Software
Houzz Logo Print
jlacy1010

How can I decorate my mantle?

14 years ago
My home is on the South Carolina coast. The mantle is 4 feet long. Any suggestions are welcome!

Comments (76)

  • 14 years ago
    I'd definately go for thicker candle shape. I actually think two thick candle sticks would look a little better than the ones in (not sure what you call them) holders. The fire space is chunky, the chimney breast is quite chunky and the shelf is quite chunky. You don't want the candles to be narrow and weedy
  • 14 years ago
    I think the mantle height could look fabulous using proportion. what about some very large standing candle holders on the hearth or tall pottery and a mirror or artwork leaning on mantle?
  • 14 years ago
    You have a rugged rock fireplace with a small mantle & delicate pieces. I would lower the current mantle, and if possible, add another layer of wood to make it thicker. Add one large accessory off to one side. Let the rock speaker itself.
  • 14 years ago
    I would (take down the wreath) look for the longest, carved and white-washed wood FISH and showcase it on the mantle with possibly light colored fishing lanterns hung above on each side.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I'd say pop the TV over the fireplace.
  • 14 years ago
    You're in a great area with all those antique shops. Look for those special and different items that you can add vs. candles and knick knacks and make them larger items that will stand out and show up in that large space. You can have fun adding unique, different and rustic items that I know you'll be able to locate in NC. Good luck!
  • 14 years ago
    What's bothering me is that rustic stone fireplaces aren't considered SC coastal, (I'm SC Low Country) unless you were going for a rustic farmhouse look. My solution would to built out or remove the stone and build a classic fireplace surround .( I can here the howls now!) The beautiful crown moulding you have is coastal! You have plenty of inspirations in Georgeton, Charleston, or Savannah. Take tours, buy local design magaInes & books. If you don't want to be that authentic, I agree with every one who suggested built ins on each side, lowering the mantel, & replacing it with one with better proportions.
  • 14 years ago
    I agree with Poshhaus. The tv is a distraction where it is. Why not put it up.
  • 14 years ago
    Beautiful fireplace, but I'm inclined to agree that the mantel, both on scale and placement, is more of a distraction. Painting it a more gray tone, to match the stones would be the Q&E way to go. Otherwise, if you can have a cornice box built to cover it ... here is a a rough image of what that might look like. Something drift woody/rustic?

    Also agree that matching or built-in side storage for desk and TV would be nicer. I like the cabinetry of the desk and would just try to match that in a TV storage unit.

    As far a "decor" goes, I can see you have a lovely ship and print on the desk. Stay with the nautical coastal theme. I found these hurricane styled candles in a round and pillared style which I liked, plus a nice nautilus shell, and Glassquirks at Etsy makes the most beautiful stained glass sailboats. I chose a blue one, to bring out the blue tones in the fireplace (the cabinetry already brings out the browner tones of the gray) and a tall blue ceramic for the hearth. I think a basket to fill the "hole" in the fireplace makes a nice solution (and extra storage should you need it) Maybe fill it with kindling? I don't know that you need all or even any of these, but hope it gives you some ideas.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I would do a clean lined mirror to go w your crown.....nothing else you have a ton going on next to it....just place it on mantel
  • 14 years ago
    Drop the mantle shelf down to the 3rd course of stone above the lintel, change it to something a little wider with brackets if you like them positioned to line up midway either side of the fireplace.Colour the mantle to blend with the floor and furniture that reddish pine is at odds with everything else.
    Above the mantle a tall mirror with a frame of something like limed oak just a little over half as wide as the whole chimney breast.
    As it is everything is out of balance,
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I think all of the comments are so helpful.... I cannot wait to seek help soon. I like the two photos attached here that make the fireplace take center stage and both are so low country perfect...
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    I think all of the comments are so helpful.... I cannot wait to seek help soon. I like the two photos attached here that make the fireplace take center stage and both are so low country perfect...
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Although I agree that 1/3 proportions work well in most places, it does not work with mantel heights, which would put a mantel shelf at only 32" high in a room with an 8' ceiling. Typical mantel height is 52" -54" off of the hearth, regardless of ceiling height, because of how it works visually - putting decorations right at eye level. Anything lower or higher tends to look odd to our eyes, unless the overall design of the room breaks out of the mold and embraces different-than-typical proportions.
  • 14 years ago
    I concur with many suggestions above. Consider a drier, driftwood grey stain on the mantle. Give some breathing room to the stone fireplace. ( move TV and computer desk. I vote no on mantle TV .) Try a local artist on the mantle... no need to hang, low and panoramic vs square maybe just lean it to bring the focal point down.. consider tying in the flanking wall color with the greys in the stonework.
    An armchair to the right or left of the fireplace and a hooked rug with some color would cozy up the feel (and weight the floor visually with rich color). An antique shore bird decoy might complement either low on the hearth (bigger) or on the mantle (tall and thin) like a heron or egret. Can't tell how close the sofa is, if you have room swing it 90 degrees to catch the window and hearth view with armchair on the window side of the fireplace.
  • 14 years ago
    A bit off topic: You know, the lovely photos of room/fireplaces above ... of course, no TV in sight. I really enjoy TV, but I'm beginning to think no room but a media room seems to accommodate those big (and bigger) black squares, especially if you intend to actually watch it.
  • 14 years ago
    Coast road is right about mantel height! I shouldn't send opinions before drinking coffee in the morning!
  • 14 years ago
    Here's another idea.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Hi jlacy, wow, so much good input, we all love a mantle! I just have to chime in :-) I would suggest layering the great mantle you have. In this photo, note the contrasting layers on and in front of the mantle. I think the sail boat on the left of your photo would be a nice focal point on your mantle. If you can visually open/simplify to the right and left of the fireplace it would really support it being the strong attention-getter.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Click on the above photo to see better.
  • 14 years ago
    I have learned so much from this discussion! Lessismore has the exact idea I would do. Stain the mantle to a less bold color and make it pop with tall and strong "knickknacks". I would place metal sculpture focal point (keeping with nautical it could be a sunburst or a sailboat) under the mantle and above the fireplace hole. This would draw the eye away from the too high mantle and keep the firplace a focal point. I definitely would not place the tv above the mantle, too high and then the tv becomes the focal point and not the great fireplace. Built ins would be fantastic next to the fireplace for the computer and the tv.
  • 14 years ago
    My photo comp w/my orginal post got deleted, so I'm reposting, with the comparison of a round mirror vs. a rectangle.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    What about a large model sail boat or schooner. Keep it simple but elegant. You've got great rustic decor but the tv is a huge distraction. A cabinet with doors to hide clutter of components would be nice. Then look for a firescreen that brightens the hearth like a handpainted nautical picture. I don't think structural changes would be necessary just tweek what you have. Great crown moulding and bones and your ceiling fan is great! You might want to change out the blinds for built in plantation shutters at some time in crisp white to match the moulding.
  • 14 years ago
    The mantle is too short, too high up, too light in color and, strangely, too heavy looking for the beautiful but narrow stonework. I'd eliminate the mantle and replace it with a piece of colorful artwork that is fairly tall and relatively narrow. Perhaps 3' to 3.5' wide and 5' or so high. This should cover any damage to the stone that was done in hanging the mantle and result in a striking stone faced fireplace that will, then become, "the focal point of the room."
  • 14 years ago
    I think joehamilton may be on to something. Here's a woodland scene superimposed onto your fireplace. Probably not your choice in artwork and should be a bit more narrow, but I think it helps to see a visual.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Doesn't the piece make the fireplace seem top heavy? The piece is so much larger than the insert hole. I think that the idea is great, but I think that the piece needs to be proportioned to the insert size to not feel as though it is taking over the space and the fireplace. Also, if the television is staying in it's current position, the piece seems to compete with the television. I really feel that my original thought in built-ins flanking the fireplace would be the best alternative. Once there is some more wood detail, the mantel would not feel so out of place. Also, the corbals on the mantel could be removed and columns to the hearth could be added too.
    Cheers!
    m.
  • 14 years ago
    Joehamilton- not SC Coastal!
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Probably not the best choice to frame the photo but I was trying to cover up the candle holders and used a program that has nothing to do with design, just to see how one piece of artwork would look. I agree that it should be only as wide as the mouth. Steal a piece of artwork from another place in the house, get a roll of butcher paper and cut and hang it, or see if a friend has something that might work in order to get an idea. I think it'd be worth a try and a more cost-effective solution in the near-term.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Here are a few art recommendations. Everything on the site comes in a range of sizes and materials, custom framed or just the print...

    Let us know if any of these catch your eye. Enjoy!

    http://www.committedphotography.ca/photos/details/2614
    http://www.committedphotography.ca/photos/details/368
    http://www.committedphotography.ca/photos/details/1969
  • 14 years ago
    Cool photos, but not relevant for SC coast. No rocks, just wide white sandy beaches & dunes.
  • 14 years ago
    last modified: 14 years ago
    Way back up there, I suggested a larger, freestanding fireplace screen to disguise or camouflage the actual size of the comparatively small firebox. Found a nice assortment of screens here that have a pretty wide range of styles and prices. Many of them have multiple sizes available. If you could find one that is 4 feet wide like your mantle, and as tall as possible (within reason) it might make that pretty fireplace look a bit more balanced. It's a place to start -

    http://www.plowhearth.com/fireplace-screens/category_s2011_d4000_c1027_all.html?sortby=price1
  • 14 years ago
    Wow, all you asked was decorating ideas for the mantel! Great ideas for sure. Well, my two cents is to work with what you have. I was thinking of a wonderfully shaped antique clock that blends with you mantel that looks like a "one piece" art above the FP. But, I came across this from houzz and it looks pretty cool.
    Wendi Young Design · More Info
  • 14 years ago
    If you decide to do photos over the fireplace or even a collection of photos and want some from SC, go to The Market. There are several vendors that have framed and unframed from Rainbow Row to Folly Beach. Would love to have one myself of Bull Island. Or take some yourself. Georgetown has some beautiful scenes and you can have them blown up to fit your mantle.
  • 14 years ago
    Yes, cressor! Much more appropriate . Galleries with local artists are abundant in the area.
  • 14 years ago
    Sheryl, absolutely. Gorgeous photo or painting from a local artist and a sweetgrass basket! There are so many sizes and shapes to choose from in those. Love the lowcountry!
  • 14 years ago
    Not perfect, but here are a few more ideas using a local photo.
  • 14 years ago
    little miss k - So are you suggesting that they just "saw off" the existing mantle, replace with a better fit at a better height (I like the lower left best) and cover whatever damage with a big print/photo?
    On photo vs. painting/print - Of course, if they find/or take a photo image they love, they could always have that done up in as a canvas. An actual photo would/could (should imo) have a matting and such - so it is less like a poster and more like "art." :-)
  • 14 years ago
    Sawing it off isn't a bad idea. Can't be that difficult to fill and paint over a couple of holes.
  • 14 years ago
    Hey lessismoore! I'd find a local craftsman who knows what they're doing, but yes, I'd get rid of the current mantle. It's not well placed. Get an excellent, qualified craftsman who has been in the industry for a long while and I would bet they could repair any damage so that you couldn't even tell, for a price of course. My wood guy is excellent; an old Scot who lives & breathes wood, and he could do it, but I'm on the opposite coast. As far as the photo, I wasn't trying to show a finished piece of art, simply attempting o show how a large photo (or piece of art) might generally look, plus a new mantle better placed. I lost my design software in a move. I simply used MS Powerpoint to do this for a look/see and it only does so much. :o)
  • 14 years ago
    Hey littlemissk - you did a great job with just power point. And I agree with suggested mantle replacement if at all possible. :-)
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    Is jlacy1010 still here? : )
  • 14 years ago
    Well, that were a Christmas wreath above the mantle, weren't it?
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    P.S. "sawing it off" is a bad idea, but there are professional fireplace people in the area *ahem* that can handle such a task so that everything looks as it should, if such radical solution is desired.
  • 14 years ago
    If you live on the coast, perhaps you could find filler for the fireplace on the beach? Driftwood, shells loose or in big glass vases, sand? The mantelpiece is off size, but take the simplest path: just cover it up and see if that satisfies. If not, then think about more radical and less undo-able changes.

    And, so what if the stone isn't in the regional idiom? As long as the house is consistent with itself, this is America, where people in California build English manors, and people in North Carolina copy French chateaux (you know what I mean), and every state in the nation is dotted with Cape Cod cuties and Williamsburg reproductions.

    Built-ins are never a bad idea (say I, whose house has no closets), but matching movables will do if that fits your budget better. Ballard Designs and Pottery Barn and the like can fix you up. Or get approximate matching used pieces and paint them the same color.

    As for what to put on the mantelpiece, just clear it off completely and let it talk to you a while.

    Take your time.
  • 14 years ago
    Just to redeem myself, when I said "saw it off", I did not mean DIY!
  • 14 years ago
    pcmom1 LOL But, honey, you can do anything with a Sawzall!
  • 14 years ago
    OMG...a mantle discussion with 74 entries, must be so many gorgeous ideas...no! It's companies blatently promoting themselves, it's supposed designers picking on people, it's revising somebody's entire space. I imagine the initial poster dropped out a while back.
  • 14 years ago
    I suggest you decorate your mantle with things that you love, but keep it simple. Fight the urge to balance items evenly on both sides.
  • PRO
    14 years ago
    You can find early sailing ships' models and civil war ships' models that are beautiful displayed on a mantle or on top of an armoire