain it melts out... I guess it can be a tricky one too. I would scratch Fried Green Tomatoes and Stained Glass and jsut get a Guacamole, but that is me. I have all 3 of them and Guac is my favorite.

    On that list I would never be without:

    Liberty
    Rainforest Sunrise
    Old Glory
    Paradigm
    Alex Summers

    Dark Shadows is on my wish list.....

    Good luck and let us know what you decide

    Alexa

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    My comments

    Earth Angel -- fabulous plant, good grower, can handle some sun
    Carnival
    Dream Weaver -- slow and died in second winter
    Frosted Dimples -- looks great all year round
    Sagae -- this is a classic but if you have to choose, I'd take Liberty over Sagae
    September Sun -- tried this twice, didn't grow for me
    Stained Glass -- got a poor TC of this one so it's not doing well, even after three years
    Heatwave
    Old Glory
    Dancing in the Rain
    Sum of All
    Cinderella
    Fried Green Tomatos -- Nothing quite like the scent of these blooms -- plant it where you can smell it
    Alex Summers
    Paradigm
    Dark Shadows
    Rosedale Golden Goose
    Rainforest Sunrise -- fabulous all round small hosta
    El Capitan
    Liberty -- my personal favourite, does great in sun or shade, in the ground or in a pot
    Dream Queen

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Here's my comments on your list:

    Earth Angel -a must have..Hosta of the Year 2009
    Carnival - nice looking at first but disappointing somewhat.
    Dream Weaver -My top third favorite; go for this one.
    Frosted Dimples -really nice and gets better with time
    Sagae - a must have; vigorous looking... a giant
    September Sun - nice, as alternative, get Inniswood
    Stained Glass - a must have; really distinct
    Heatwave -dont know that one...
    Old Glory -an old soldier...really beautiful and strong
    Dancing in the Rain -beautiful..too bad I lost mine..
    Sum of All - in that family, I would get Sum It Up or..
    Cinderella -young plant for me..so far so good...
    Fried Green Tomatoes - very fast grower...but ordinary...
    Earth Angel -a must have
    Alex Summers -also a must have, a top 10 favorites.
    Paradigm -nice list: that one is a "MUST HAVE"..slug-free.
    Dark Shadows - I'm not excited yet...it takes a long time. Hope it worth the wait...
    Rosedale Golden Goose -nice yellow but many others similar
    Rainforest Sunrise - Oh..that's a must have; best small hosta
    El Capitan -dont have this one
    Liberty -well, you just got my No. 1 hosta. BUY ONE OR 2
    Dream Queen -similar to Dream Weaver which I prefer.

    Papou

    Here is a link that might be useful: Papou's hosta website

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    I wanted to say: "instead of Sum of All, I would get Sum It Up or Parhelion which has the narrow white border.

    Papou

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Alexis,

    A picture of a hosta growing in a similar zone (you are 5b and I am 5a) is worth alot, so I'll try to include a photo if I can.

    Earth Angel - I like it very much


    Carnival - I moved this one to a sunnier location after this photo was taken. I like the way the color changes; here it is on Aug. 7


    Dream Weaver - third year plant..slow growing

    Frosted Dimples - don't have

    Sagae - a must have in any collector's garden. 7 yr. old plant but divided a couple of times...
    May 31

    2 weeks later


    September Sun - growing fast - 2 yr. old plant


    Stained Glass - another must have, great grower. bought in 2005; This is just a "piece" of it I put in a newer bed last year. taken on Aug. 7

    Heatwave - on my list to get this year

    Old Glory - a GREAT hosta - got in 2005...pic taken on Aug. 7

    Dancing in the Rain - slow grower; melts out Pretty in June, though, when this picture was taken. If I had it to do over, however, I would not buy this hosta again.

    Sum of All - I LOVE Sum of All...but it grows HUGE! I purchased it late 2006. Here's a photo from May last year; it got so large I had to move it from this location so my neighbor could mow his lawn. And this is with only 3 eyes!

    Here it is in August after I moved it. The only advice I would offer on this one is that the huge leaves (we are talking platter size here) DEMAND lots, even MORE water than the average large hosta.


    Cinderella - I got this for my granddaughter's fairy tale hosta bed in 2007. It is nice and quickly outgrowing its spot...which means we need to enlarge her bed!

    Fried Green Tomatos - don't have

    Alex Summers - I don't have

    Paradigm - another beauty, wonderful in June but look at the colors in August!


    Dark Shadows - on my wish list

    Rosedale Golden Goose - don't have

    Rainforest Sunrise - I hadn't gotten that excited over it until now (it's second year) and had NO idea why -- look at it; what's not to like?

    El Capitan - don't have

    Liberty - A must have...mine is just a baby

    Dream Queen - slow grower for me - purchased in 2006

    I hope this session of "show & tell" helps, Alexis!

    Char

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    "Liberty" is one of the favorites in our gardens.

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    DREAM WEAVER IS is a sport of 'Great Expectations'

    if you have one.. you dont need the other.. if one failed . the other will ...

    and someone said dream queen is similar ...

    skip them ....

    if anyone says its hard to grow... go with that.. unless you like the challenge ... but dont complain when you fail ...

    if papou ... grows it like a weed.. and its his favorite.. ignore that info ...

    he is a magician ... unless you are of the level of growing that he is.. the other peeps are probably going to be right ...

    lol

    ken

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Papou is so passionate about his plants and I can see that in his descriptions. In addition to his growing talents, he probably has the advantage of a high water table. My gardens are "very" dry and require frequent watering to keep the plants growing.

    You created a great lust, however I do second any of the above noted weaknesses in varieties...except Dream Weaver...slow grower, but a must have!

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Papou has the advantage of being someone who does his best to give hostas a perfect growing environment and he has great success doing so! Nobody's hostas are more beautiful or do better. If Papou can't grow it, nobody can :-)

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Sorry everyone, some thing was wrong with my computer and it had to go get fixed. I didn't want anyone to think I was ungrateful for all the wonderful suggestions.

    Don: I tried responding shortly after you pointed out Earth Angel was listed twice, that's when my computer problems started. I submitted but it never showed up. Oh well. The other Earth Angel was suppose to be Blue Angel.

    Based on everyone's expertise here is the list I've come up with. Let me know what you think. Course there's always room for one... or two...someone please stop me...

    Paradigm
    Liberty
    Rainforest Surprise
    Alex Summers
    Dark Shadows
    Earth Angel
    Sagae
    Inniswood
    Frosted Dimples
    Stained Glass
    El Capitan

    Thank you everyone. Any final thoughts on this list.

    Alexis

  • 17 years ago
    last modified: 11 years ago

    Placing my orders on Monday. Wish me luck and once again Thank you.

    Alexis