Software
Houzz Logo Print
jcpyburn

Yellow tomato recipes

17 years ago

Hi,

I am currently being blessed with an overabundance of yellow roma style tomatoes and my freezer is already packed full of this years harvest. I am planning on making the yellow tomato chutney and the honeyed yellow tomato butter from the Ball book, but I think I am going to need more recipes for them. I did a search but pretty much only came up with red tomato recipes.

Does anyone have any recipes for yellow tomatoes specifically or can I use yellow tomatoes in recipes that call for red?

If so how will that affect the flavor of the finished product being that the yellow tomatoes are much sweeter and milder than red?

and finally, what about acidity levels. Is there enough difference in the acidity between red and yellow that I need to add extra acid or anything?

Any recipes you could post for me would be great or ideas for recipes that call for red but would be good with yellow too.

Carly

Comments (27)

  • 17 years ago

    HArd to know about flavor on yellows. Close your eyes and taste both a red and a yellow in a blind test and see if you notice any difference in taste. Yellow tomatoes may need a bit more acid added to safely can, I grew yellow and white cherry tomatoes one year and most of them split while ripening. I wasn't able to notice mush difference in taste, expept the yellows and whites were a little milder. You can subsitiute any tomato type, provided you add the necessary acid. To make a yellow salsa, use all yellow ingredients like yellow hot peppers and such. Acid levels of ALL tomatoes, including different color ones will vary. Even for that, a single tomto type can have very differnet acid levels when grown in different soils and weather conditions.

  • 17 years ago

    Added to any "red" tomato recipe they really perk it up in appearance. Yellow tomatoes added to salsa make it very attractive for gifts. You can also make a sweet yellow tomato sauce (just use the red tomato sauce recipe) with a bit of added sugar or some finely grated carrot.

    Dave

  • 17 years ago

    Go ahead and use any tomato recipe.

    There's no general difference in acidity between reds and yellows. (There are small differences from variety to variety, but they aren't particularly linked to colour.)

    The flavour also depends on the specific variety. I find many yellows have a hint of a "citrus" taste, and many are a bit sweeter, but that's only a very general impression. Some yellows are complex and deeply flavoured, others very sweet, etc., just as some reds are.

    When I have a lot of tomatoes of different kinds, I like to separate out the yellows and can them separately --- a plain yellow sauce, not cooked too long, is a beautiful thing, and tasty, too!

    If you have meaty roma varieties in yellow (is it Yellow Bell?), you should be able to get a pretty thick sauce without overcooking (the longer you cook, the darker it gets in colour), ending up with a gorgeous, yellow sauce --- it makes a gorgeous pizza. Impress your friends! Also a lovely pasta dish with a little green herb sprinkled on top.

    And a fantastic tomato soup can also be made from the yellow sauce. Make a plain white sauce (flour and butter, maybe a bit of garlic), then add the tomato sauce and season to taste. Throw in some tortellini to make it more hearty!

    Enjoy. I LOVE yellow tomatoes!!!!

    Zabby

  • 17 years ago

    As Zabby said, any difference in acidity is due to growing conditions and/or the varietal but as a whole yellow tomatoes are no more or less acid than red ones. They can be interchanged in any current reliable canning recipe.

    There's a perception of lower acidity with some yellow varieties but it's due to a higher level of sugar.

    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    How about giving credit where credit is due. Zappy mentioned nothing about growing conditions. I DID!! Unless your ignoring my posts again.

  • 17 years ago

    ksrogers - I have eaten many straight off the vine (*grin*) and they are very mild and sweeter than most reds. Wonderful flavor! A yellow salsa sounds very interesting!

    Dave - a yellow tomato sauce is a great idea too! so simple I never would have thought of it! (smacking myself on forehead!) I love, love, love the flavor of these tomatoes and I think that the sauce sounds fabulous!

    Carol - I guess that is what I thought too! LOL! it is good to know that they are interchangeable!

    Zabby - I am not sure of the variety. The nursery where I bought the plant said that it was Jubilee but these yellows look exactly like romas except golden yellow. I think they got the seeds mixed up or something. They are very meaty and very prolific. I am planning on trying to save some seeds so I can grow them next year. I think I will make some of that tomato soup tomorrow! Sounds wonderful for the kind of weather we are having this week! (Cooler weather thank goodness, I was sick of the 100 degree days!)

    Thanks to everyone for all of the help and info!!

    Carly

  • 17 years ago

    Ken, my failure to give you separate credit for mentioning soil was not deliberate, though you clearly think so. It was an error. People make them.

    And speaking of errors, it's Zabby, not Zappy.

    Carol

  • 17 years ago

    Goodness, Ken. Let's keep Carly's thread civil, please! I wouldn't dream of taking credit for something you said, and I'm sure Carol didn't mean to give it to me. I'm an editor and if nobody ever made an error I'd have no income and couldn't afford to buy tomato seeds at all.

    And of course I agree, though I didn't happen to mention it in this particular post --- probably a subconscious effort to avoid thinking about the trauma of this year's growing conditions --- and I do think the specific variety is the main factor in tomato taste. Even the time of harvesting has an effect; the first, mid-season, and last tomatoes picked from the same plant can have noticeably different tastes in my experience.

    Carly, good luck! Any chance you would share a few of those seeds? If so, send me an e-mail. I can trade if you like.

    I've got three nice meaty yellows this year, but none that sounds like your description. Mine are Yellow Bell, which is very "blocky" with four distinct lobes; the most productive of the three, though not as much this year as usually; Amish Yellow, which is ovalish with a bit of a pointed tip --- much like Amish paste, though on the small side (though everything is this year); and Plum Lemon, which is well named --- it is the size of a plum and has a very pronounced pointy tip; least productive but very cute.

    Z

  • 17 years ago

    Zabby,

    I would be glad to trade seeds with you! You wouldn't happen to have yellow pear tomato seeds would you? I love those and was going to get some seeds later this year. Could you give me any tips on saving the seeds? I have saved from other things but never tomatoes and I want to make sure I get good, viable seeds!

    Carly

  • 17 years ago

    Carly,

    The link below may be helpful.

    Bill

    Here is a link that might be useful: Saving Tomato Seed

  • 17 years ago

    Bill,

    Thanks for the link! It was most helpful!!

    Carly

  • 17 years ago

    Carly,

    Yellow tomato sauce for White Chili and yellow tomato juice for Blondie Mary's. I make both sauce and juice every year. Yum!

    Kim

  • 17 years ago

    One of the strongest flavored tomatoes I've grown is Aunt Gertie's Gold. We've made an exceptional tomato jam with this, and a pizza sauce as well.

    But thats one distinctly flavored yellow tomato.

  • 17 years ago

    I concur with what others have said. I made two batches of the same sauce recipe (below, if anyone is interested)-- one batch with yellow tomatoes and one with red. I measured the pH, because I was canning, and the yellow sauce was actually slightly more acidic. I thought the flavor was excellent without any adjustment, but if the finished sauce tastes too sweet to you, you could add a bit of lemon juice, ascorbic acid, or vinegar.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Tomato sauce

  • 17 years ago

    Jessica - The tomato sauce you linked to does sound good. But it is important to note that it is a cooking recipe not a canning recipe. It contains too much oil to be safely canned per the current guidelines.

    Tested and approved canning recipes for tomato sauce are available in the BBB and at NCHFP.

    Dave

    Here is a link that might be useful: NCHFP - Canning Tomatoes recipes

  • 17 years ago

    Sorry, didn't read the original post carefully. To can, cut down the oil (I used a couple tablespoons for a giant pot of sauce) and add acid if not using a pressure canner.

  • 17 years ago

    Plum lemon tomatoes sound wonderful. Never heard of those before. I will have to do a websearch for them.
    You will still need to add bottled lemon juice or citric acid to most tomato sauces even in a pressure canner. That isn't just for using a boiling water bath canner in many cases.
    I agree, that sauce is a cooking recipe, not a canning recipe.
    The NCHFP and the Ball Blue Book are the most reliable sources for home food preserving, I agree, Dave. Good suggestions for finding recipes and methods.

  • 17 years ago

    Linda Lou,

    Here's a photo of plum lemon tomatoes. (Though I wouldn't recommend ordering from this company, personally.) If you would like, I'd be happyt to send you some seeds --- drop me an e-mail.

    Zabby

    Here is a link that might be useful: Plum Lemon Tomato Photo

  • 17 years ago

    Are the mini yellow bell style tomatoes easier to grow from seed than mini red tomatoes? Are the an heirloom type?

  • 17 years ago

    keepitlow,

    There are many varieties of both red and yellow small tomato. I haven't found one colour easier or harder to grow from seed than another. The one main difference I have noted is that most modern hybrids that you find seedlings of regularly at garden centres, and the seeds in the mainstream catalogues etc. are heavy yielders, and most are early-ripening varieties, since that's what modern backyard gardeners are mostly looking for: lots of tomatoes, as soon as possible!

    Whereas there is a wide range of characteristics among all the varieties you can choose from if you grow from seed --- the famous Brandywine, for instance, matures late and doesn't yield that well, but many people love the taste enough to grow it even if they only get a few tomatoes, fairly late in the season.

    But there are plenty of open-pollenated (meaning not hybrids, i.e., their seed will breed true) and heirloom (generally defined as OP tomatoes and at least 50 [some say 75] years old) varieties that yield well, in red, yellow, and even pink, purple, brown, orange.... (I have never seen a blue tomato!).

    Some grow well in one climate but not in another. Did you try growing a small red heirloom and not have it do well? You might try a couple other types and see what works in you area!

    Good luck,
    Zabby

  • 17 years ago

    Some cherry types split. Most of mine all split and are not useful. I wasn't even planning on grwoing any cherry types and the seeds I started were all supposed to be a grape type tomato. They look more like miniature plum tomatoes, but even a few of them split as well. Right now, there are, more split rotten ones on the ground instead of on the plants. The sources for yelow cherrry toms include: Heirlooms of snowberry. lemon drop, gold nugget, yellow tumbling tom and hybrids of sun sugar, jenny, golden rave from the following source:
    http://www.totallytomato.com/sp.asp?c=9

    Here is a link that might be useful: Yellow toms of all sizes

  • 17 years ago

    Thanks for the link and replies. Had no idea so many yellow toms were available.

    This was what I was referring to.

    http://www.tradewindsfruit.com/vegetables/yellow_pear_tomato.jpg

    Saw one seller at a farmers market that had some and forgot to ask him about them. Never saw them before.

    As far as my toms? I planted some from plants from Lowes. The red cherries were sold by the single plant and expensive. The other big toms were sold in a 9 pack and all 9 plants were less than the one cherry tom.

    My toms did OK this year. Lots of cracks and disease, but had way more than we could use. Would like some disease resistant toms, that grow easy and was wondering about the yellow toms, especially cherry size.

  • 17 years ago

    Buying tomato plants are always risky as they are not marked very well. Most are forced grown and can go into shock once transplanted. There are also some white tomatoes, but their color is a very light yellow. The sites mentioned also have chocolate cherry toms which are very deep red. Some regular types are even purple color, or look green. I buy seeds and grow my own for use in making sauce. Mine are started indoors about mid April and by the end of May are well on their way to starting to bud out when they get transplanted outside. Some years, I will start over 200 plants. Same with sweet peppers. To reduce disease issues, never plant tomatoes in the same place year after year. The soil does get contaminated with blights and fungal infections. I would wait at least 4-5 years before reusing a specific location in the garden, same with peppers. No matter how disease resistant they may be, blight and septoria leaf spot can kill them quickly. The last time I bought a store bought plant in a large pot, it lasted 3 weeks and died.

  • 17 years ago

    keepitlow,

    Yellow Pear is indeed an heirloom---it's been around over a hundred years. Red Pear, too. (Did you know tomatoes used to be grown as ornamental plants? People thought the fruit was poinsonous!)

    Both are easy to grow and yield a lot of small tomatoes. I have to say I don't find either of them very tasty, compared to many other cherry types. But hey, any tomato fresh from the garden is pretty darned good!

    Most kinds are pretty easy to grow. If you are having lots of disease problems you might ask for help on the tomato forum --- you could be able to improve your chances by changing some of the conditions (enough sun, right amount of water, good soil, etc.). Lots of knowledgeable and experienced growers over there.

    Good luck,

    Zabby

  • 17 years ago

    I have a tasty yellow tomato jam recipe for a lemon jam. It uses yellow tomato pulp, lemon juice and pectin and a little other stuff. I'm having computer troubles, but I can try and post the recipe if you are interested. It is very good. Back when I first made the jam, my little sister tried some and liked it a lot. She asked for seconds, even after she was told it was tomato jam. Now I try to get some yellow tomatoes every year so she can have this jam.

  • 17 years ago

    Yes I would be very interested in a recipe for yellow tomato jam. Sounds very good. I was wanting to make some tomato jam this year anyways cause my oldest daughter likes it and I do too.

    TIA

    Carly

  • 17 years ago

    Here is a great yellow cherry tomato suitable for a jelly.

    Here is a link that might be useful: Sunsugar Hybrid